EPA Targets Co-Benefits in Rulemaking—Public Health to Suffer

The Environmental Protection Agency proposed a critical change in the cost-benefit analysis used in the mercury rule that applies to coal-fired power plants. By eliminating the principle of co-benefits, public health impacts would be severe.

3 minute read

January 3, 2019, 2:00 PM PST

By Irvin Dawid

Global warming and pollution

Chris_LeBoutillier / Pixabay

"The Environmental Protection Agency on Friday proposed a major change in the way the federal government calculates the costs and benefits of dangerous air pollutants, arguing that authorities should exclude some of the public health benefits stemming from new rules," report Brady Dennis Juliet Eilperin  for The Washington Post on Dec. 28. 

The proposal, which revisits a 2011 rule limiting mercury emissions from coal plants, argues EPA lacked justification to curb the neurotoxin in the first place because many benefits stemmed from the overall drop in air pollution that would occur once power companies adopted new technologies.

Rather than rolling back the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (MATS) rule, the EPA proposes to revise the calculation used to determine the health benefits of the rule, specifically attacking the use of co-benefits which result when other pollutants, such as particulate pollution and nitrogen oxide, are also reduced by the new equipment used to reduce mercury emissions.

The MATS rule applies only to coal-fired power plants, the nation’s single biggest emitter of mercury, and oil-powered plants, which "produced less than 1% of total electricity generation during 2016," according to the Energy Information Administration. Mercury is essentially not emitted by natural gas-fired power plants.

By not allowing co-benefits, the cost-benefit analysis works against installing the new equipment, as most of the health benefits are gained by reducing other pollutants, and the costs of adding the pollution-control equipment are exponentially greater than the health benefits gained by mercury reduction alone.

“I just think it’s a little fuzzy math when you say, ‘Reduce mercury and we have all these other benefits over here,’ as the shiny object,” EPA acting administrator Andrew Wheeler saidin an interview with The Washington Post this fall.

But the environmental and public health community view the dismantling of the rulemaking calculation far differently.

“There is no legitimate justification for this action,” Harold P. Wimmer, chief executive of the American Lung Association, said in a statement, adding that the regulation had been effective not just in limiting mercury, but also emissions of carcinogens such as arsenic, chromium and nickel, as well as toxic acid gases that form particle pollution, which causes asthma attacks, heart attacks and premature death.

“EPA’s proposal to undermine the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards is one of its most dangerous efforts yet.”

The new rule stems from a Supreme Court case in 2015 where the Obama MATS rule was invalidated and remanded to the the DC Circuit Court of Appeals while Obama's EPA reworked the cost-benefit analysis. Eilperin and Dennis explain the subsequent events that led to Friday's proposal.


Friday, December 28, 2018 in The Washington Post

View of downtown Los Angeles at golden hour from top of grassy hill with wooden bench in Vista Hermosa Natural Park

Downtown Los Angeles Park Wins National Award

Vista Hermosa Natural Park, designed by the landscape architecture firm Studio-MLA, has won the ASLA 2023 Landmark Award. Completed in 2008, Vista Hermosa was the first public park built in downtown L.A. in over 100 years.

September 11, 2023 - ASLA The Dirt

View of small-town street with brick buildings and cars parked in diagonal parking with string lights going across street in Cleveland County, Oklahoma.

Norman, Oklahoma Eliminates Parking Mandates

The city made a subtle, one-word change that frees up developers to build parking based on actual need and eliminates costly unnecessary parking.

September 14, 2023 - Next City

Few passengers waiting in subway station with multiple platforms and "North Station" signs in Boston, Massachusetts

Boston Transit Riders Report Safety Concerns

Almost three-quarters of current and former riders report feeling unsafe while using MBTA services.

September 18, 2023 - Hoodline

Mosaic mural at Little Tokyo/Arts District transit station in downtown Los Angeles.

Prioritizing Equity in Federal Transit Funding

TransitCenter recommends several transit capital projects deserving of federal transportation dollars.

September 20 - TransitCenter

Close-up of top of California state capitol dome with U.S. and California flags flying and blue sky in background.

California Housing Bills Streamline Affordable Housing

A series of current and proposed bills are paving the way for more affordable housing production in the state, where environmental laws are often deployed to delay or block new development.

September 20 - CALmatters

Main Street in Bentonville, Arkansas with three-story brick buildings, people sitting at tables on sidewalk, and sign on building for "The Walmart Museum."

Growing Pains in Northwest Arkansas

Like other small communities suddenly made popular during the Covid-19 pandemic, the region is struggling to maange its explosive growth.

September 20 - Axios

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.