Keeping An Open Mind: How Some Cities Are Reducing Emissions While Supporting Economic Vitality

As cities swell and car use soars, U.S. cities should take note of some bold, even radical, emissions-reducing policies being deployed around Europe.

Read Time: 4 minutes

October 7, 2018, 7:00 AM PDT

By Robert Fischer @viewpoint_plaza

Bike Traffic

If you care about the environment, you'd better start caring about transportation. | Michel Passet / Shutterstock

Transportation and clean air are at odds with one another, and as transportation-sourced CO2 emissions continue to rise in the U.S., American cities would do well to consider transportation policies that both mitigate emissions and support economic vitality.  

To appreciate the severity of the problem, it would help to start with these facts: for two years running, transportation has surpassed all other sectors as the biggest contributor to greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S., according to data released by the Energy Information Administration in March.

For decades the top carbon emitter in the U.S. was the power sector, in large part because of coal. But that all changed in 2016 when, for the first time, transportation outpaced all other sectors–more than agriculture, industry, and even electricity generation–accounting for 28 percent of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions.

And while cars, trucks, commercial aircraft, and railroads all contribute to transportation sector emissions, light-duty passenger cars and trucks–basically your typical commuter car and pick-up truck–account for 60 percent of all transportation greenhouse gas emissions.

Which is why U.S. cities should take note of some bold, even radical, emissions-reducing policies being deployed around Europe.

Take Germany, for example, which surprised the world in February with a five-city pilot proposal to reduce the number of private cars by making public transportation free–or at least ticketless. 

"Effectively fighting air pollution without any further unnecessary delays is of the highest priority for Germany," three ministers wrote in a letter to EU environment commissioner Karmenu Vella in Brussels.

Though details have yet to emerge about how Germany plans to fund the initiative, ticketless public transportation programs aren't new. 

Estonia's capital city, Tallinn, introduced fareless public transport for residents in 2013. To fund the measure, the city of Tallinn gets 1,000 euros a year from residents' income tax.  Nonresidents and tourists must still purchase tickets. 

The results have been impressive. Population numbers in the city have increased, and the overall city budget has grown, according to Edgar Savisaar, the populist mayor who introduced the fiscal law.  

"The lost ticket revenue from residents is 12 million euros ($15 million)," Savisaar said.  "The gain from additional revenues from the increase in the residential population, at the most conservative estimate, is well above 20 million euros ($25 million)."

In fact, the Tallinn initiative has been so successful that the central government earlier this year rolled out ticketless bus travel for the whole country. 

And if fighting emissions with ticketless transportation isn't audacious enough for you, consider these policies directed directly at cars.

Oslo, Norway, plans to permanently ban all cars from its city center by 2019 – six years ahead of Norway's county-wide ban on petrol-based cars, going into effect in 2025. Oslo will also invest heavily in public transportation and replace 35 miles of roads with bike lanes.

And you have to love the French: when the city of Paris banned all cars with even-numbered plates from entering the city for a day in 2014, pollution dropped by 30%. Inspired, in July 2016 the city banned all cars made before 1997 from driving in the city center on weekdays–though they are permitted on the weekend. Furthermore, the city government plans to double its bike lanes and limit select streets to electric cars by 2020.

But perhaps nothing compares to the city center of Ljubljana, Slovenia, where you must park your car at an underground garage outside the car-free area. The only exception is for the elderly, disabled people, or mothers with young children. They are offered free rides in electric taxis. Bicycles and buses are also permitted in this zone.

At first, local businesses in Ljubljana were worried the scheme would hurt trade, but quite the opposite happened. Business and tourism have increased, according to the World Economic Forum. And thanks to the city's policies, traffic has decreased by 12% since 2011.

So what do all these cities have in common? 

A keen understanding that public transportation, walking, and bicycling are not only unbeatable when it comes to fighting CO2 emissions, but they have the added benefit of increasing home values, costing taxpayers less, attracting tourists, and supporting vibrant, interactive economies.

So as US cities swell and car use soars, keep an open mind to some of the more innovative ways Europeans are mitigating their CO2 emissions.

Sure, prioritizing walking, biking and public transportation will cut into our drive-through culture, but at least we will all breathe easier. 

Robert Fischer

Robert Fischer is a Technology and Policy Advisor at Mandli Communications Inc. and an Associate Editor of the SAE International Journal of Connected and Autonomous Vehicles.


The Top Urban Planning Books of 2022

An annual list of the must-read books related to urban planning and its intersecting fields.

November 28, 2022 - James Brasuell

Urban separated bike lane with street trees on one side and cars parked on the other

How Urban Trees Save Lives

New research shows a strong connection between a healthy urban tree canopy and lowered mortality rates.

December 1, 2022 - Congress For New Urbanism

The website for Project Sidewalk shows a street with a menu for identifying issues with mobility infrastructure.

Top Websites for Urban Planning - 2022

Every year, Planetizen collects the websites breaking new digital ground in the world of planning and related fields.

December 6, 2022 - James Brasuell

Portland, Oregon street

Portland Moves Forward With Contentious Homelessness Strategy

The city’s plan to reduce the number of unhoused people has met with criticism, particularly for a proposal to ban encampment on public property citywide.

December 7 - Smart Cities Dive

View from back of two elderly people sitting on park bench

How Neighborhoods Impact Older Adults’ Resiliency to Climate Change

New research seeks to learn how homes, neighborhoods, and communities affect how older residents are affected by climate change.

December 7 - Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University

Aerial view of small rural community in Kentucky with ild rolling hills and sparse development

Rural Communities Growing Faster Than Cities

After a decade of sustained population loss, rural America is bouncing back thanks to shifting demographics and pandemic-induced migration.

December 7 - Carsey School of Public Policy

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.