What Comes Next if California Repeals Its Gas Tax Increase?
Shortly after voting on Proposition 6, "Voter Approval for Future Gas and Vehicle Taxes and 2017 Tax Repeal Initiative," voters will be asked to sign petitions for an initiative for the 2020 ballot "that would ensure fuel taxes, car sales taxes and truck weight fees are spent on transportation projects," reports Alexei Koseff for The Sacramento Bee on July 31.
The proposal expands on Republican arguments that the gas tax increase, passed last year by Gov. Jerry Brown and Democratic lawmakers, was unnecessary because the state already has plenty of money to pay for a backlog of road repairs and maintenance.
Unlike the taxes and fees in Senate Bill 1, the Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017, the new initiative, which appears to be the brainchild of Carl DeMaio, who funded the current repeal initiative, brings in no new revenue. Instead, it diverts existing funds from the state's general fund to transportation, a trend seen elsewhere, particularly in states that are reluctant to hike transportation user fees like Texas.
For example, state legislation passed in 2011 requires that truck weight fees, about $1.1 billion according to Koseff, is used to pay debt service on Proposition 1B, the $19.9 billion transportation bond passed in November 2006. A much larger diversion would come from motor vehicle sales taxes.
The largest chunk of new funding for the plan comes from reallocating the sales taxes on automobiles to local transportation officials. According to a study [pdf] by the Center for Automotive Research, California sales taxes for new cars, used cars, parts and services totaled $6.5 billion in 2013.
There already is a "transportation lockbox" for fuel tax revenue, known as Article 19 in the state constitution, although it does allow revenue to be spent on transit guideways. In June, voters overwhelmingly passed Proposition 69 that provided lockbox protection for two SB 1 fees.
Koseff describes other aspects of the measure, including savings attained by outsourcing to the private sector. He also wrote a comprehensive description of Proposition 6 for those who are interested.
- Government / Politics
- 2018 Campaign
- 2020 Campaign
- Article 19
- California Ballot Initiatives
- California Gas Tax Repeal Initiative
- Heavy Truck Fees
- Motor Vehicle Sales Tax
- Proposition 1B
- Proposition 6
- Road Repair and Accountability Act
- SB 1
- State Gas Tax Repeal
- Tax Diversions
- Transportation Lockbox
- Truck Weight Fees
- Center for Automotive Research
- Carl DeMaio
- Alexei Koseff