How Zoning Reform Can Help Businesses Transition to Outdoor Operations
First reports about cities allowing restaurants and retail businesses to spill out onto streets and into parking spaces started earlier this month and haven't let up. First it was Brookhaven, Georgia, then came Tampa, Florida and Hinsdale, Illinois. Now, people in cities as large as New York City, Houston, and Denver are having very public discussions about how to make al fresco commercial activity the new normal, and the Ned Lamont, the governor of Connecticut, took the extraordinary step of removing parking minimums for outdoor restaurant and retail activities, in addition to suspending some permitting processes and expediting approvals for outdoor activities.
Planners looking for ways to support their communities through the economic and public health impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic are thus presented with an obvious opportunity. An article by Sara Bronin, chair of Hartford, Connecticut's Planning and Zoning Commission, digs into some of the specific zoning reforms that can help pave the way for the transition to al fresco commercial activities. Bronin commences this discussion with the frank assessment that local zoning laws have been written to prevent exactly this kind of outdoor commercial activity for decades in the United States. Paris is illegal in the United States, according to Bronin.
What would it take to make a more Parisian built environment in the United States? Zoning reform, says Bronin. And the parts of the zoning code that can have the most benefit to businesses during the pandemic have to do with parking, as already put into action by Gov. Lamont in Connecticut, and described here by Bronin:
But it’s parking that will likely be the biggest barrier to moving indoor activities outside. With car use plummeting during the COVID-19 pandemic, many parking lots are sitting idle. Spots are likely to remain at least partly empty given that businesses will have to limit the number of patrons inside. Even if restrictions were completely lifted today, it will take months, maybe even a year or more — to fill these lots again. For grocers, restauranteurs, bar owners, and retailers, the possibility of converting these lots into usable space has a lot of appeal. But zoning laws will prevent most conversions, because of requirements that each lot has a minimum number of parking spaces.
For more ideas about how zoning codes can be revised to support more outdoor commercial activities, Broning cites a comprehensive rezoning process approved in Hartford several years before the onset of the pandemic, which included removing minimum parking requirements for all buildings.