AAA Study: Auto Ownership More Cost-Effective Than Ride-Hailing

Even after factoring in insurance, parking, depreciation, fuel, repair, maintenance and licensing, urban dwellers would pay half the costs to travel, on average, nearly 11,000 miles annually in their own new car rather than relying on ride-hailing.

August 25, 2018, 11:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

"A new study from AAA finds that it can cost city residents twice as much to use ride-hailing services than it would to cover the same mileage in a car they own, even factoring in the cost of fuel, insurance and parking," reports Jason Plautz for Smart Cities Dive.

The study found that it would cost the average city dweller $20,118 a year to rely solely on ride-hailing services, compared to $10,049 a year in a new car including parking costs.

For urban dwellers with access to unpriced parking, "relying on ride-hailing services is nearly three times more expensive than vehicle ownership in these cities," according to the auto association's press release. Cost savings would be even greater by purchasing a used vehicle.

According to data from AAA’s annual Your Driving Costs study, the average annual cost to own and operate a new vehicle, the costliest form of vehicle ownership, is $7,321 for 10,841 miles of travel annually...Depreciation is the single largest expense for vehicle owners. By driving a pre-owned vehicle in good condition, ownership costs are significantly lower

"Whether you own a vehicle or not, ride-hailing services are a convenient transportation option,” said John Nielsen, managing director, Automotive Engineering and Repair. “However, with the average American city-dweller driving nearly 11,000 miles per year, a personal vehicle is still the more cost-effective choice.”

"Notably, the AAA study does not account for driving trips replaced by public transit, which is far cheaper per-mile than ride-hailing and can be used as a replacement for driving, depending on the scope of transit networks in a given city," adds Plautz. Biking, walking, and scooting should also reduce ride-hailing trips.

The July 2018 study, prepared by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, appears in the form of a 2-page "fact sheet" that can be downloaded from the Aug. 21 news release.

AAA found that "[o]n average, those using ride-hailing services spent an average of $13.15 per trip, spending 15.11 minutes and traveling 6.66 miles. Ride-hailing costs include the occasional use of rental vehicles for longer distance travel. Full methodology can be found in the study’s fact sheet."

Other studies

In the "Dive Insight" section, Plautz points to two earlier studies that did not appearentirleyconsistent with the findings from the AAA study:

Writing in The Conversation [October 15, 2017], F. Todd Davidson and Michael E. Webber of the Energy Institute at the University of Texas at Austin calculated that one-quarter of the entire U.S. driving population would be better off relying solely on services like Lyft and Uber, factoring in the value of time spent in traffic

The Kleiner Perkins 2018 Internet Trends Report found that in four of the five largest U.S. cities  New York City, Chicago, Washington, DC and Los Angeles  ride-hailing was cheaper than car ownership, but the reverse was true in Dallas.

Lyft claims that "[i]n 2017 alone, almost a quarter of a million passengers on its platform dropped owning a personal vehicle, due to the availability of ridesharing specifically," according to TechCrunch writer Darrell Etherington.

One of the first studies to "quantify how the uptick in transportation network companies might be affecting consumer behavior" was performed by researchers at the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, Texas A&M Transportation Institute and Columbia University, reported Nicole Casal Moore for the University of Michigan News on August 10, 2017. The study was unique because it was based on surveys in Austin after the city banned Uber and Lyft in May 2016.

The study found that 41 percent of those surveyed turned to their own vehicle to fill the void left by Uber and Lyft. Nine percent actually bought an additional car for this purpose.

The researchers found a correlation between the level of inconvenience reported and the likelihood that a survey participant would buy a car. Inconvenienced residents were more than five times more likely to buy a car.

Wednesday, August 22, 2018 in Smart Cities Dive

Soldier Field

Phase 1 Revealed for $20 Billion Chicago Megaproject

Plans for One Central, a proposed megadevelopment that would add 22.3 million square feet of buildings to the city of Chicago, are taking shape.

October 19, 2021 - Chicago Tribune


Boston Introduces 'Maximum Parking Ratios' for Large Buildings

Large buildings with uses of all kinds will be subject to Boston's new "Maximum Parking Ratios."

October 14, 2021 - Streetsblog Mass

GIS Mobile App

Survey: What Mobile Apps Are Most Useful for Planning in 2021?

Planetizen is requesting your input in creating the definitive list of mobile apps for professional, student, academic, or citizen planners—updated for a planning profession forever altered by the Covid-19 pandemic.

October 18, 2021 - Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.