Keep up with essential planning news and commentary, delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.
Means-Based, Transit-Fare Discounts Take a Leap Forward in the Big Apple
"Mayor Bill de Blasio and Corey Johnson, the City Council speaker, shook hands Monday on a $89.2 billion city budget that included a major concession by the mayor to provide funding for discounted subway and bus fares for some of the poorest New Yorkers," report William Neuman and J. David Goodman for The New York Times on June 11. The current fare for an adult is $2.75 per ride. A monthly MetroCard, enabling unlimited rides, costs $121.
The program will begin in January, with New Yorkers whose income is below the federal poverty line — about $25,000 a year for a family of four [and $12,140 for an individual]. It is estimated that about 800,000 people could be eligible for the subsidy, although far fewer are expected to enroll in the first year.
While the 50 percent discount is high compared to some other means-based, transit discount programs, restricting income to below the federal poverty level eliminates many working poor from eligibility. See programs in Bay Area and Seattle described below for comparison.
The discount is the same as those received by seniors and the disabled. The big difference, though, is that New York City, as opposed to the New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority, will pay the subsidy, which amounts to $106 million for the first six months, "with further financing to come in future budgets," add Neuman and Goodman." The budget also includes "$254 million more for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, called for by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and initially resisted by the mayor."
The program, known as “Fair Fares," was backed by the City Council and surprisingly resisted the progressive mayor.
"I don’t understand how you can justify subsidizing $6.60 for every ferry ride, but not helping people who live in poverty get on the train,” Council Speaker Johnson told the mayor’s budget director at a recent hearing, reported Emma G. Fitzsimmons and J. David Goodman on May 11.
"From its inception, the effort to establish half-priced transit fares for the city’s working poor was conceived by Community Service Society," a New York City non-profit group advocating for low-income residents since 1939, "as an anti-poverty initiative," states the lengthy June 12 press release. The proposal was strongly backed by the Riders Alliance.
Other low-income fare subsidy programs
King County Metro Transit in the Seattle area began a program to subsidize transit fare for low-income residents, beginning in 2015. Sound Transit and the Seattle Streetcar also accept the discounted fares, known as ORCA LIFT. The program provides half-price discounts for a much greater percentage of low-income people than Fair Fares, up to double the federal poverty level. A King County individual with an income up to $24,276 qualifies, compared to a New Yorker making half that amount.
Kirk Johnson reported on the program for The New York Times in February 2015. Planetizen's Philip Rojc posted in May 2015 that Seattle joined "Chicago, Cincinnati, Denver, and Kansas City" in offering the low-income discounted fares. Planetizen contributing editor Elana Eden posted on the expansion of the program in December 2016.
In April, the Toronto Transit Commission began their Fair Pass program, a "Transit Fare Equity Program for low-income Torontonians" [pdf]. The monthly discount is 21 percent and the single-ride discount is 33 percent.
Finally, an April post by Planetizen managing editor James Brasuell indicates that "four of the [Bay Area's] largest transit agencies and the Metropolitan Transportation Commission [MTC] are proposing a 20 percent discount to low-income riders." Like the King County program, it would be eligible for those earning up to double the federal poverty level.
"The initial idea was to cut fares by 50 percent," reported Michael Cabanatuan for the San Francisco Chronicle on April 10.
While most of the region’s two dozen transit agencies expressed interest, many were afraid that they’d lose too much money. So the [MTC] focused the plan on the six largest transit agencies and reduced the proposed discount to 20 percent.
Julie Teglovic reports "the Commission voted [on May 23] to approve a revised program framework for a Regional Means-Based Fare Program for four large Bay Area transit operators — BART, Caltrain, Golden Gate Transit and SFMTA — during a pilot period."
- New York
- Government / Politics
- Social / Demographics
- Fair Fares NYC
- New York City
- Bay Area
- King County
- City Budgets
- Discounted Transit Fares
- Fair Fares
- Federal Poverty Line
- Free Transit
- Low Income Fares
- New York City Transit
- ORCA Transit Pass
- Poverty Line
- Transit Fares
- Transit Subsidies
- Community Service Society of New York
- King County Metro Transit
- New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority
- Metropolitan Transportation Commission
- New York City Council
- Riders Alliance
- Toronto Transit Commission
- Mayor Bill de Blasio
- Michael Cabanatuan
- Emma G. Fitzsimmons
- David Goodman
- Corey Johnson
- Kirk Johnson
- William Neuman