Judge Rules Tolls Are Taxes to Dismiss Truckers' Lawsuit Against Rhode Island

The nation's sole truck-only tolling program survived its first lawsuit after a federal judge dismissed litigation brought by the American Trucking Associations, ruling that the proper venue was state court. ATA believes it is unconstitutional.

3 minute read

March 27, 2019, 11:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Toll Road Truck

View Factor Images / Shutterstock

The ruling hands a victory to Rhode Island Department of Transportation Director Peter Alviti, who in August had filed a motion in the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island to have the lawsuit dismissed, reports Eleanor Lamb for Transport Topics on March 20.

In his plea for the suit’s dismissal, Alviti cited the Tax Injunction Act [TIA], which restricts the power of federal district courts to prevent the collection or enforcement of state taxes, and the 11th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

Note that Chief Judge William E. Smith did not rule on the merits of the lawsuit, American Trucking Associations [ATA] v. Alvitia, Rhode Island Department of Transportationfiled in the same district court a month earlier, which dealt with the issue of whether the toll program “impedes the flow of interstate commerce.” Rather, his ruling dealt with the issue of court venue.

“The facts are clear that the fees, while dubbed tolls, are really a highly targeted and sophisticated tax designed to fund infrastructure maintenance and improvements that would otherwise need to be paid for by other forms of tax-generated revenue,” Smith’s decision said. 

“As such, the court is without jurisdiction under the TIA; the federal case must be dismissed and ultimately heard in the courts of Rhode Island.”

Why truck-only tolls?

The court document notes that, according to the General Assembly, large trucks cause 70% of the damage to Rhode Island’s roads and bridges, but contribute less than 20% of the state’s annual revenue for infrastructure projects.

In neighboring Connecticut, new Democratic Governor Ned Lamont had campaigned on the issue of truck-only tolls, viewing Rhode Island as a model, but has since changed his position to include passenger vehicles in the toll schedule so as to capture more revenue.

Not giving up

Matt Cole, news editor for Commercial Carrier Journal, reports on March 21 that American Trucking Association will likely pursue their case in state court.

“ATA is reviewing the decision and considering next steps but looks forward to vindicating its underlying claims on the merits, whatever the venue," said ATA Deputy General Counsel Rich Pianka.

ATA claims that it is the selective manner in which the tolls are applied, not the fact that only heavy-duty trucks are being tolled, that violates the constitution's interstate commerce clause. Lamb explains:

Under Rhode Island’s toll system, a hauler within the state who needed to pass through one gantry repeatedly for dispatches would be charged less than a trucker moving through the state who encountered multiple gantries.

ATA’s lawsuit argued that truck tolls discriminate against interstate commerce. If a state charges a user fee for access to channels of interstate commerce, that fee has to be a fair approximation of use and cannot discriminate between in-state and out-of-state interests.

With the current litigation now resolved to the Rhode Island Department of Transportation's satisfaction, it remains to be seen how fast they can construct eleven tolling gantries to complete the truck-tolling system. A shortfall of revenue caused the department last month to cut $28 million from bicycle and pedestrian projects and trim $96 million from its highway repaving budget.

Wednesday, March 20, 2019 in Transport Topics

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Use Code 25for25 at checkout for 25% off an annual plan!

Redlining map of Oakland and Berkeley.

Rethinking Redlining

For decades we have blamed 100-year-old maps for the patterns of spatial racial inequity that persist in American cities today. An esteemed researcher says: we’ve got it all wrong.

1 hour ago - Alan Mallach

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

May 14, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Front of Walmart store with sign.

Walmart Announces Nationwide EV Charging Network

The company plans to install electric car chargers at most of its stores by 2030.

May 7, 2025 - Inc.

Public Market sign over Pike Place Market in Seattle, Washington with pop-up booths on street.

Seattle’s Historic Pike Place Market Leans Into Pedestrian Infrastructure

After decades of debate, the market is testing a car ban in one of its busiest areas and adding walking links to the surrounding neighborhood.

5 seconds ago - Cascade PBS

Yellow and silver light rain train in downtown Long Beach, California.

The World’s Longest Light Rail Line is in… Los Angeles?

In a city not known for its public transit, the 48.5-mile A Line is the longest of its kind on the planet.

2 hours ago - Secret Los Angeles

Man reaching for young girl sliding down playground slide.

Quantifying Social Infrastructure

New developments have clear rules for ensuring surrounding roads, water, and sewers can handle new users. Why not do the same for community amenities?

3 hours ago - Happy Cities