Social Equity Cited in Veto of California Road Pricing Bill

Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed a unique road pricing bill due to concerns that charging a fee would limit access to driving on two blocks of Lombard Street, a popular tourist attraction in San Francisco that is severely congested.

October 18, 2019, 2:00 PM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


San Francisco, California

REPORT / Shutterstock

Assembly Bill 1605, the "Crooked Street Reservation and Pricing Program," was not a prototypical congestion or cordon pricing bill that would permit a Manhattan-like program, but it would have forced tourists to pay to drive on a public road, not unlike motorists being charged to park on a public street. Unlike parking charges, though, state legislation is required in California before cities can charge driving fees on roads they manage.

With over a million vehicles driving the “crooked street" section of Lombard Street located between Leavenworth Street and Hyde Street annually, the San Francisco County Transportation Authority devised a Lombard Crooked Street project and settled on a reservation and pricing program that Assemblyman Phil Ting introduced as legislation. The bill passed the legislature last month.

Kate Larsen, reporting from Lombard Street for the local ABC network affiliate (see the video in source article), notes that the critical component of the plan was not the fee, but the reservation element.

"The issue is not the fee, the issue is limiting the number of permits sold, to the capacity of the street," said Steve Taber, the transportation chair of the Russian Hill Neighbors association.

Taber is disappointed the Governor rejected the bill, since he views the reservations, not the fees, as the real solution to reducing congestion in his neighborhood. "You could give them away and you would still have a viable program because you would limit them."

Of course, with traditional highway congestion pricing, it's all about the fee, which increases with the level of congestion, often dynamically, meaning the toll would change every six minutes or so, ensuring that speeds do not drop below the federally mandated 45 mph.

Veto message

"As the former county supervisor representing this neighborhood, I am acutely aware of the need to address congestion and safety around Lombard Street," wrote Gov. Newsom, the former San Francisco mayor from 2004 to 2011, in his Oct. 12 veto message [pdf].

However, the pricing program proposed in this bill creates social equity issues. Access to this iconic attraction should be available to all, regardless of their ability to pay.

The fact that social equity was the key reason for the governor's veto does not augur well for real cordon pricing programs like those being considered for downtown San Francisco and Los Angeles. Social equity has proven to be a major challenge for the Los Angeles cordon pricing program. A "Road Pricing Equity Report and Toolkit" was prepared by a Bay Area nonprofit to deal with overcoming the controversial pricing aspect of cordon charges.

"I’m disappointed that the Governor vetoed AB 1605," Ting responded in an emailed statement.

Lombard Street draws up to 17,000 visitors per day on busy weekends and neither the presence of parking enforcement officers, nor the closure of the crooked segment has helped to alleviate congestion. The city is running out of options. I look forward to working with the Governor and local residents to resolve this public safety and quality of life issue.

Related in Planetizen on cordon pricing programs and legislation in California

Hat tip to the International Bridge, Tunnel and Turnpike Association Smart Brief.

Sunday, October 13, 2019 in ABC KGO TV 7 - San Francisco

A group of people gather in front of a row of small homes.

Georgia's First Tiny Home Village Now Open, and Sold Out

Eight single-family houses on a half-acre of land.

July 25, 2021 - Urbanize Atlanta

Tall buildings in Downtown Phoenix.

Arizona's Tallest Building Will Soon Be Vacant

The tallest building in the Grand Canyon State will enter a new era.

July 21, 2021 - KJZZ

Raleigh, North Carolina

It's Good to Be a Small Business in These 6 U.S. Cities

Here are six U.S. cities where small companies are thriving.

July 20, 2021 - Devin Partida

Junior Designer

Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates

Executive Director/Administrator of City Planning

Chattanooga-Hamilton County Regional Planning Agency/City of Chattanooga

Assistant Planner

City of Willits

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.