The Inflation Reduction Act's 'Inadequate' Reliance on Electric Vehicles

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) commits the United States to an unprecedented investment in climate action—going well beyond previous efforts from the Obama and Biden administrations, such as the previous clean energy and transportation infrastructure investments included in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, respectively.

Those previous examples could also serve as cautionary tales—of incremental steps that failed to solve greenhouse gas emissions while reinforcing some of the systems that have contributed to the climate crisis. All of those efforts have yet to balance the carbon budget yet—will the IRA?

A recent analysis by Yonah Freemark for the Urban Institute identifies cause for concern about the inadequacies of the IRA, noting that while the bill will make significant progress toward the goals set by the Paris Climate Agreement, the bill’s approach to transportation infrastructure, especially its reliance on electric cars, will prove inadequate for the needs of the climate.

“Focusing on electric cars and trucks is unlikely to quickly reduce US emissions and fails to account for the resource intensity of car manufacturing, noncarbon pollution produced by vehicles, and the unsustainable land uses car dependence produces,” writes Freemark.

The first problem is one of affordability, which will make it hard to scale the electric vehicle market commensurate with the need.

But there is also a critical angle of direct relevance to land use planning and urban design. The IRA’s reliance on electric cars doesn’t prioritize the more climate friendly approach of getting people out of their cars—on foot, onto bikes, or onto transit.

Freemark also notes that a future of automobile dependency also locks in other negative externalities, such as traffic fatalities, congestion, and air and water pollution. For more on the various negative externalities of electric vehicles, and the need to set a price for their use, with new fees and taxes, see a recent feature Planetizen feature article by Adam Millard-Ball and Michael Manville.