Where BART's New Extension to the Fringe Went Wrong

This story begins and ends with a freeway.

2 minute read

August 29, 2017, 11:00 AM PDT

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell


BART East bay

David Wilson / Flickr

Alon Levy critiques the plan for a new BART extension proposed for the city of Livermore, located on the suburban fringe of the East Bay Area. According to Levy's argument, the new extension continues BART's focus on suburban service, which limits ridership relative to the other U.S. rail transit system of comparative scope (i.e., the Metrorail system of the Washington, D.C. region).

In 2006, transit expert Christof Spieler, now serving on the board of Houston METRO, compared the two systems, writing that BART mostly serves the suburbs, whereas the Washington Metro serves both the suburbs and the urban core. Unfortunately, BART's plans for expansion keep prioritizing suburban service. The best example of this is the extension to Livermore, for which BART released the environmental reviews on Monday.

According to Levy's critique, the Livermore BART extension's fatal mistake is in its route down the I-580 Freeway. According to Levy, "[f]reeway running is not common on the highest-performance urban rail systems, because nobody wants to live, work, or play right next to a freeway. People prefer living a few minutes by car from the freeway for easy access." It's freeway alignment means this BART extension is already doomed to low ridership, especially in off-peak hours.

But low expected ridership is not the only flaw Levy finds with the Livermore BART extension, there's also high costs—per rider, the cost is expected to be four times as expensive as the recently completed Second Avenue Subway in New York City.

Tuesday, August 1, 2017 in The Bay City Beacon

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Close-up of "Apartment for rent" sign in red text on black background in front of blurred building

Trump Administration Could Effectively End Housing Voucher Program

Federal officials are eyeing major cuts to the Section 8 program that helps millions of low-income households pay rent.

April 21, 2025 - Housing Wire

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

April 30, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Ken Jennings stands in front of Snohomish County Community Transit bus.

Ken Jennings Launches Transit Web Series

The Jeopardy champ wants you to ride public transit.

April 20, 2025 - Streetsblog USA

Person in yellow safety suit and white helmet kneels to examine water samples outdoors on a lake shore.

USGS Water Science Centers Targeted for Closure

If their work is suspended, states could lose a valuable resource for monitoring, understanding, and managing water resources.

47 seconds ago - Inside Climate News

Close-up of white panel at top of school bus with "100% electric" black text.

Driving Equity and Clean Air: California Invests in Greener School Transportation

California has awarded $500 million to fund 1,000 zero-emission school buses and chargers for educational agencies as part of its effort to reduce pollution, improve student health, and accelerate the transition to clean transportation.

April 30 - California Air Resources Board

Aerial view of Freeway Park cap park over I-5 interstate freeway in Seattle, Washington at night.

Congress Moves to End Reconnecting Communities and Related Grants

The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee moved to rescind funding for the Neighborhood Equity and Access program, which funds highway removals, freeway caps, transit projects, pedestrian infrastructure, and more.

April 30 - Streetsblog USA