Blog post
Smart Growth and Australia
As managing editor of Planetizen, I'd like to make a quick note on today's op-ed, Resisting Dickensian Gloom by Tony Recsei. Mr Recsei asked for a chance to respond to a recent criticism of his work by Planetizen regular Michael Dudley. It is our policy at Planetizen to allow points of view that are critical of the status quo in urban planning, so I agreed to run the piece. I did ask Mr. Recsei to tone down some of the more personal attacks on smart growthers so that his points could be presented more clearly to our audience, and I believe he has done that.
As managing editor of Planetizen, I'd like to make a quick note on today's op-ed, Resisting Dickensian Gloom by Tony Recsei. Mr Recsei asked for a chance to respond to a recent criticism of his work by Planetizen regular Michael Dudley. It is our policy at Planetizen to allow points of view that are critical of the status quo in urban planning, so I agreed to run the piece. I did ask Mr. Recsei to tone down some of the more personal attacks on smart growthers so that his points could be presented more clearly to our audience, and I believe he has done that.
I did do one bit of fact-checking, because I was interested in the work of the Australian Conservation Foundation, which Mr. Recsei cites. His interpretation is that inner-city residents of Australian cities create more greenhouse gas emissions than those who live in suburban areas. I asked Charles Berger, Director of Strategic Ideas at the ACF, if that was the case. Here is his response:
The findings are quite challenging for some environmentalists. In particular, they suggest that merely increasing urban densities and using public transport will not necessarily reduce total or per-capita ecological footprints. In Australia, wealthy inner city residents are driving less than others, but have increased consumption in nearly every other category of goods and services. Whatever savings are being achieved by bicycling and walking are being more than counterbalanced by increased airplane flights, food, clothing, and much else besides.
We are aware that some commentators have used these findings to encourage unsustainable peri-urban developments, and we categorically reject their conclusions. Eco-footprints in suburban areas in Australia are lower than in the urban core in spite of, not because of, lower residential densities. What the pro-urban sprawl groups also miss is that fact that Australian ecological footprints are across the board far higher than any reasonably sustainable level. Neither inner urban nor outer suburban development patterns are currently anything like sustainable.
Neither consumption-intensive inner city lifestyles, nor vehicle-dependent suburban lifestyles, are compatible with ecological imperatives. The main finding of our Consumption Atlas is that both need to change, and change dramatically.
Regards
Chuck Berger
Topics
- An International 'Winner' for the Sorriest Bus Stop in America
- The Neighborhoods With the Most Millennials Are Mostly in New York and Chicago
- Everything About Tax Increment Financing
- Brightline, Florida's High-Speed Rail Company, Goes All in on Vegas
- Study Reveals the Futility of Building Out of Congestion
- Vacant Commercial Spaces Spreading in New York
- Silicon Valley City to Approve Massive Vallco Development, Like it or Not
- Don't Blame Climate Change for Hurricane Florence
- 5 Ways Tech Is Changing U.S. Cities
- A Showcase of Innovative Climate Change and Resiliency Design Projects
- 220,000 EV Drivers in California to Lose Carpool Lane Perk in 2019
- Rezoning Plan Moves Forward in St. Paul
- Friday Eye Candy: Mapping Distance and Social Connectedness
- Checking in With the Trinity River Park Project in Dallas
- Weekly Scooter Media Brief: September 10-20
- New Book Studies 20 Examples of Adaptive Reuse
- Homeless Tents Missing the Permanent Housing Mark in San Diego
- Duplexes Approved for 99 Percent of Vancouver Single-Family Neighborhoods
- Prices Increasing in the Luxury Market
- Downtown Cincinnati: Parking Not Required
