Will Manhattan's "Central Business District Tolling" Clear the Way for More Congestion Pricing?

Cordon pricing applied to Manhattan's Central Business District, approved by the state legislature on March 31 and signed into law by Gov. Andrew Cuomo on April 1, has the ability to be a game changer for other cities considering similar programs.

April 8, 2019, 6:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Sofiaworld / Shutterstock

"Congestion Pricing Marks the End of an Era," posted by James Brasuell on Friday, refers to the landmark passage of the Central Business District Tolling Program in the state budget bill on March 31.

According to Emily Badger, the idea of charging drivers to enter parts of Manhattan, also known as Cordon Pricing, could enact a generational shift in the conventional thinking about transportation.

Badger's colleague, Winnie Hu, New York Metro desk reporter for The New York Times who focuses on transportation and infrastructure, agrees.

"[T]he rest of the country is far more likely to seriously consider embracing such a policy — even though it was once considered politically toxic, according to municipal officials and transportation analysts," writes Hu on April 1 (source article).

“New York’s use of congestion pricing could be a game-changer,” said Travis Brouwer, an assistant transportation director in Oregon, which has considered congestion pricing for traffic-jammed Portland.

“If New York City can prove that congestion pricing can work and gain public acceptance, it could give cities like Portland a boost as we look to introduce pricing.”

Down the Acela corridor, Philadelphia is watching. “It makes a difference,” Christopher Puchalsky, director of policy and strategic initiatives for the city’s transportation office, told Jason Laughlin, The Inquirer's transportation reporter, on April 2. “We always try to keep an eye out for best practices and see if we can make it work in Philadelphia also.”

New York City’s experiment with congestion pricing will provide valuable data for Philadelphia, Puchalsky said Tuesday, but ... Philadelphia has no policy proposal for congestion pricing, and Puchalsky has said in previous interviews that it would likely take hundreds of thousands of dollars to study how to do it right before attempting it. 

Up the Acela corridor, transit advocates in Boston are pushing the mayor and governor to consider congestion pricing.

On the West Coast, in addition to Portland, Seattle, San Francisco, and Los Angeles all have actual plans or studies, unlike Philadelphia or Boston, to enact cordon pricing. However, their outcomes are uncertain. All the more reason to see what happens in Manhattan below 60th Street, the northern edge of the Central Business District toll cordon, after the pricing program begins in 2021.

"Congestion pricing’s moment follows decades of failed efforts to unclog roads around the country," adds Hu.

Historically, cities responded to congestion by building more roads or widening existing ones — only to find that those, too, became jammed, said Matthew Turner, an economics professor at Brown University.

Listen to Turner speak with Meghan McCarty Carino of KPCC (Southern California Public Radio) in 2017 about the Southern California Association of Governments' consideration of congestion pricing in Los Angeles (posted here).

But congestion pricing is not just about reducing traffic congestion.

“As we build a city of the future, we must reduce our reliance on cars,” Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan tells Hu. “My goal is to make our downtown core a healthier place for all with fewer cars, a more equitable transportation system and less climate pollution.”

Formidable challenges to adopting cordon pricing

“Social equity was the conversation stopper when it came to congestion pricing,” Stuart Cohen, the founding director of Oakland-based TransForm, told Hu. “In West Coast cities, equity is very high on the political agenda.”

While imposing tolls on drivers brings up issues of equity, Joe Cortright of City Observatory reminds us that equity is a concern with all transportation funding options. 

Fortunately, Cohen's group and the NRDC published a report to deal with this set of challenges. See Todd Litman's post, "Road Pricing Equity Report and Toolkit."

In the Manhattan program, "[r]esidents of the CBD [Central Business District] making less than $60,000 per year (adjusted gross income) are entitled to a tax credit equal to the amount paid for tolls (except if the toll is claimed as a business expense)," write Kate Slevin and Alex Matthiessen in a timely post on April 5 for Streetsblog NYC: "Every Last Detail About Congestion Pricing … Explained!"

Matthiessen worked with Charles Komanoff, a New York economist in an earlier version of cordon pricing promoted by Move NY (see 2017 post, also based on Hu's reporting). "[T]he idea of “putting a price on driving” clashes with America’s car-loving culture in which driving wherever the road may lead is often seen as the ultimate freedom," Komanoff tells Hu.

And with that assertion, we come right back to where this post began: if you haven't read, "Congestion Pricing Marks the End of an Era," do so now!

Related in Planetizen:

Monday, April 1, 2019 in The New York Times

The New York Public Library's stone lions Patience and Fortitude have donned face masks to remind New Yorkers to wear face coverings during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Top Urban Planning Books of 2021

Planetizen's annual list of the top urban planning books of the year is here—maintaining a tradition that dates back to 2002.

November 26, 2021 - James Brasuell

Empty Road

The Roadway Expansion Paradox

Motorists want expensive roadway expansions provided that somebody else foots the bill, but when required to pay directly through tolls, the need for more capacity often disappears. What should planners do?

November 28, 2021 - Todd Litman


Urban Exodus: Data Don't Support the Popular Pandemic Narrative

Americans fled cities in waves during the pandemic, right? Not to so fast.

November 30, 2021 - Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University

California Homeless

Study: At Least 1,500 Unhoused Died on the Streets of L.A. During the Pandemic

New research represents the first detailed picture of death among people experiencing homelessness during the pandemic.

31 minutes ago - The Guardian

A mile marker showing mile zero of the Great Allegheny Passage, which is a bike and pedestrian path that begins in Cumberland, Maryland and ends in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

Measuring the Economic Impact of the Great Allegheny Passage

Small communities once dependent on coal, coke, paper, lumber, and manufacturing now have a 150-mile bike and pedestrian path contributing to the local economy.

1 hour ago - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Houston, Texas

Houston Could End Homelessness With Less Than 2,000 Housing Units

Houston's homeless response program has yielded strong results in the last few years. Just 1,900 new affordable housing units could 'effectively end' homelessness in the city.

2 hours ago - Rice Kinder Institute for Urban Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.