California Road Charge Pilot Launches July 1; Gas Tax Increase Still Needed
"Next week California will launch an experiment to determine whether the state could repeal the gas tax and instead charge motorists for each mile they drive—essentially turning every public road into a toll road," writes Carl Davis, Research Director at the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP).
The California Road Charge pilot program will last for nine months. It will be the second operating program in the United States, after OReGO (posts here) that charges motorists a small vehicle-miles-traveled (VMT) fee.
Davis states the program has merit, but he also charges the state is "ignoring the preventable decline of its gas tax." However, Planetizen has tracked the unsuccessful efforts by state Senator Jim Beall, D-San Jose, chairman of the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee and Gov. Jerry Brown to raise the gas tax anywhere from six to 12 cents per gallon, first in last year's regular legislative session, and then in a special session.
California may be a blue state, but Democrats do not hold a two-thirds majority in the legislature. As long as a two-thirds threshold is needed for the legislature to raise gas taxes and as long as House and Senate Republicans remain stalwart in their opposition to raising the gas tax, it would not seem likely that raising gas taxes will be the solution to the state's ballooning transportation deficit.
"Fuel economy is down 0.4 mpg from the peak reached in August 2014, but still up 5.3 mpg since October 2007," wrote Dr. Michael Sivak, researcher for the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute in a June 2 email accompanying a May fuel efficiency report.
"Changes in vehicle fuel economy are only part of the reason gas tax revenues are falling short," writes Davis.
In fact, when we studied the causes of the gas tax’s decline in 2013, we found that more than three-fourths of the decline since the mid-1990s was unrelated to fuel economy improvements.
Oregon’s new VMT tax is an unsustainable revenue source because it contains the same design flaw that has plagued the state’s gasoline tax for almost a century—a stagnant, fixed tax rate that is incapable of keeping pace with inflation.
Davis sent a comment much to the same effect to a California Transportation Commission committee last year.
Indexing is necessary, be it for a road charge or a gas tax
"Regardless of whether drivers are taxed per-mile or per-gallon, revenues will fall short in the long-term unless the tax rate is indexed to inflation," writes Davis. "Florida, Georgia, Maryland, Rhode Island, and Utah already index their gas tax rates, and unlike per-mile charges whose widespread implementation is still years away, inflation indexing can be implemented almost immediately."
Well, in California's case, it may take either a change to the state constitution, a change to the political party composition of the state legislature, or a change in the Republican party position on gas taxes for that to occur.
The experiments underway in California and Oregon are important steps toward preparing us for that future. But we don’t have the luxury of planning for the future while ignoring the needs of the present. To deal with the shortcomings that exist in our infrastructure right now, gas tax reform—not a per-mile charge—is the answer.
- United States
- Government / Politics
- California Road Charge
- Fuel Efficiency
- Indexing Gas Tax
- State Gas Tax
- State Gas Tax Decrease
- VMT Fee
- Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP)
- University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute
- Sen. Jim Beall
- Carl Davis
- Michael Sivak