California Unlikely to Follow New York in Allowing Urban Street Tolling

With the New York State legislature expected to pass a tolling plan for Manhattan early next week, the Chronicle's Rachel Swan reports on the unlikelihood of a similar plan being adopted in San Francisco or any city in the Golden State.

3 minute read

March 29, 2019, 12:00 PM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


One of the key reasons that cordon area congestion pricing appears likely to pass the New York State legislature on or before April 1, the state budget deadline, is the need for revenue to address the city's ailing subway system. "Though state leaders have not ironed out details, they had reached consensus on [March 25] that the plan was necessary to help pay for much-needed repairs to the city’s beleaguered subway system," report Jesse McKinley and Winnie Hu for the New York Times.

One congestion pricing plan backed by the governor and mayor is projected to raise about $1 billion annually from fees for driving into a congestion zone spanning Manhattan’s central business district, from 60th Street south to the Battery. That money would, in turn, be used to secure bonds totaling $15 billion for M.T.A. capital projects through 2024.

Rachel Swan, who covers transportation for The Chronicle, took notice of that potential revenue stream in her piece on Wednesday:

But as tempting as that kind of money is to some California politicians and traffic experts, congestion pricing is likely to be a tough sell in San Francisco, Los Angeles or elsewhere in the state anytime soon, even though those cities are considering such proposals.

Like New York, state legislation must pass before cities in California can implement what is technically known as cordon area congestion pricing, urban programs that have been operating successfully in Singapore, Londonand Stockholm since 1975, 2003 and 2008, respectively, enabling state legislation is necessary. Pricing the traffic lanes on a street apparently is not the same as pricing the parking lanes on that same roadway.

“There’s just this natural tendency not to like it,” said Assemblyman Richard Bloom, D-Santa Monica. He introduced a bill last year [AB-3059: Go Zone demonstration programsthat would have authorized two congestion-pricing test runs in Northern California, and two in Southern California. The idea: to unclog traffic-snarled streets, reduce air pollution and encourage motorists to spend less time on the road.

“It’s challenging,” said state Sen. Scott Wiener, D-San Francisco, who cosponsored Bloom’s bill last year. “People just aren’t used to paying for the cost of driving,” he added, referring to what it costs to build and maintain roads, not for gas and tuneups

The bill died before its first hearing, hobbled by opposition from the Automobile Club of Southern California [AAA] and the California Trucking Association, among other business and labor groups.

Congestion pricing advocates should not be discouraged, but instead should look at the New York City example. Eleven years ago, congestion pricing died on the New York State Assembly floor due to Democratic opposition. But with new leadership in the legislature and the governor's office, it looks like cordon area congestion pricing will finally be coming to the U.S.

Advocates should find inspiration from recent words from N.Y. Gov. Andrew Cuomo, whose leadership was crucial. Cited from "Cuomo Calls Congestion Pricing The Most Difficult Issue," NY State of Politics:

“Congestion pricing is the greatest opportunity we have had,” Cuomo said in a radio interview on The Brian Lehrer Show on WNYC on March 20. “We have talked about it for 20 years. It is the smartest idea I think for urban development.” 

Cuomo has national experience considering he served as Secretary of Housing and Urban Development under President Clinton. The congestion pricing segment in the interview can be found in the second 30-minute segment of (which will appear after the first segment is completed) on The Brian Lehrer Show at 19:50.

Related in Planetizen:

Hat tip to MTC News Headlines.

Wednesday, March 27, 2019 in San Francisco Chronicle

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Use Code 25for25 at checkout for 25% off an annual plan!

Redlining map of Oakland and Berkeley.

Rethinking Redlining

For decades we have blamed 100-year-old maps for the patterns of spatial racial inequity that persist in American cities today. An esteemed researcher says: we’ve got it all wrong.

May 15, 2025 - Alan Mallach

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

May 21, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Interior of Place Versailles mall in Montreal, Canada.

Montreal Mall to Become 6,000 Housing Units

Place Versailles will be transformed into a mixed-use complex over the next 25 years.

May 22, 2025 - CBC

Flat modern glass office tower with "County of Santa Clara" sign.

Santa Clara County Dedicates Over $28M to Affordable Housing

The county is funding over 600 new affordable housing units via revenue from a 2016 bond measure.

May 23 - San Francisco Chronicle

Aerial view of dense urban center with lines indicating smart city concept.

Why a Failed ‘Smart City’ Is Still Relevant

A Google-backed proposal to turn an underused section of Toronto waterfront into a tech hub holds relevant lessons about privacy and data.

May 23 - Governing

Pale yellow Sears kit house with red tile roof in Sylva, North Carolina.

When Sears Pioneered Modular Housing

Kit homes sold in catalogs like Sears and Montgomery Ward made homeownership affordable for midcentury Americans.

May 23 - The Daily Yonder