Smart Growth Loves Heatmaps

Smart growth can provide many important benefits that are easy to see using informative and beautiful heatmaps—our complex world as viewed by all-knowing gods.

4 minute read

September 20, 2021, 12:00 PM PDT

By Todd Litman

A map showing a heat map that represents commute times in an urban area.

Mineta Transportation Institute / Commute Duration Dashboard

Smart Growth development policies create compact, multimodal communities. This can provide many benefits: residents of compact, multimodal neighborhoods tend to save on transportation costs, spend less time travelling, have lower traffic fatality rates, consume less energy and produce less pollution than they would if located in automobile-dependent areas. That information is great, but not always persuasive. Planners need to show people what these benefits look like.

New geographic information systems (GIS) allow us to see our complex world like all-knowing gods. With the right datasets you can produce color-coded heatmaps (or "choropleth" if you want to impress people with big words) showing how various factors vary from one area to another. In recent years, several organizations have developed dynamic mapping system that allow users to choose areas, data layers, filters, and presentation features. The results can be useful and beautiful. Let me share some of my favorites.

The Mineta Transportation Institute’s new Commute Duration Dashboard, illustrates commute duration (average minutes per commute) for most U.S. communities, plus residents' demographic data. One dashboard presents census tract data and another shows county level data. Below is the view of the Nashville, Tennessee region, a city of which I am particularly fond. Darker color indicates longer duration commutes. It shows that central neighborhood residents tend to spend significantly less time commuting than workers in outer suburbs, a pattern found in most urban regions. If you want a shorter commute, choose a Smart Growth neighborhood.

Mineta Transportation Institute Commute Duration Dashboard

Mineta Transportation Institute Commute Duration Dashboard

The map below, from Center for Neighborhood Technology’s Housing + Transportation Affordability Index, shows the portion of household budgets that households must devote to housing and transportation expenses for various Nashville neighborhoods. The maps can be adjusted to show housing or transportation affordability separately, and different affordability metrics. These maps indicate that central neighborhoods tend to offer the best value, particularly for lower-income families.

CNT Housing + Transportation Affordability Index 

CNT Housing + Transportation Affordability Index

UC Berkeley’s Cool Climate Maps shows household's carbon emissions, taking into account  emissions from transportation, housing, and consumer goods. The blue area in the center of the map also shows Nashville. It indicates that central neighborhood households produce far lower emissions, less than half, as residents of sprawled, automobile-dependent areas. If you want less pollution, support compact infill development.

UC Berkeley Cool Climate Maps

UC Berkeley Cool Climate Maps

Below is Nashville's Walk Score heatmap. Overall, the city rates poorly, a score of 28 out of 100, but some neighborhoods rate much better. You can find similar maps for Bike Scores and transit access. If you want more healthy and enjoyable exercise, locate in a central, walkable neighborhood.

Walk Score

Walk Score

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s National Walkability Index uses a sophisticated GIS mapping system to shows various metrics related to walking conditions. Once again I show Nashville, and once again central neighborhoods and the centers of small towns, rate far better than automobile-dependent sprawled areas.

U.S. EPA National Walkability Index

USEPA National Walkability Index

The Walking Index is just one of several GIS maps included in the U.S. EPA’s Smart Location Database, which shows various built environment metrics including density, diversity, design, transit quality, and accessibility. The map below shows the number of jobs reachable within a 45-minute transit trip in Nashville. Unsurprisingly, transit access is far better in central neighborhoods than in outlying areas. If you want more independent mobility and economic opportunity for non-drivers, build more affordable housing in central neighborhoods.

Access to Jobs and Workers Via Transit Tool

The TransitCenter Equity Dashboard shows local public transit performance factors including service intensity, affordability, reliability, access to opportunity, and travel times compared with automobile. Unfortunately, it currently only covers six U.S. urban regions but is expanding. Below is a heatmap showing the portion of jobs accessible by transit in the Los Angeles region.

TransitCenter Equity Dashboard

TransitCenter Equity Dashboard

Although these mapping systems reflect different impacts and perspectives, they all have similar results: more central, multimodal neighborhoods tend to perform much better.

However, heatmapping can be used inappropriately, when information is presented without accounting for all factors. For example, the map below shows Nashville's crime density, crimes per acre or hectare. This implies that central areas are most dangerous, but this does not account for other risk factors. Those central areas tend to have high population densities and lots of commercial activities that generate crimes. For example, bank robberies only occur in commercial centers where banks are located, and bar fights occur primarily in entertainment districts where there are lots of bars. This map does not really demonstrate that crime rates will increase, or that most people will experience more crime risk, by locating in a central neighborhood.

Nashville Crime Density Map

Nashville Crime Density Map

Knowledge is power, and heatmaps provide knowledge in a wonderfully accessible format. I love them, but use with caution! Be sure that you can explain what they illustrate, and be aware of how they may misrepresent key issues.

Todd Litman

Todd Litman is founder and executive director of the Victoria Transport Policy Institute, an independent research organization dedicated to developing innovative solutions to transport problems. His work helps to expand the range of impacts and options considered in transportation decision-making, improve evaluation methods, and make specialized technical concepts accessible to a larger audience. His research is used worldwide in transport planning and policy analysis.

Green rapid transit bus pulled into station in dedicated lane.

Indiana Once Again Considering Ban on Dedicated Transit Lanes

The proposed legislation would impact the construction of planned IndyGo Blue Line, the third phase of the city’s bus rapid transit system.

February 25, 2024 - Fox 59

View from shore of Sepulveda Basin water catchment basin with marsh plants along shore.

LA’s ‘Spongy’ Infrastructure Captured Almost 9 Billion Gallons of Water

The city is turning away from stormwater management practices that shuttle water to the ocean, building infrastructure that collects and directs it underground instead.

February 25, 2024 - Wired

View of 110 freeway with downtown Los Angeles buildings in background.

LA Freeway Ramp ‘Quietly Canceled’

A 2018 lawsuit forced Metro and Caltrans to do full environmental reviews of the project, leading to its cancellation.

February 29, 2024 - Streetsblog LA

Blue and white Pittsburgh bike share bikes lined up at a station with a red city bus on street in background.

Micromobility Operators Call for Better Links to Transit

For shared mobility to succeed, systems must tap into the connectivity and funding potential offered by closer collaboration with public transit.

3 hours ago - GovTech

New York MTA Bus

Retaining Transit Workers Is About More Than Wages

An analysis of California transit employees found a high rate of burnout among operators who face unpredictable work schedules, high housing costs, and occasional violence.

4 hours ago - Streetsblog California

View of Hollywood Reservoir with palm trees in foreground and Los Angeles neighobrhoods in background.

California's Stormwater Potential

A new study reveals that if California could collect and treat more stormwater in cities, it could provide enough water to supply a quarter of the state’s urban population.

6 hours ago - Cal Matters

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.