Maryland's $9 Billion Project Would Be the Nation's Largest P3 for Highways

Gov. Larry Hogan (R-Md.) announced last week plans for the largest highway contract awarded to a public-private partnership: adding four express toll lanes to the Capital Beltway and I-270. A third highway widening will be completed internally.

4 minute read

September 29, 2017, 6:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

Planetizen noted that Governor Larry Hogan's $9 billion highway widening proposal was critiqued by Angie Schmitt of Streetsblog USA here on Saturday. Other aspects, including financing, of the three highway widenings are observed in this post.

The complex road package would have a public-private partnership design, build, finance, operate and maintain four new express toll lanes (two in each direction) on the Capital Beltway (I-495) and on Interstate-270. They would be built adjacent to the existing eight, unmanaged, unpriced lanes.

Widening of the third highway, the Baltimore-Washington Parkway, designated as MD-25, would be undertaken by the Maryland Transportation Authority, the state's tollway authority that already operates eight toll facilities. The first step, though, would be a potentially controversial transfer of ownership of the parkway from the National Park Service, a bureau of the U.S. Department of the Interior, to the state.

Gov. Larry Hogan (R-Md.) "said he started the process during a recent meeting with Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke," reports David Shepardson for Reuters. "A spokesman for Zinke said Thursday no decisions over the future of the parkway were made during the meeting."

"With the total project estimated value at $9 billion, the Public-Private Partnership (P3) portion to add four new lanes on both I-495 and I-270 is the largest proposed P3 highway project in North America," according to the governor's press release on Sept. 21. There was no cost breakdown for the three segments of the projects though.

Today’s announcement officially begins the process to solicit the P3 industry for input and solutions to provide major congestion relief to these key transportation routes.

Cost to Maryland taxpayers: $0

However, Maryland won't be investing its taxpayers' money, according to Washington Post reporters Robert McCartneyFaiz Siddiqui and Ovetta Wiggins. Instead, users of the new pavement will ultimately be footing the bill.

Because of private-sector involvement, Hogan said, the plan would not cost taxpayers any money. Instead, he said, because of private companies’ up-front investments in the Beltway and I-270 ventures, the state could potentially reap billions of dollars of additional funds.

The plan foresees that the revenue spun off from the Beltway and I-270 would help cover the cost of upgrading and widening the B-W Parkway. Hogan was firm in saying that the roads would effectively pay for themselves.

Pushback from greens

"The proposal immediately drew criticism from some Democrats and from environmentalists and smart-growth advocatest, who said bigger roads would ultimately lead to suburban sprawl and an increased number of drivers, in turn worsening McCartney, Siddiqui and Wiggins for The Post. Their preference was for public transit investment. 

“We do not see any point in new highways or expanding existing highways,” said David Sears, chairman of Montgomery County’s Sierra Club group. “It makes a nice difference for a short period of time, but that’s probably measured in months — not years. And people adjust their behavior and then the roads are just as clogged as they used to be.”

However, what Sears' is referencing is 'induced demand' based on 'free lanes.' It's not clear if the concept turns to priced lanes.

"Based on Virginia’s experience, Sen. Richard S. Madaleno Jr. (D-Montgomery), who is seeking the Democratic nomination to challenge Hogan next year, said rush-hour tolls for commuters would be as high as $20 to $40," 

HOT lanes not included

If the new express toll lanes operate like the existing I-95 Express Toll Lanes, owned by the Maryland Transportation Authority, toll rates would be determined by time-of-day and whether E-ZPass (transponder) or video (license plate) tolling was applied. See brochure [pdf].

Note that there are no exceptions for carpools or zero-emission vehicles. Everyone pays. These are not High Occupancy Toll (HOT) lanes where carpools travel at no cost, as do three-person or more carpools on the neighboring 95 and 495 express lanes in Virginia.

Planetizen observed that the new $500 million 395 Express Lanes project in neighboring Virginia, which broke ground last month, also essentially involves no public funding by Virginia taxpayers. Additionally, it will make a minimum $15 million contribution to public transit annually.

Fits an emerging pattern for new lane construction

All three Maryland highway widenings that comprise the $9 billion Maryland project fit the emerging pattern posted last month "that when freeways are widened, express lanes, financed in part by user fees, are being added rather than mixed-flow lanes."

A major exception to the pattern can be found in California, though, where voters have opted to support local transportation sales tax measures that widen highways with general purpose lanes, such as Orange County Transportation Authority's I-405 Improvement Project that received a $629 million TIFIA loan last month to finance the express lane addition of the $1.9 billion project.

WaPo Poll on Express Toll Lane additions

At the bottom of The Washington Post article is a "non-scientific," one-question poll for readers to answer:

"Do you support the governor's plan to widen three major highways using toll lanes?"

On Monday evening, 47% said 'yes'; 53% answered 'no.'

Hat tip to David Orr.

Monday, September 25, 2017 in Planetizen

View of Mount Hood at golden hour with Happy Valley, Oregon homes in foreground.

Clackamas County Votes to Allow ADUs, Residential RVs

County officials hope the zoning changes will help boost the housing supply in the region.

June 18, 2024 - Mountain Times

Single-family homes in a suburban neighborhood in Florida.

New Florida Law Curbs HOA Power

The legislation seeks to cut down on ‘absurd’ citations for low-level violations.

June 16, 2024 - The Guardian

Aerial view of intersection in New York City with yellow cabs and zebra crosswalks.

Planners’ Complicity in Excessive Traffic Deaths

Professor Wes Marshall’s provocatively-titled new book, "Killed by a Traffic Engineer," has stimulated fierce debates. Are his criticisms justified? Let’s examine the degree that traffic engineers contribute to avoidable traffic deaths.

June 13, 2024 - Todd Litman

Two-story homes on residential street in Surrey, British Columbia, Canada.

British Columbia Cracks Down on Short-Term Rentals

Provincial leaders say the new rules could open up as many as 19,000 units for long-term rental.

June 20 - CTV

Small backyard cottage with gabled roof in San Diego, California.

San Diego Sees Continued Growth in ADU Permits

Recent changes to regulations have made it easier and more affordable for homeowners to build ‘granny flats,’ and San Diego’s housing stock is benefiting.

June 20 - Axios San Diego

Close-up of top of California state capitol dome with U.S. and California flags flying and blue sky in background.

California is Updating its Climate Adaptation Strategy

The 2024 draft plan outlines the state's key climate resilience priorities, includes specific and measurable actions, and serves as a framework for collective efforts across sectors and regions in California.

June 20 - California Natural Resources Agency

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.