Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Bay Area Home Prices Rise Despite Out-Migration

Kathleen Pender, business columnist for the San Francisco Chronicle, points to two reasons why home prices rise amidst a Bay Area exodus to other states. On a state level, out-migration shows California's strong but dysfunctional economy.
May 13, 2018, 11am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments
Andrey Bayda

"If you look just at domestic migration — people moving around the country — the Bay Area lost about 46,000 people more than it gained during the year that ended July 1, according to U.S. Census Bureau estimates released March 22 ," reports Pender on May 4. In other words, the region's net domestic migration was negative 46,000.

That net loss was nearly twice as big as the previous year and marked a turnaround from earlier years, when more people were coming to the Bay Area than leaving.

One thing these stories [in the national media hyping the Bay Area exodus based on Redfin report] mostly failed to mention is that net immigration — people coming from and leaving for other countries — is still positive in the Bay Area. About 58,000 more people came here from abroad than left last year, surpassing the nearly 46,000 who decamped for other states. (The census estimates included the nine-county Bay Area and three neighboring counties.*)

See Chronicle image [jpg] showing immigration and domestic migration graphs for the greater 12-county Bay Area.

A second reason deals with the wealth of the Bay Area's migrants, both those coming and going. While those leaving are getting wealthier, reaching $81,500 median household income in 2016, in-migrant households are wealthier, with $90,000 median household incomes that year. The contrast is much greater for the state as a whole, according to a newly released report described below.


California out-migration amidst economic growth – new report highlights dysfunction

While the Bay Area may have experienced net domestic in-migration until recently, the Golden State has endured net domestic out-migration for almost three decades, while continuing to grow modestly due largely to natural increase, i.e., births minus deaths, and to a lesser extent, net positive immigration, reaching 39,810,000 residents in 2017.

Courtesy California Legislative Analyst's Office

County-level migration and immigration data is available from the Demographic Research Unit of the California Department of Finance's Dec. 27, 2017 report [pdf], posted here. Note that the last column, "Net Domestic Migration," on Figure E2, beginning on page 5, refers to both intrastate and interstate domestic migration, according to state demographer Phuong Nguyen.

According to a report released May 3 by San Francisco-based think tank Next 10, which looked at housing, migration and employment trends, the state "lost nearly 1.1 million more people to other states than it gained from 2006 to 2016," adds Pender.

It concluded that “the main driver for net out-migration appears to be high housing costs,” not high state income taxes. That’s because the “vast majority of people who moved out of California were concentrated in lower-skilled, lower-paying fields, namely sales, transportation and food preparation.” 

“California has seen a net inflow of residents who earn more than $50,000 annually, have bachelor’s or advanced degrees, and work in high-skilled occupations. This is especially true for the Bay Area, where high salaries and abundant job opportunities outweigh the high cost of living,” the report said.

On May 4, the Associated Press reported that California edged-out the United Kingdom to claim the #5 stop in the world's strongest economies, after the U.S., China, Japan and Germany. "But a strong economy can also be dysfunctional, and not all Californians are benefitting," states the executive summary [pdf] of the report, prepared by Beacon Economics.

The state is experiencing shifting population dynamics driven by high housing costs and changes in the employment make-up of California residents.

MarketWatch also wrote about the Next 10 report on May 6: "With no letup in home prices, the California exodus surges."

Footnotes: *The Combined Statistical Area, or CSA, a U.S. Census term, for the 9-county Bay Area includes the three counties of San JoaquinSanta Cruz, and San Benito that do not border San Francisco or San Pablo Bay, but are economically tied to the nine counties.

Full Story:
Published on Friday, May 4, 2018 in San Francisco Chronicle
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email