Supreme Court: OSHA Exceeded its Public Health Authority

The Supreme Court ruled that the Occupational Safety and Health Administration had overreached its authority to protect the health of workers in large private companies. In a separate decision, it upheld a vaccine mandate for most healthcare workers.

5 minute read

January 18, 2022, 12:00 PM PST

By Irvin Dawid


The exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court, with an American flag flying above its large columns and white marble exterior.

Kostiantyn1302 / Shutterstock

In a major blow to the Biden administration's Path Out of the Pandemic plan, the main element being to "vaccinate the unvaccinated," the U.S. Supreme Court on January 13 blocked an emergency temporary standard written by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) that required most workers in large companies (100+ employees) to be vaccinated against COVID-19 or undergo weekly coronavirus testing and wear masks to prevent viral spread.

"The question...is whether the [Occupational Safety and Health] Act plainly authorizes the Secretary [of Labor]’s mandate," referring to the large employer mandate, wrote the majority of justices in the first 10 pages of the 30-page, unsigned opinion in the case, "National Federation of Independent Business v. Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration."

"The Act empowers the Secretary to set workplace safety standards, not broad public health measures."

"The vote... was 6 to 3, with the liberal justices in dissent," writes Adam Liptak, who covers the United States Supreme Court for The New York Times. "The ruling means that companies across the country must now decide between protecting employees, potentially losing staff members resistant to complying and running afoul of patchwork regulations."

Complicated but quick path to the Supreme Court

The final decision was noted on page 9 of the 30-page ruling [pdf]:

The applications for stays presented to JUSTICE KAVANAUGH and by him referred to the Court are granted.

The stays refer to the most recent federal appeals court ruling (Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati) that reinstated the OSHA rule on December 17. In November, at least 34 lawsuits against the OSHA rule had been consolidated and sent to the Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati after the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans had stayed the rule twice.

OSHA had introduced the rule, technically referred to as an emergency temporary standard, on Nov. 4 after President Biden addressed the nation on Sept. 4 to announce his plan to combat the Delta surge. The large employer mandate was but one of four vaccination measures aimed at vaccinating two-thirds of the American workforce. The other three:

  • Health care worker mandate, which the justices also decided on Jan. 13 (see below)
  • Federal worker vaccine mandate
  • Federal contractor and subcontractor vaccine mandate

Healthcare workers mandate

"The vote in the health care case was 5 to 4, with Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh joining the liberal justices to form a majority," adds Liptak. "That second mandate applies to workers at hospitals and other health care facilities that participate in the Medicare and Medicaid programs."

In both the employer and health worker cases, the justices explored whether Congress had authorized the executive branch to take sweeping actions to address the health care crisis.

In the unsigned majority opinion that occupies the first ten pages of the 23-page ruling of "Biden v. Missouri" [pdf], the five justices write, in sharp contrast to their OSHA ruling:

First, we agree with the Government that the Secretary’s rule falls within the authorities that Congress has conferred upon him...

The Secretary of Health and Human Services determined that a COVID–19 vaccine mandate will substantially reduce the likelihood that healthcare workers will contract the virus and transmit it to their patients. He accordingly concluded that a vaccine mandate is “necessary to promote and protect patient health and safety” in the face of the ongoing pandemic. 

The rule thus fits neatly within the language of the statute. After all, ensuring that providers take steps to avoid transmitting a dangerous virus to their patients is consistent with the fundamental principle of the medical profession: first, do no harm.

The five justices: Breyer, Sotomayor, Kagan, and the two aforementioned conservative justices, are referring to the governing statute under which the Medicare and Medicaid programs operate. Liptak acknowledged the minority viewpoint:

In dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justices Samuel A. Alito Jr., Neil M. Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett, wrote that “scattered provisions” in the statute did not justify the mandate.

Path to Supreme Court

The final decision is noted on the first page of Biden rv. Missouri [pdf]: "Two District Courts enjoined enforcement of the rule, and the Government now asks us to stay those injunctions. Agreeing that it is entitled to such relief, we grant the applications."

Unlike the employer mandate, the  Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) mandate never went to an appeals court. Two district courts, one in St. Louis, the other in the Western District of Louisiana, had issued preliminary injunctions on the mandate in November.

Remaining federal vaccine mandates

A three-judge panel of the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati, the same court that ruled in favor of the large employer mandate on Dec. 17, "voted 2-1[pdf] to uphold a ruling by a federal judge in Kentucky which found the Biden administration overstepped its bounds," reported Jared Serbu for the Federal News Network on Jan. 6.

As for federal employees, including those serving in the military forces, the vaccine mandate has so far withstood legal challenges.

Related in Planetizen: Biden administration vaccine mandates

Supreme Court rulings on other vaccine mandates

Vaccine mandates abroad

Thursday, January 13, 2022 in The New York Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Close-up of "Apartment for rent" sign in red text on black background in front of blurred building

Trump Administration Could Effectively End Housing Voucher Program

Federal officials are eyeing major cuts to the Section 8 program that helps millions of low-income households pay rent.

April 21, 2025 - Housing Wire

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

April 30, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Ken Jennings stands in front of Snohomish County Community Transit bus.

Ken Jennings Launches Transit Web Series

The Jeopardy champ wants you to ride public transit.

April 20, 2025 - Streetsblog USA

Close-up of white panel at top of school bus with "100% electric" black text.

Driving Equity and Clean Air: California Invests in Greener School Transportation

California has awarded $500 million to fund 1,000 zero-emission school buses and chargers for educational agencies as part of its effort to reduce pollution, improve student health, and accelerate the transition to clean transportation.

April 30 - California Air Resources Board

Aerial view of Freeway Park cap park over I-5 interstate freeway in Seattle, Washington at night.

Congress Moves to End Reconnecting Communities and Related Grants

The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee moved to rescind funding for the Neighborhood Equity and Access program, which funds highway removals, freeway caps, transit projects, pedestrian infrastructure, and more.

April 30 - Streetsblog USA

"No Thru Traffic - Open Streets Restaurants" sign in New York City during Covid-19 pandemic.

From Throughway to Public Space: Taking Back the American Street

How the Covid-19 pandemic taught us new ways to reclaim city streets from cars.

April 30 - Next City