Court: Federal COVID-19 'Vaccine or Test-and-Mask' Mandate 'Fatally Flawed'

The Biden Administration's most sweeping and possibly controversial action to increase COVID vaccinations has been stayed twice by a federal appeals court and is likely headed to the Supreme Court

3 minute read

November 15, 2021, 11:00 AM PST

By Irvin Dawid


Coronavirus Testing

Joe Tabacca / Shutterstock

The timeline of the rulings by the New Orleans-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on one of the mandates included in a multi-prong vaccination strategy that applies to the nation's corporate workforce was first announced by President Joe Biden on Sept. 9 has been remarkably swift.

Rule issued, and promptly stayed

On Thursday, Nov. 4, the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) announced a new emergency temporary standard to protect more than 84 million workers from the spread of the coronavirus on the job.

Under this standard, private employers of 100 or more people "must develop, implement and enforce a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, unless they adopt a policy requiring employees to choose to either be vaccinated or undergo regular COVID-19 testing and wear a face covering at work," according to OSHA.

On Friday, the proposed rule was published in the Federal Register, setting Dec. 6 as the deadline for submission of comments from the public. On Saturday, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit stayed the rule in response to petitions filed by the states of Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Utah, South Carolina, and companies that claim they’re adversely affected by the rule, according to Bloomberg Law

"The Fifth Circuit panel said in a brief order, signed by a deputy clerk, that the judges were blocking the regulation 'because the petitions give cause to believe there are grave statutory and constitutional issues with the mandate," reported Isabella Grullón and Lauren Hirsch and for The New York Times on Nov. 6.

At the core of the legal challenge is the question of whether OSHA exceeded its authority in issuing the rule and whether such a mandate would need to be passed by Congress.

 [The panel] said the rule was suspended “pending further action by this court.”

A second ruling

That action took less than a week after hearing from the Justice Department on Monday and the plaintiffs on Tuesday.

"In a 22-page ruling [pdf] issued on Friday, a three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, in New Orleans, held that a group of challengers to the mandate issued by the Biden administration was likely to succeed in its claim that it was an unlawful overreach, and barred the government from moving forward with it," reported Charlie Savage on Nov. 12 (source article). The case is BST Holdings LLC v. OSHA.

Once again, the theme of public health vs. individual rights surfaced, expressed by Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt, who wrote:

"The public interest is also served by maintaining our constitutional structure and maintaining the liberty of individuals to make intensely personal decisions according to their own convictions — even, or perhaps particularly, when those decisions frustrate government officials.”

"On the dubious assumption that the Mandate does pass constitutional muster—which we need not decide today—it is nonetheless fatally flawed on its own terms," wrote Engelhardt and Judges Edith H. Jones and Kyle Duncan.

"The ruling by the panel of the Fifth Circuit is unlikely to be the final word," adds Savage.

Some challenges to the mandate are in other circuits, and the cases will be consolidated before a randomly chosen one of those jurisdictions. The Supreme Court is expected to eventually decide the matter.

Related in Planetizen

Hat tip to Jordan Williams of The Hill who highlighted the "fatally flawed" description by the judges. 

Friday, November 12, 2021 in The New York Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Close-up of Donald Shoup during interview.

Legendary Parking Guru Donald Shoup Dies at 86

Urbanists are mourning the loss of a dynamic voice for parking reform and walkable cities.

February 10, 2025 - StreetsBlog NYC

Red 1972 Ford Pinto with black racing stripes on display with man sitting in driver's seat.

Analysis: Cybertruck Fatality Rate Far Exceeds That of Ford Pinto

The Tesla Cybertruck was recalled seven times last year.

February 11, 2025 - Mother Jones

Row of vehicles parked and plugged in at EV charging station.

Federal EV Charging Program Suspended

The National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure program planned to fund the construction of hundreds of EV charging stations across the country.

February 9, 2025 - Wired

‘Umeke Lā‘au: Culture Medicine art installation - giant wooden sculpture of calabash with people standing inside.

A Monument to Resilience: Native Hawaiian Art Installation Honors History and Healing

The towering ʻUmeke Lāʻau installation by Native Hawaiian artist Meleanna Aluli Meyer, unveiled at Honolulu's city hall, is a powerful symbol of cultural resilience and healing.

February 18 - University of Hawai'i News

Close-up of narge eucalyptus tree.

Rethinking Fire-Resistant Landscaping: Which Trees Should We Plant?

Fire experts emphasize the need to replace highly flammable trees like Mexican fan palms and eucalyptus with fire-resistant species such as oak, sycamore, and toyon, while also strengthening home fire defenses to reduce wildfire risks in California.

February 18 - Los Angeles Times

Aerial view of Fremont, California.

Fremont, California Criminalizes Homelessness, “Abetting” Encampments

Non-profits worry the ordinance, which does not explicitly exempt service providers, will have a chilling effect on unhoused residents and those who offer resources.

February 18 - The Guardian

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.