Done Deal: Manhattan Congestion Pricing

Finally, congestion pricing, as applied to city cordons, not highways, will be coming to the U.S., thanks to a budget deal approved by the New York State Legislature early Sunday morning. Tolls below 60th Street should begin by Jan. 1, 2021.

4 minute read

April 2, 2019, 10:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


New York City

Goran Bogicevic / Shutterstock

"State politicians announced an agreement shortly after midnight on Sunday to approve the tolling policy for Manhattan as part of a broader package of funding and reforms to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority stuffed into the state’s $175 billion budget," writes Vincent Barone, transit reporter for amNewYork on April 1, the deadline to pass the state budget.

The key details of the plan — including the price of the tolls — will be worked out on a future date.

Under the agreement, tolls would be activated by the end of 2020 and charge drivers as they pass 60th Street in Manhattan. The FDR Drive and West Side Highway would be excluded. Car owners living within the tolled district who make less than $60,000 a year would also be eligible for credits, according to the budget. Drivers wouldn't be tolled more than once per day. 

"The agreement makes New York City the first city in the nation to implement a congestion pricing plan, which the state has dubbed the Central Business District Tolling Program," writes Rebecca C. Lewis for City & State NY on April 1.

Widely called "congestion pricing," now common on many express lanes on highways, rather than the more precise "cordon area congestion pricing," Barone reports that it is uncertain if the toll would be variable, i.e., higher for peak-hours, and reduced when traffic is light, which is what is generally associated with congestion or value pricing. However, note that the Federal Highway Administration defines "cordon charges," which is what the legislature authorized, as "either variable or fixed charges."

Tolling infrastructure

"The authority is looking to 'minimize the infrastructure footprint, and leverage current infrastructure, to the greatest extent possible,'" reports Barone in a separate piece on the agreement on April 1. Overhead toll gantries that read E-ZPass transponders are not a certainty.

The MTA is already exploring the use of new roadside readers to tap into cars’ Bluetooth systems, as well as the possibility of utilizing drivers’ smartphone GPS systems without the need for any new street infrastructure, among a handful of other options to charge drivers entering the congestion zone, according to request for ideas that Bridges and Tunnels issued last Thursday.

Who will work out "the details?"

That would be the six-member Traffic Mobility Review Board, which "will next year recommend toll pricing, which could vary based on the time of day, as well as other exemptions and potential credits for drivers to the MTA's Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority [TBTA], which will oversee the program and give the state significant say over city traffic," adds Barone. "The plan is expected to raise $1 billion a year, which the MTA could bond against for up to $15 billion."

Members of the board will be appointed by the TBTA. "New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio will recommend one, one will come from the 'Long Island Rail Road Region' and one will come from the 'Metro North Region," adds Lewis.

Congestion pricing politics

Having the state's two commuter railroads receive some of the revenue was key to the budget agreement, reported Winnie Hu for The New York Times on March 28. "Long Island lawmakers want revenue from congestion pricing to flow to the commuter trains their constituents ride."

“At the end of the day, congestion pricing for Long Islanders should mean a better Long Island Rail Road,” said Senator Todd Kaminsky, who leads an influential six-member Long Island delegation that is part of the Senate’s Democratic majority.

Hu delves into the disproportionate subsidies received by the LIRR, not only in comparison to the New York City Transit Authority, but also Metro-North Railroad.

Finally, Jesse McKinley and Vivian Wang of The New York Times observed on March 31 that the budget deal negotiations took "weeks of intraparty bickering," which would include the aforementioned LIRR funding battle, unlike other state transportation funding legislation, e.g., last month's Alabama 10-cents per gallon fuel tax increase that was marked by bipartisan cooperation. 

"Republicans mostly oppose the concept, referring to it as a new tax," reports Katie Pyzyk of Smart Cities Dive. As noted in a post on the politics underlying the collapse of the Amazon deal in Queens in February, the midterm elections brought major changes to the legislature

Readers may wish to listen to a report from NPR-affiliate, WNYC, on the approval of the congestion pricing program by the legislature, as well as other aspects of the budget legislation, e.g., plastic bag ban, and/or read Gov. Andrew Cuomo's statement on the 2020 budget agreement: "We Got it Done!"

Related in Planetizen:

Monday, April 1, 2019 in amNew York

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

Graphic with blue background, flags, and text reading 2024 Presidential Election

Where 2024 Presidential Candidates Stand on 12 Issues Important to Urban Planners

Whether you’re yet undecided or have already cast your early vote, here is a roundup of the key positions of Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump on important urban planning policies.

October 31, 2024 - Planetizen

Amtrak Coast Starlight passenger train passing over bridge in Altamont Pass, California.

Amtrak Expanding Service in California’s Central Valley

Amtrak is planning a major expansion to the passenger rail lines connecting the Central Valley and the Bay Area.

November 4, 2024 - The Modesto Bee

Commercial street in small rural U.S. town with storefronts and clocktower.

Progressive Planning in Ideologically Conservative Communities

Planners must work in diverse political environments including conservative jurisdictions that are skeptical of new issues and perspectives. Here are ways to reconcile conflicting goals.

November 7, 2024 - Todd Litman

Aerial view of rainbow painted four-way crosswalk in the Castro district, San Francisco, California.

San Francisco Implements ‘Daylighting’ at Intersections

Vehicles are prohibited from parking within 20 feet of a crosswalk as part of the city’s Vision Zero efforts to eliminate traffic deaths and make roads safer.

4 hours ago - SFGate

View of Washington state capitol dome in Olympia, Washington at golden hour.

Washington Voters Keep Carbon Tax

An initiative that would have ended the state’s “cap and invest” program failed, leaving the program in place.

5 hours ago - Governing

Close-up of four Tesla sedans parked and plugged in at charging station.

The Future of Electric Vehicles Under Trump

Will Elon Musk’s influence temper Trump’s anti-EV stance?

6 hours ago - Wired

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.