Op-Ed: Jane Jacobs Wouldn't Recognize the Cities of Today

Without children at the center of activity, the urban neighborhoods of today offer little compared to the ideals expressed by Jane Jacobs, according to this strongly worded critique of contemporary urbanism.

2 minute read

June 7, 2016, 10:00 AM PDT

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell


Kids on bikes

Dasha Rosato / Shutterstock

Benjamin Schwarz begins a critique of what he calls the Vibrant Urban Neighborhood with the following description of his subject: "its standard-issue bike shops and vintage clothiers, its 'authentic' live-work spaces and dive bars, its predictable purveyors of vinyl records and locally-sourced foodstuffs, its de rigueur venues for generically hip 'live music,' its uniform throngs of overwhelmingly unmarried and childless active or aspiring knowledge workers ritualistically intoning the shibboleth of 'diversity'…"

Instead of the renaissance many urbanists describe, the increasing popularity of Vibrant Urban Neighborhoods, or VUNs, "merely demonstrates that consumption and entertainment have become the dominant means of self-definition and of what passes for political expression—and, concomitantly, it signifies not the triumph of urban life but of our crabbed vision of the promise and potentialities of neighborhood and community."

To further describe where the urban renaissance has gone wrong, Schwartz compares contemporary urban neighborhoods to those extolled by Jane Jacobs. According to Schwartz, children are the component most lacking from contemporary neighborhoods. In fact, the bulk of the argument contained in the column is devoted to reframing the importance of children in some of Jacobs's most famous passages, and achieving an accurate comparison of the "urban villages" of her day with the VUNs of ours.

By discussing children, Schwartz also enters into an ongoing debate about the long-term appeal of urban environments to families as they age and grow. Planetizen blogger Michael Lewyn recently wrote about the complex demographic trends unfolding for families in and around cities. Other recent stories have lamented the lack of priority given to children in setting an urban agenda in Oakland, California, and provided statistical analysis of the U.S. cities with the most children.

Monday, June 6, 2016 in The American Conservative

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Cover CM Credits, Earn Certificates, Push Your Career Forward

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

June 11, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Large crowd on street in San Francisco, California during Oktoberfest festival.

The Simple Legislative Tool Transforming Vacant Downtowns

In California, Michigan and Georgia, an easy win is bringing dollars — and delight — back to city centers.

June 2, 2025 - Robbie Silver

Rendering of Shirley Chisholm Village four-story housing development with person biking in front.

San Francisco's School District Spent $105M To Build Affordable Housing for Teachers — And That's Just the Beginning

SFUSD joins a growing list of school districts using their land holdings to address housing affordability challenges faced by their own employees.

June 8, 2025 - Fast Company

Bird's eye view of half-circle suburban street with large homes.

In More Metros Than You’d Think, Suburbs are Now More Expensive Than the City

If you're moving to the burbs to save on square footage, data shows you should think again.

8 seconds ago - Investopedia

Color-coded map of labor & delivery departments and losses in United States.

The States Losing Rural Delivery Rooms at an Alarming Pace

In some states, as few as 9% of rural hospitals still deliver babies. As a result, rising pre-term births, no adequate pre-term care and "harrowing" close calls are a growing reality.

June 15 - Maine Morning Star

Street scene in Kathmandu, Nepal with yellow minibuses and other traffic.

The Small South Asian Republic Going all in on EVs

Thanks to one simple policy change less than five years ago, 65% of new cars in this Himalayan country are now electric.

June 15 - Fast Company