California Cities Continue Fight Against State Preemption

Lafayette City Council Member Susan Candell penned an op-ed in support of a lawsuit to invalidate Senate Bill 9 by four Southern California cities, highlighting a recent supportive court filing by UCLA economic geographer Michael Storper.

5 minute read

September 11, 2023, 10:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Row of white Spanish Revival-style homes in Torrance, California.

kevin / Adobe Stock

On March 29, 2022, four cities in Los Angeles County, led by Redondo Beach, filed a writ of mandamus lawsuit against California Attorney General Rob Bonta in Los Angeles County Superior Courts, charging that Senate Bill 9, which permits the subdivision of single-family lots, violates the California Constitution in that it takes away the rights of charter cities to have control of local land use decisions.

[Related: More SB 9 Drama: L.A. County Cities Sue California, April 4, 2022. See additional posts tagged SB 9 dating back to August 2021.]

“In enacting Senate Bill 9 ('SB 9') in 2021, the State of California eviscerated a city’s local control over land use decisions and a community-tailored zoning process,” states the attorney acting on behalf of the petitioner city of Redondo Beach, joined by the cities of Carson, Torrance and Whittier, in the introduction of the 57-page filing [pdf].

In essence, SB 9 eliminates local authority to create single-family zoning districts and approve housing developments, a right that has existed for practically a century.

The Mercury News commentary

Lafayette City Council member Susan Candell, one of a very long list of elected city leaders in California who have endorsed a related ballot initiative effort launched by SB 9 opponents known as Our Neighborhood Voices, reported in her commentary for The Mercury News that Professor Michael Storper of UCLA’s Luskin School of Public Affairs, had filed a legal declaration [pdf] in support of the SB 9 lawsuit. 

[Related: Ballot Initiative Could Overturn California's Zoning Reforms, February 15, 2022]

“Storper agrees based on his 2019 paper, and he is willing to testify under oath to prove that the currently popular narrative supporting the state’s policies is unabashedly untrue,” writes Candell.

He says the current narrative is “fundamentally flawed and lead(s) to simplistic and misguided policy recommendations” and actually harms residents and communities due to gentrification and displacement.

Storper says that the states’ erroneous narrative “diverts attention away from the real need to address housing affordability for low- and moderate-income groups already residing in the prosperous metropolitan regions.”

Storper came in first in last year's “Annual Google Scholar Citation Data for Planning Faculty,” reported Planetizen managing editor, James Brasuell, on Jan. 26, 2022.

Leading the number of citations is Michael Storper at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), a controversial author and researcher who has provoked direct criticism on multiple occasions on Planetizen.

Update: Our Neighborhood Voices ballot initiative [November 2024]

In addition to highlighting Storper's support for the SB 9 lawsuit, Candell also promotes the ballot initiative that would amend the state constitution to prevent state preemption in local planning.

The only solution is to pass a constitutional amendment that would allow cities to override the state laws that are failing to solve our affordability and homelessness crisis — the Our Neighborhood Voices Initiative. 

As noted earlier, the effort was described in the February 15, 2022 post, “Ballot Initiative Could Overturn California's Zoning Reforms: The 'mother of all NIMBY initiatives' is seeking signatures to qualify for the statewide ballot in California.”

In fact, Candell was one of seven proponents who submitted  the “Request for Circulating Title and Summary” [pdf] to the initiative coordinator of the State Attorney General's office on July 13. If the measure qualifies, it would appear on the November 2024 ballot.

Article 34 repeal ballot confusion

“This constitutional amendment is expressly intended to authorize local laws to override conflicting state land use planning and zoning statutes,” states the last paragraph of the first section of the 6-page initiative [pdf]. However, the penultimate section simply states, "Article XXXIV of the Constitution of the State of California is repealed.”

Ballotpedia, the nonprofit organization that tracks most ballot measures in the U.S., has titled the Our Neighborhood Voices ballot measure, “California Authorize Local Land Use and Planning and Repeal Article 34 Initiative” (2024).

The California Authorize Local Land Use and Planning and Repeal Article 34 Initiative may appear on the ballot in California as an initiated constitutional amendment on November 5, 2024.

The ballot measure would repeal Article 34 of the state constitution, which requires local voter approval via a ballot measure for federal and/or state government-funded housing projects classified as low rent. The initiative would also authorize local laws related to land use, planning, and zoning to supersede state laws if they are enacted by the local electorate.

The repeal of Article 34 of the California Constitution, the subject of three posts on Planetizen since 2019, will appear in a measure by itself on next year's ballot, a result of the passage of Senate Constitutional Amendment (SCA) 2 by Sen. Ben Allen (D--Santa Monica) on Aug. 31, 20222, though exactly when appears to be unsettled.

“The measure will ask voters to do away with Article 34 of the California Constitution, which requires voter approval before public housing is built in a community,” reported Liam Dillon for the Los Angeles Times on Sept. 2, 2022.

Article 34, which passed in 1950, stymied low-income housing construction in California for decades and continues today to add to the cost and uncertainty of building affordable housing.

While other states have had and repealed laws that called for a public vote before the construction of low-income housing, only California’s Constitution currently requires voter approval for public housing.

March or November?

According to Ballotpedia: “The California Remove Voter Approval Requirement for Public Low-Rent Housing Projects Amendment is on the ballot in California as a legislatively referred constitutional amendment on November 5, 2024.”

A “yes” vote supports amending the California Constitution to repeal Article 34, which requires local voter approval via a ballot measure for federal and/or

state government-funded housing projects classified as low rent.

The Secretary of State's webpage, “Qualified Statewide Ballot Measures,” on Sept. 7 indicates it will appear on the March 2024  ballot as a result of the passage of SCA 2 (Allen) Public housing projects. (Res. Ch. 182, 2022) (PDF). However, a bill to move the measure, along with ACA 5 (Low) Marriage equality. (Res. Ch. 125, 2023) (PDF) which has also qualified for placement on the March 2024 ballot, to the November 2024 ballot has passed both houses and will be read for a third time on Sept. 8.

See Dillon's piece in the LA Times for more information on Sen. Ben Allen's bill and the effort to get it approved.

As for the confusion of having two ballot measures ask voters to repeal Article 34, look for future clarification in the comment section below.

Saturday, August 26, 2023 in The Mercury News

Single-family homes in a suburban neighborhood in Florida.

New Florida Law Curbs HOA Power

The legislation seeks to cut down on ‘absurd’ citations for low-level violations.

June 16, 2024 - The Guardian

Three colorful, large beachfront homes, one khaki, one blue, and one yellow, with a small dune in front and flat sand in foreground.

Florida Homeowners 'Nope Out' of Beach Restoration Over Public Access

The U.S. Corps of Engineers and Redington Shores, Florida are at a standstill: The Corps won’t spend public money to restore private beaches, and homeowners are refusing to grant public access to the beaches behind their home in return for federal assistance.

June 7, 2024 - Grist

Multistory apartment building under construction.

New Tennessee Law Allows No-Cost Incentives for Affordable Housing

Local governments in the Volunteer State can now offer developers incentives like increased density, lower parking requirements, and priority permitting for affordable housing projects.

June 10, 2024 - Nooga Today

Green meadow with water running through and trees on either side in Yosemite National Park.

Yosemite Meadow Undergoing Major Restoration

Rangeland recently acquired from private owners is being restored to a more natural state thanks to a purchase by the Trust for Public Land.

7 hours ago - San Francisco Chronicle

Large black SYV driving down city street with blurred background.

GAO to Investigate How Vehicle Design Impacts Safety

A lax set of rules around vehicle size, height, and other factors is partly responsible for the alarming rise in pedestrian deaths in the United States.

June 17 - Streetsblog USA

Worker in yellow safety suit holding up orange SLOW sign on road

New Orleans Faces $1 Billion Shortfall for FEMA-Funded Roadwork

After years of delays, cost overruns, and deadline extensions on a FEMA-funded street repair program, New Orleans officials face a massive funding shortfall and accusations of mismanagement.

June 17 - NOLA.com

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.