New York City Congestion Pricing Plan Ready for Review

Motorists and truckers would pay tolls to drive south of 60th Street in Manhattan while passengers in taxis and ride-hailing vehicles would pay a surcharge under a plan released Friday by the Fix NYC panel convened by Gov. Cuomo in October.

4 minute read

January 22, 2018, 5:00 AM PST

By Irvin Dawid


New York City

ant D / Shutterstock

New York Times reporters Winnie Hu and James Dwyer reviewed a draft of the plan released Thursday by the Fix NYC panel, formed after Governor Andrew Cuomo (D) declared a state of emergency in the subways last June.

The panel had a two-fold purpose: reduce congestion in Manhattan's Central Business District and provide needed funding for the city's ailing subways and bus lines.

In announcing his support last summer for congestion pricingGov. Andrew Cuomo said the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the region’s umbrella transit agency, needs a new, reliable source of funds. Depending on how the prices are structured, the task force estimated that up to $1.5 billion could become available annually.

According to the Fix NYC Advisory Panel Report [pdf], prepared by HNTB Corporation, passenger vehicles would pay a toll of $11.52 to drive south of 60th Street, charged once per day, Monday through Friday, between the hours of 6am to 8pm.

Trucks would pay $25.34, and taxis and ride-hailing vehicles could see surcharges of $2 to $5 per ride within Manhattan's Central Business District, report Hu and Dwyer.

The report says that the fees on taxis and for-hire vehicles could be put in place within a year, followed by trucks and then cars in 2020. None of those fees should be charged, the [Fix NYC] task force said, until repairs are made to the public transit system.

Bridge tolls?

What may be a major shortcoming of the plan is that it doesn't call for tolls on the New York City-owned bridges over the East and Harlem rivers, an integral part of the Move NY congestion pricing plan released in 2013. In fact, it is likely that changes made to the Fix NYC plan by Gov. Cuomo, as is his right, would lower tolls on bridges and tunnels owned by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, report Hu and Vivian Wang for The New York Times on Jan. 19.

The only tolling would come from overhead toll gantries lining 60th Street southbound intersections in Manhattan, like former Mayor Michael Bloomberg's plan that died on the state Assembly floor in April 2008 without even getting a vote due to overwhelming opposition.

Hopefully the bridge toll reductions would only come after the MTA is receiving revenue from the 60th Street tolls. In a feature New York Times article last November on how city and state leaders have diverted funds from M.T.A, Emma G. Fitzsimmons, et.al., write:

In 2013, the M.T.A. was made to send $5 million to an affiliate agency, the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, to cover the cost of reducing tolls.

Silver lining of deteriorating subway system?

The crisis in the transit system may also make it easier for Mr. Cuomo to sell the pricing plan to the legislature. When Mr. Bloomberg made his pitch a decade ago, the transit system was in far better shape. In fact, the Bloomberg plan was intended to address surging ridership and anticipated the budget pressures that led to maintenance cuts.

Most of the plan would require the approval of the state legislature, which is expected to receive [the plan] Friday.

Mayoral opposition?

Unlike the 2008 plan advanced by former Mayor Bloomberg the New York City Council, Mayor Bill de Blasio has opposed congestion pricing, favoring a millionaires' tax to finance transit improvements, arguing that "congestion pricing hurts the middle class and poor who live outside Manhattan and drive into it."

The report dismissed those claims, saying only 4 percent of residents of other boroughs commute to jobs in Manhattan in a vehicle, or approximately 118,000 residents. Of those, it said, more than half were higher income individuals, and fewer than 5,000 of them would qualify as working poor.

However, de Blasio appeared "cautiously open to the plan," report Hu and Wang on Friday.

“This plan certainly shows improvement over previous plans we’ve seen,” Mr. de Blasio said during a radio appearance on WNYC,  calling it “definitely a step in the right direction.”

However, de Blasio emphasized to listeners that this was a plan advanced by the state, not the city, and he continues to prefer a progressive income tax over a transportation user fee to fund transit improvements.

Political battle ahead in Albany

"Mr. Cuomo, a Democrat who is up for re-election this year, almost certainly faces a legislative battle over congestion pricing, especially with lawmakers from the boroughs outside Manhattan who fear that a congestion plan would hurt their constituents who drive because they have limited access to subways and buses," add Hu and Wang.

Opposition will be bipartisan. Paying more to drive generally transcends party lines.

Hat tip to Mark Boshnack.

Thursday, January 18, 2018 in The New York Times

View form second story inside Southdale Mall in Edina, Minnesota with escalators and model cars parked on downstairs floor.

The Mall Is Dead — Long Live the Mall

The American shopping mall may be closer to its original vision than ever.

March 21, 2024 - Governing

View of Austin, Texas skyline with river in foreground during morning golden hour.

The Paradox of American Housing

How the tension between housing as an asset and as an essential good keeps the supply inadequate and costs high.

March 26, 2024 - The Atlantic

Houston, Texas skyline.

Report: Las Vegas, Houston Top List of Least Affordable Cities

The report assesses the availability of affordable rental units for low-income households.

March 22, 2024 - Urban Edge

Aerial view of Anchorage, Alaska downtown with mountains in background at golden hour.

Anchorage Leaders Debate Zoning Reform Plan

Last year, the city produced the fewest new housing units in a decade.

6 hours ago - Anchorage Daily News

Young man in wheelchair crossing zebra crosswalk.

How to Protect Pedestrians With Disabilities

Public agencies don’t track traffic deaths and injuries involving disabled people, leaving a gap in data to guide safety interventions.

7 hours ago - Governing

Aerial view of mountain town of Steamboat Springs, Colorado in the winter with snow at dusk.

Colorado Town Fills Workforce Housing Need With ‘Dorm-Style’ Housing

Median rent in Steamboat Springs is $4,000 per month.

March 28 - CBS News

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.