Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Focus on Positive Train Control after Amtrak Train 501 Derails in Washington

Excessive speed is thought to be the cause of the deadly derailment on Dec. 18. Positive train control, which likely would have slowed down the train, was installed on the tracks and locomotive but was not yet operational.
December 22, 2017, 5am PST | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

Another deadly passenger train derailment and once again, the spotlight turns to the GPS-enabled railroad safety technology known as positive train control, or PTC, that potentially could have prevented it.

In Monday's fatal crash on a highway overpass above Interstate 5 in Dupont, Wash., 50 miles south of Seattle, Amtrak #501, on its maiden trip for the new Seattle-to-Portland route of the Amtrak Cascades service, was traveling at 80 mph as it entered a curve with a 30 mph speed limit leading into the overpass.

Three people died in the derailment, including rail advocates James Hamre, 61, and Zack Willhoite, 35, his close friend. Over 70 people were injured, which includes those traveling on Interstate 5, one of the busiest highways on the West Coast. The 12-car Talgo train was carrying 80 passengers, five crew members, and one technician.

"The National Transportation Safety Board [NTSB], in preliminary findings based upon event recorder data, identified the cause of the wreck as an overspeed condition," report Stuart Chirls and William C. Vantuono for Railway Age on Dec. 20. "NTSB also cited a lapse in situational awareness [i.e., distraction] on the part of the engineer as a possible contributing factor, as there was a second person in the cab."

Positive Train Control had been installed on the right-of-way, but wasn't operational, said Geoff Patrick, spokesman for Sound Transit, which owns the right-of-way.

The locomotive, as well as the tracks, must be equipped with the GPS technology for it to work to prevent derailments and crashes. According to Washington State Department of Transportation, which administered locomotive acquisition for the Bypass of Point Defiance project, the new Siemens Charger locomotives were equipped with PTC and would be used "once the system is activated corridor-wide in 2018."

"The Amtrak Cascades train service is jointly owned by the Washington State Department of Transportation and the Oregon Department of Transportation," according to WSDOT. "Amtrak operates the service for the two states as a contractor, and is responsible for day to day operations."

[Monday] was the first day of public use of the tracks, after weeks of inspection and testing.

"To date, Amtrak has equipped 49% of its locomotives and control cars, according to Federal Railroad Administration data from the second quarter of 2017," add Chirls and Vantuono for Railway Age.

Monday's derailment comes after several high-profile derailments involving passenger rail. According to Michael Sisak and Michael Balsamo of The Associated Press, PTC had the potential to prevent at least 25 crashes over the last 20 years, including:

The thrust of the AP piece is that Amtrak, and presumably its partner agencies, Washington State Department of Transportation and Oregon Department of Transportation, were in too much of a rush to begin service on the new route, potentially to meet deadlines set by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 for funding the $180.7 million bypass project.

WSDOT is investing nearly $800 million of ARRA High Speed High-Speed Intercity Passenger Rail funds throughout the state.

Railroads, both freight and passenger, are required to have PTC installed by "December 31, 2018, with the possibility for two additional years if certain requirements are met," according to the Federal Railroad Administration.

Hat tips to Clyde Anderson and Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority Research Library & Archive:

Full Story:
Published on Wednesday, December 20, 2017 in RailwayAge
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email