Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Three States Hope to Take Advantage of Low Gas Prices to Boost Gas Taxes

A movement at the state and federal levels would take advantage of low oil prices to boost gas taxes to pay for infrastructure. Michigan, Iowa, and Utah proposals, and a change to the federal Corker-Murphy plan, are described below.
January 12, 2015, 6am PST | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

As a general rule, politicians are loath to touch gas taxes—unless to lower or eliminate them. "But the sharp drop in gasoline prices—to less than $2 a gallon at more than a third of U.S. stations—is brightening consumers’ moods, potentially taking the edge off raising state taxes," writes Josh Mitchell who covers the U.S. economy from The Wall Street Journal's Washington, D.C. bureau. 

On the state level, Mitchell writes about developments in three states with Republican governors:

  • "In Michigan, the GOP-controlled legislature approved a plan last month for a ballot initiative to boost the gas tax for road repairs [sic]." 
    • As we noted last month, the ballot measure asks voters to raise the general sales tax - exempting motor vehicle fuel. However, Jonathan Oostin of MLive indicates that if voters approve the May sales tax measure, it would trigger changes to the gas tax that would essentially do what Gov. Rick Snyder had proposed in November:
      • "Convert existing 19-cent per gallon gasoline and 15-cent per gallon diesel taxes to a wholesale version. Gas taxes could top 41 cents by October 2015, but there would be no additional sales tax, and all resulting revenue would go to transportation." [State gas taxes total 30.26 cents per gallon as of Jan 1 according to API (PDF)].
  • "In Iowa, Republican Gov. Terry Branstad is gauging lawmakers’ support for the first state gas-tax increase since 1989, among other options to raise transportation funds." 

In June, 2013, we noted that Branstad ruled out gas tax increases amidst a "Midwest gasoline price spike" ($4.47 per gallon in Chicago). According to the Jan. 9 AAA Daily Fuel Gauge Report, the average price in Iowa was $1.99 gallon.

William Petroski of The Des Moines Register writes that Branstad not only wants the votes to determine whether to increase the gas tax, but to have county by county referendums on "1 percent local option sales tax on gasoline and diesel fuel"

  • In Utah, Republican leaders in the state House signaled this week they are moving to raise the gas tax to cover a transportation-funding shortfall.
    • Lee Davidson of The Salt Lake City Tribune writes that legislators are proposing "not only to increase (the) gasoline tax — maybe by 10 cents a gallon — but also to restructure it so that it could automatically adjust once a year to keep pace with inflation." In addition, as we've seen elsewhere, legislation will include electric vehicle fees in the form of increased registration fees to compensate for not paying gas taxes.

Three states already have taken advantages of falling gas prices. Having approved gas taxes earlier that took effect Jan 1, motorists in Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland saw gas prices decline as falling global oil prices swallowed the tax increases, reports AASHTO Journal.

Similarly, California's carbon charge, estimated at 10-cents per gallon by the California Air Resources Board (CARB), arrived largely unnoticed on Jan. 1.

Mitchell writes about many developments on the federal level, one of the most interesting being a changed proposed by one of the co-authors of the only Senate tax increase measure currently under consideration—as a proposal, not as legislation.

To circumvent a backlash, Mr. Corker [R-Tenn.] is working with Democrats to couple a gas-tax increase with an income-tax break for the lowest earners. Instead of a standalone bill, the plan would be inserted into a broad package of legislation this year, such as one aimed at overhauling corporate taxes, Mr. Corker said.

Interestingly, this is exactly what was listed in the "Five Gas Tax Myths" post as a way to deal with the objection that gas taxes are regressive and hurt the poor. It may have been instrumental in getting the 4.3-cents gas tax increase passed in 1993, the last time the federal gas tax was raised.

Correspondent's note: Article appeared on page A2 of Friday's (Jan. 09) Wall Street Journal. The link should provide a "free pass".

Full Story:
Published on Friday, January 9, 2015 in The Wall Street Journal
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email