Formidable Barriers Threaten Penn Station Renovation

Last month N.Y. Gov. Andrew Cuomo proposed that Empire Station replace Penn Station, but many challenging parts, e.g., the Hudson River Tunnels, moving Madison Square Garden, could derail it. A related piece delves into the prior ARC tunnel project.

3 minute read

February 7, 2016, 1:00 PM PST

By Irvin Dawid

Proposal #6 in N.Y. Gov. Cuomo's ambitious "multibillion-dollar wish list," what some have dubbed his Robert Moses moment, is "Empire Station." Among the most formidable challenges necessary for the $3 billion modernization of the 1968 rail station, and certainly what may take the longest, is building the the new tunnel under the Hudson River for Amtrak and New Jersey Transit trains. 

“It all starts with the tunnels,” Tom Wright, president of the Regional Plan Association, told More on the Amtrak Gateway project below.

Among the other challenges described by Marissa Piazzola, editor/reporter for Fox Business News, are:

See New York Times architectural critic, Michael Kimmelman's most recent piece on this topic, "How to Transform Penn Station: Move the Garden." He's been hammering the same message since at least 2012 if not earlier.

Most surprising in Piazzola's piece was learning that "(t)he Penn Station that we know today was praised as a first class train station upon completion in 1968, five years after the original was demolished."

Of course, ridership on the three rail lines utilizing the station, Long Island Rail Road, New Jersey Transit, and Amtrak, as well as the Seventh and Eighth Ave. subway lines has grown to the point that a "station designed to accommodate 200,000 daily commuters serves more than 650,000 each day," according to Piazzola.

How Will it be Paid for?

"The project will cost $3 billion and be funded by a public-private partnership," writes Piazzola. "Government sources will pay for $325 million of the Empire Station Complex, while the rest will be covered by private investment."

The state issued a 65-page Request for Proposals ([PDF], which outlines its plans for the site in great detail. Developers must submit proposals for either Penn, Farley, or both by April 22.

Access to the Region's Core becomes Amtrak Gateway

The most pressing issue for New Jersey commuters as well as Amtrak passengers using Penn Station going to/from New Jersey is the aforementioned tunnel construction. "Construction of a third train tunnel under the Hudson River was slated for completion by 2018," writes Dunstan Prial in a highly recommended piece that recaps the history of what was an essential project in 2010, and now is an urgent one.

But New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie killed the $12.4 billion ARC project in the fall of 2010 under the premise that New Jersey taxpayers were shouldering too much of the financial burden.

Now the massive infrastructure project is back on the drawing board but the projected cost has risen to more than $20 billion and the new tunnels won’t be completed for another decade and a half, perhaps longer.

“We will have lost 13 years or so as a result of [Gov. Christie's] decision that led to the cancellation of the ARC project,” said Martin E. Robins, a leading architect of New Jersey’s rail transit system over the past 25 years and the chief designer of the ARC tunnel.

Prial goes into the sordid details of how Christie "divert(ed) billions of dollars in ARC money to help bail out the state’s troubled finances without having to raise the state’s 14.50-cent gasoline tax," second lowest [PDF] in the nation after Alaska.

Former U.S. Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.) called it “one of the biggest policy blunders in New Jersey history.”

Hat tip to Peter Flieg.

Wednesday, February 3, 2016 in Fox Business

View of Interstate 205 bridge over Columbia River with Mt. Hood in background.

The Unceremonious Death of a Freeway Expansion Project

The end of an Oregon freeway project didn't get much fanfare, but the victory is worth celebrating.

September 19, 2023 - Streetsblog USA

Chicago Intercity Rail

Amtrak Ramping Up Infrastructure Projects

Thanks to federal funding from the 2021 infrastructure act, the agency plans to triple its investment in infrastructure improvements and new routes in the next two years.

September 25, 2023 - Smart Cities Dive

Google maps street view of San Francisco alleyway.

Ending Downtown San Francisco’s ‘Doom Loop’

A new public space project offers an ambitious vision—so why is the city implementing it at such a small scale?

September 26, 2023 - Fast Company

Aerial view of coastal development and bright blue ocean in Kaua'i, Hawai'i.

Kaua’i County Uses Long-Range Models to Mandate Resiliency Standards

The county requires builders to assess potential flood risks using models that account for sea level rise projected as far out as 2100.

1 hour ago - Smart Cities Dive

Semi truck driving down freeway with twilight sky in background.

California Governor Vetoes Autonomous Truck Ban

Gov. Newsom called the new law unnecessary, citing existing efforts by state regulators to develop new rules around autonomous trucking.

2 hours ago - Wired

Roadside motel with turquoise room doors in Tucumcari, New Mexico.

Low-Barrier Motel Shelter Is a Success—But Not an Easy One

Many guests at Motels4Now are on their second or third stays—but staff say that's doesn't equal failure, and the numbers bear that out.

3 hours ago - Shelterforce Magazine

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.