Learning from Down Under

The governors of Arizona, California, Florida, Texas, and other states where COVID-19 infections are threatening to overwhelm hospitals should consider what their counterpart in Victoria, Australia, did on July 7 to contain the coronavirus.

3 minute read

July 15, 2020, 11:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

Creative decorations for a tree on St. Kilda Road in Melbourne, pictured in April 2020. | Dave Hewison Photography / Shutterstock

"Metropolitan Melbourne will go into stage three lockdown for six weeks from 11.59pm on Wednesday [July 8] after the state [Victoria] recorded 191 new cases of coronavirus since Monday, the highest daily increase since the pandemic began," reported Josh Taylor and Melissa Davey for The Guardian on July 7.

The Victorian premier, Daniel Andrews, announced that people living in the Melbourne metropolitan area and Mitchell shire would again be subject to restrictions, meaning they can only leave their house for work, education, exercise, for necessary goods or services or for medical or compassionate reasons until 11.59pm on Wednesday 19 August.

Only 191 daily cases in Victoria, a state with over 6.6 million people, necessitate a shutdown? By contrast, look at the cases recorded by Worldometer on July 8 in U.S. states where the coronavirus is surging:

Texas: 10,199
Florida: 9,989
California: 8,561
Arizona: 3,520

Leadership

Andrews announced the return to stay-at-home restrictions on July 7. He "cited the rapid rise in cases in Melbourne and said it was unsustainable to keep the current restrictions in place," add Davey and Taylor.

“These are unsustainably high numbers of new cases, he said. “It is simply impossible with case rates at this level to have enough contact tracing staff, to have enough physical resources, no matter where they come from, no matter what uniform they wear, in order to continue to suppress and contain this virus without taking significant steps."

What about the U.S.?

"I think any state that is having a serious problem, that state should seriously look at shutting down," said Anthony S. Fauci, the nation’s top infectious-disease official, in a Wall Street Journal podcast on Wednesday.

He softened his tone on Thursday, telling The Hill's Steve Clemons, "Rather than think in terms of reverting back down to a complete shutdown, I would think we need to get the states pausing in their opening process." CNN also reported on the interview:

"Not to be hyperbolic about it -- it really is the perfect storm and (an) infectious disease and public health person's worst nightmare. It's a spectacularly transmissible virus," he said. "The efficiency with which this transmits is really striking."

Four states that account for about 50% of new infections -- Arizona, California, Florida and Texas -- need to aggressively keep people socially distanced, including by closing bars and preventing crowds, he said.

Another health expert echoed Fauci's initial comment about second shutdowns.

"If you're not doing the ... things we've talked about in the past to get this outbreak under control, starting with test and trace ... your only option is to shut down," Dr. Ali Khan, former director of the CDC's public health preparedness office, told CNN's "New Day" Thursday.

U.S is not Australia

Comparing states in America with states in Australia is not a fair comparison in the age of COVID-19. Australia is a coronavirus success story, in a league with its neighbor, New Zealand. To date, 106 people have died from the virus, the same rate, 4 per million, as New Zealand, according to Worldometer. Over 135,000 Americans have died from COVID-19, a rate of 410 per million.

A final note on the so-called lockdown in Melbourne: it's not. It's a stay-at-home order that includes a shutdown of nonessential businesses, very similar to what all but eight governors in the U.S. issued in March and April during the first surge of the pandemic. Residents can leave their homes for shopping and exercise without documentation just as they did in the U.S.

Related in Planetizen:

Coronavirus Success Stories [New Zealand], June 8, 2020
What Can Vancouver Teach Melbourne? November 23, 2014
How Jan Gehl Turned Melbourne into a Pedestrian Paradise, June 24, 2013

FULL STORY: Coronavirus Australia: Melbourne in six-week lockdown after Victoria records 191 new cases

Tuesday, July 7, 2020 in The Guardian

Community / Economic Development Government / Politics Social / Demographics Australia United States Arizona California Florida Texas Melbourne Mitchell Shire Victoria COVID 19 Coronavirus Coronavirus Restrictions Coronavirus Success Lockdown Second Shutdown Shutdown of Nonessential Businesses Stay At Home Order Daniel Andrews Melissa Davey Anthony S. Fauci Ali Khan Josh Taylor View More

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Cover CM Credits, Earn Certificates, Push Your Career Forward

Learn More

Advertise with us

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.