An American Urban Coronavirus Success Story

The City by the Bay has joined eight largely rural counties in California by advancing last Tuesday to the least restrictive tier of the state's new reopening criteria by reducing coronavirus transmission to nearly New York levels.

5 minute read

October 27, 2020, 11:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

Coronavirus and Urbanism

Eddie Hernandez Photos / Shutterstock

California suffered through the summer coronavirus surge that largely affected the South and West, where cases and hospitalizations increased dramatically. California's coronavirus dashboard shows two distinct peaks of its 14-day rolling average of daily new infections on July 25 and August 19 of nearly 9,500 and 8,200, respectively.

On August 28, Gov. Gavin Newsom retooled the reopening framework, creating a four-tiered system for the state's 58 counties, based largely on two health metrics: daily infections per 100,000 people, i.e., incidence, as determined by the results of diagnostic testing, and the test positivity rate: the ratio of positive test results to total tests administered. 

By Oct. 17, the state's 14-day rolling average of new cases had dropped to just over 3,100. Evan Webeck of the Bay Area News Group reported on Oct. 18 (source article) that California has seen the daily rate of new infections drop to 10 per 100,000 people while nationwide coronavirus cases increased by 25% during the past two weeks.

California ranked #42 on the Harvard Global Health/Brown School of Public Health COVID Risk Levels Dashboard with 11 daily new cases per 100k (7-day moving average) based on Oct. 24 data, with North Dakota #1 with 105 cases, the U.S. average at 20 cases, New York #45 with 8 cases, and Maine #51 with 2.4 cases. 

Health experts took notice of California's plunging infections.

"California 'holds a lesson for all of us,' Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the Brown University School of Public Health, tweeted [on Oct. 18], praising 'strong leadership' from Gov. Gavin Newsom and the state’s health and human services chief, Dr. Mark Ghaly," wrote health and medicine correspondent, Barbara Feder Ostrov, in a piece for CalMatters on Oct. 23.

Jha credited the state’s “huge boost” in testing and county-by-county “micro-targeting” as “smart policies” that have helped control the virus. California has averaged nearly 124,000 COVID-19 tests each day for the past two weeks.

“Instead of approaching lockdowns as light switch (on or off), CA approach is that of a dimmer switch…Obviously we don’t know if it will last but so far, so good,” he wrote.

Sadly, it doesn't appear to be lasting. Like the rest of the nation, cases are rising in the Golden State, with the 14-day average of daily new infections over 3,600 on Oct. 25. How high it goes will be determined by people's behavior, not the density of where they live, as Webeck noted in the third paragraph of his piece.

The reasons why [infections have plunged], health experts say, are made clear by a stroll through San Francisco. Pedestrians are masked and passing each other at acceptable social distances. Painted circles partition off small groups at one of the city’s most popular parks. 

“If you social distance and you wear masks, you decrease the cases dramatically,” said Dr. John Swartzberg, an infectious disease expert and professor emeritus at UC Berkeley. “A culture that accepts the science and follows it is going to do better.”

San Francisco drops a tier

"San Francisco [last] Tuesday became the first major jurisdiction in California to advance into the state’s least-restrictive yellow reopening tier, Dr. Mark Ghaly, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, said in a series of announcements," reported Webeck on Oct. 20. The city was one of six Bay Area counties on March 17 that were first in the nation to shelter-in-place to slow the spread of the virus.

At 0.8%, the positivity rate in San Francisco is one of the lowest in California. The city is also testing more of its residents per-capita than any other jurisdiction in the state. That allowed it to further reduce its case rate, using a modifier in the state’s calculation, from 2.5/100K to 1.5/100K, according to data from CDPH.

According to the state's new reopening criteria known as Blueprint for a Safer Economy, the yellow or "minimal" restriction tier requires less than one daily new case per 100k and less than 2% test positivity. Accordingly, "[m]ost indoor business operations are open with modifications." 

Dr. Erica Pan, California’s public health officer, said San Francisco benefited from the new health equity metric, which requires the positivity rates in the most disadvantaged communities to be within a certain percentage of the countywide average.

"Experts credit San Francisco’s success to a long partnership between public health officers and universities, most notably during the AIDS crisis," reports San Francisco-based Maura Dolan in an extensive piece describing the city's success for the Los Angeles Times on Oct. 25.

Nina Bai with U.C. San Francisco wrote in July about how the city's AIDS epidemic response helped prepare them for COVID-19.

In that sense, San Francisco, America's second densest large city after New York, shares a similarity with the successful responses of its dense East Asian counterparts in Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore, and Vietnam that had memories of dealing with the more fatal, though less contagious, SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) coronavirus in 2003, and South Korea, which dealt with a more recent deadly coronavirus, Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS), in 2015.

San Francisco, with its 882,000 residents living on 47 square miles, joined six of the state's least populous counties, all less than 20,000, plus Siskiyou (pop. 45,000) and Humboldt (pop. 136,000) counties in the "minimally restrictive" tier which permits most indoor operations to open with modifications.

"City officials still are not declaring victory," adds Dolan of the Times.

Characteristically, they warn, the virus still lurks around the corner. And as they have before, they will follow local metrics rather than reopen just because the state allows it.

Related in Planetizen:

Sunday, October 18, 2020 in The Mercury News

Black and white Rideshare Pick-Up Zone sign

The Slow Death of Ride Sharing

From the beginning, TNCs like Lyft and Uber touted shared rides as their key product. Now, Lyft is ending the practice.

June 1, 2023 - Human Transit

Urban sidewalk shaded by large mature trees

Cool Walkability Planning

Shadeways (covered sidewalks) and pedways (enclosed, climate controlled walkways) can provide comfortable walkability in hot climates. The Cool Walkshed Index can help plan these facilities.

June 1, 2023 - Todd Litman

Traffic on the 405 interstate freeway through the Sepulveda Pass at Getty Center Drive in Los Angeles, California

Congestion Pricing Could Be Coming to L.A.

The infamously car-centric city is weighing a proposed congestion pricing pilot program to reduce traffic and encourage public transit use.

May 30, 2023 - Los Angeles Times

"Welcome to Texas" road sign with Texas flag and "Drive Friendly - the Texas way" slogan

Report: Austin’s State Roads Deadlier Than City Roads

Traffic fatalities and serious injuries grew on state-owned roads in the Texas capital, even as city-owned streets saw death rates plateau.

20 seconds ago - Smart Cities Dive

View from lakeside with green grass and pink blooming flowers

Who Benefits Most from Land Conservation Efforts?

A new study estimates that recent land conservation generated $9.8 billion in wealth nationally through the housing market and that wealthier and White households benefited disproportionately.

1 hour ago - PNAS

Close-up of black parking meter with blurred street in background

Richmond Repeals Parking Minimums, Encourages Off-Street Parking and Transit

The Virginia city is replete with underused off-street parking lots, which city councilors hope to make available for parking at more times while encouraging transit use.

2 hours ago - Next City

Project Manager III

San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency

UDO Transportation Planner

City of Charlotte - Charlotte Area Transit

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.