Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Gentrification and the Bay Area's Controversial Growth Management Plan

Is gentrification the inevitable result of land use planning that reduces greenhouse gas emissions by favoring infill development over auto-dependent sprawl? The Urban Displacement Project looks at the unintended effects of Plan Bay Area.
August 29, 2015, 7am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

Plan Bay Area, adopted to reduce transportation-cause greenhouse gas emissions as required by the landmark Sustainable Communities and Climate Protection Act of 2008 (aka SB 375), has survived four law suits. Now the MetropolitanTransportation Commission (MTC), which is implementing the plan along with the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG), and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), which approved the greenhouse gas reductions associated with the plan, "commissioned (a) study to examine the potential for low-income residents to be uprooted by implementation of Plan Bay Area," writes Richard Halstead for the Marin Independent Journal. 

The study was authorized "in response to concerns raised by advocates for low-income Bay Area residents," adds Halstead.

"Miriam Zuk, postdoctoral research fellow at the Center for Community Innovation at UC Berkeley's Institute Of Urban And Regional Development who directed the Urban Displacement Project," said the research project confirmed the findings of previous smaller-scale studies," writes Halstead.

“When you open up transit and create amenities around transit, property values go up,” Zuk said, “and when property values and rents go up, some people can no longer afford to live in those neighborhoods.

Halstead writes about two of the lowest income areas in Marin County that heretofore may not have been as affected by the ongoing Bay Area gentrification than wealthier enclaves: Marin City, population 2,666, which is unincorporated despite then name, and the Canal neighborhood of San Rafael, county seat and "Marin's largest city, with a population of 57,713," according to the Marin Independent Journal.

Canal Neighborhood:

According to the study, the Canal’s Hispanic population increased from 47 percent in 1990 to 80 percent in 2013; the neighborhood’s overall population grew by 50 percent between 1990 and 2013 without a commensurate increase in the stock of housing.

To afford rents, many Canal residents pack into units resulting in significant overcrowding. The study reports that “it is not uncommon for three to four families to live in one unit, each family living in one bedroom, with as many as ‘eight or more persons’ in a two-bedroom apartment.” There are many multifamily rental buildings located in the neighborhood.

The study concludes, “When the SMART train station opens in San Rafael, the Canal area will be at risk of gentrification.” It states that the “Canal’s limited area to develop new housing, high renter rate, high levels of poverty, low incomes, and lack of affordable housing put it potentially at risk for displacement.”

Marin City

(T)he study reports the African American population there decreased from 75 percent in 1980 to 42 percent in 2013. A third of Marin City’s population, some 698 people, live in public housing managed by the Marin Housing Authority.

“There is less risk of immediate displacement pressure in Marin City at least among the community that is in public housing,” Zuk said.

But, the study concludes, “There is a constant fear that these public housing units will be lost, given the area’s high land value and views of the Bay, as well as recent unfriendly policies and deferred maintenance.”

In "Can Gentrification Integrate Neighborhoods?", Philip Rojc, contributing editor at Planetizen, explores the same topic as it applies to Latino barrios in eastern Los Angeles.

The gentrification risks to Marin County tied to increased infill growth "conflict with the expectation of some Marin opponents of Plan Bay Area who predicted implementation of its policies would attract more low-income residents, not displace them," writes Halstead.

Listen to Zuk explain the Urban Displacement Project's findings in a call-in, half-hour radio show on KQED's Forum, "UC Berkeley Study: Gentrification Crisis is 'Not Yet Half Over'".

Full Story:
Published on Wednesday, August 26, 2015 in Marin Independent Journal
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email