Learn today, plan for tomorrow.
Sign up for news and offers from Planetizen Courses, the online learning platform for planners.
"Cruising the San Francisco Bay on a new plug-in hybrid ferry, Gov. Jerry Brown on Thursday evening signed more than a dozen environmental bills that aim to boost the electric vehicle market, particularly among poor Californians, and reinforce the state’s fight against climate change," reports Alexei Koseff of The Sacramento Bee.
“Whether we travel by car, bus, or boat the need to move to zero-emission transportation is urgent. These bills will help get more clean cars on the road and reduce harmful emissions,” Brown said in a statement.
Among the 16 bills Brown signed aboard the ferry:
▪ Senate Bill 1014, by Sen. Nancy Skinner, D-Berkeley, which gives state regulators authority to establish emissions reduction targets for ride-hailing services like Uber and Lyft. The bill originally would have required the companies to provide all of their rides in zero-emission vehicles by 2029, but it was scaled back amid opposition from the tech industry. [See: "Should Ride-Hailing Vehicles Reduce Emissions?" June 22, 2018].
This bill creates the Zero-Emission Assurance Project to spur sales of used zero-emission vehicles (ZEVs) to low and moderate income Californians, somewhat similar to the Clean Vehicle Rebate Project for new electric vehicles. According to Cervantes:
Questions about battery life are among the highest ranking concerns that consumers have about the prospect of buying a ZEV, according to an April 2018 study [pdf] by the University of California, Davis [and National Center for Sustainable Transportation]. This concern is well-founded, as the cost of a replacement ZEV battery can range from $5,500 to more than $15,000.
Another bill to place more used electric vehicles in the hands of low and moderate income residents is Senate Bill 957, by Sen. Ricardo Lara, D-Bell Gardens, which allows low-income Californians to obtain carpool lane stickers for clean cars bought secondhand. Brown signed three additional bills by Lara at the climate summit, including:
Koseff describes several more bills that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants. He also reported on the protestors that grabbed much media attention as it showed that there is division among climate activists.
Outside [the Moscone Convention Center], hundreds of protesters calling for an end to oil drilling disputed Brown’s own achievements and the purpose of the summit, which they said promoted “false solutions” at the expense of local communities that are bearing the brunt of climate change’s impact.
Some environmental activists accuse Brown of being too closely tied to the oil industry. They sharply criticize his reluctance to limit oil production in California, which they argue would do more to benefit the environment and emissions reduction goals than policies Brown has favored, like cap-and-trade.
[See Keep it in the Ground – 2018: As climate hawks gather in San Francisco for the Global Climate Action Summit that convenes Wednesday, Gov. Jerry Brown, host of the summit, is dogged by critics who can't distinguish between oil production and consumption.]
All 16 bills are listed and described in the (Global Climate Action) Summit News. As for Executive order B-55-18 [pdf], establishing a new target to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045, Evan Halper reports for The Los Angeles Times that it "was so far-reaching and unprecedented that it was met with considerable skepticism."
The ambitious plan raised immediate questions. As an executive order, is it even binding? Does California have any plan in place for a complete decarbonization of its economy?
[Brown] acknowledged that getting to carbon neutrality requires “technological changes that don’t exist yet” and his measure is aimed at bolstering their innovation.
“This is a transformation that is called for that we will get to,” he said. “This is the boldest move that I have seen certainly anywhere in the U.S.”
If that language has you thinking "Gov. Moonbeam," a term coined in 1976 by the Chicago columnist Mike Royko in part due to Brown's desire to launch a satellite during his first term as governor, Royko would be laughing in his grave if he could have heard how the summit ended.
"In closing remarks at the Global Climate Action Summit, Governor Edmund G. Brown Jr. today [Sept. 14] announced that the State of California is teaming up with San Francisco-based Earth-imaging company Planet Labs (Planet) to develop and eventually launch a satellite that will track climate change-causing pollutants with unprecedented precision and help the world dramatically reduce these destructive emissions," according to Summit News.
"With science still under attack and the climate threat growing, we’re launching our own damn satellite,” said Governor Brown.