Drivers: Beware Following GPS Navigation Instructions Too Closely

For the second time at the same railroad crossing in Atherton, California, a motorist followed his GPS navigation onto Caltrain tracks. In both cases, the motorists fled their vehicles before being hit by an oncoming train.

3 minute read

February 13, 2018, 11:00 AM PST

By Irvin Dawid


dennizn / Shutterstock

The car hit Saturday night was a classic, 1950s-era Autin-Healey, identifiable by its grill, about the only recognizable part remaining after being dragged about a quarter-mile by a southbound Caltrain baby bullet. The crash occurred shortly after Caltrain #804 left the Redwood City station at 8:07 pm, heading for its next stop, Palo Alto.

"After extinguishing the vehicle fire, Menlo Park firefighters were able to free what was left of the classic car by 10:26 p.m. using the jaws of life and other extrication equipment to (release) the twisted metal and debris from under the much larger locomotive,” the fire district said in a statement, reports the Daily Post staff on Feb. 10.

No injuries were reported onboard the train. The 349 passengers were transferred to the next southbound about two hours later according to Adrian Brandt, who was monitoring Caltrain radio transmissions.

The San Mateo County Sheriff's Department reports "that the driver turned onto the track while using GPS and got stuck," according to NBC Bay Area.

"[Menlo Park] Fire Chief Harold Schapelhouman said this is the second car that has been stuck at this crossing and caught fire," adds the Post.

“The last time this occurred in December of 2014, a driver following his navigation system on a dark and rainy night turned onto the tracks and the vehicle became stuck. Fortunately, in both of these cases, the drivers were able to escape from their vehicles before being struck by a southbound passenger train,” Schapelhouman said.

Last October, a similar, GPS navigation-caused crash occurred at a Caltrain crossing in Palo Alto, just a few miles south. Fortunately, the driver and his passengers abandoned the rental car and no passengers or crew were injured on the train.

Special Four Quad Gates Irrelevant

The scene of Saturday's crash, the Fair Oaks Lane crossing adjacent to the Atherton station, open only weekends but not served by express trains, is also the first and only "quiet zone" on the San Francisco-to-San Jose Caltrain line, the nation's third busiest commuter rail line when measured by ridership per mile.

Extra safety precautions must be installed at these locations that don't require locomotives to routinely blast their horns, such as four-quadrant gates which have proven very effective in preventing crashes caused by motorists attempting to "beat the train" by driving around conventional two-quad gates. However, their application is limited to when the gates have been engaged, i.e., before a train approaches.

An "Analysis of Safety at Quiet Zones" [pdf] released by the Federal Rail Administration (FRA) in 2014 found "[n]o significant difference in collisions before and after the establishment of quiet zones."

Not an anomaly

GPS navigation-related incidents at rail crossings occur more frequently than one might imagine, although the FRA doesn't quantify them. In 2016, 2,025 highway-rail crossing collisions occurred, resulting in 265 fatalities, according to the FRA. One of the more deadly ones, and the first to officially be linked to GPS, occurred in February 2015 after a truck drove onto Metrolink tracks in Oxnard, Calif. The resulting crash derailed the train, killing the engineer, who was operating the train in the front cab car.

"What made this crash stand out was the possible role of digital mapping technology in taking a driver down a wrong path," reported Daisuke Wakabayashi for The New York Times on Dec. 19, 2016. "This was the first time the [National Transportation Safety Board] has targeted navigation apps as a factor in a major accident."

Audio warning?

Reporting for the Hartford Courant on a more deadly train crash, also is February 2015 but at a Metro-North grade crossing in Valhalla, N.Y. that was not linked to the motorist using a navigation app, Don Stacom wrote in March, 2016 that "[s]ome analysts have suggested that vehicle navigation systems play a role in crashes, because drivers follow the GPS directions but don't get an audio warning that they're approaching railroad tracks.

The FRA last spring reached an agreement with Google to have rail crossing information used in its navigation systems, and the agency is trying to get Garmin and other GPS producers to do likewise."

Hat tip to Adrian Brandt.

Saturday, February 10, 2018 in (Palo Alto) Daily Post

Aerial view of homes on beach in Maui, Hawaii

Hawaii Passes First Legislation Regulating Short-Term Rentals Statewide

The new law will give counties the power to limit number or short-term rentals and convert existing short-term rental units back into long-term residential housing.

May 13, 2024 - USA Today

Entrance to a drive-through car wash at night with green 'Enter' sign.

Ohio Towns Move to Ban New Car Washes

City officials in northeast Ohio are putting limits on how many car wash facilities can open in their towns.

May 16, 2024 - News 5 Cleveland

Rail tracks on the left, rustic log-built train station painted reddish brown with a green metal roof and concrete platform on the right, evergreen forest and bright blue sky with fluffy white clouds in the background.

More Passenger Rail Coming to Montana

Planning is underway to restore a 45-year-defunct regional passenger rail line connecting southern Montana to Billings and Amtrak’s east-west Empire Builder line from Seattle to Chicago.

May 14, 2024 - 8KPAX

Apartment For Rent Sign

HUD Proposal Would Soften ‘One-Strike’ Policy

Formerly incarcerated people are often barred from publicly subsidized housing, putting them at higher risk for homelessness and recidivism.

2 hours ago - Truthout

Water flowing through Glendale Narrows section of Los Angeles River in Glendale, California with a concrete bridge, power lines, and hills in background.

Los Angeles County Making Progress in Stormwater Capture

During this “super year” of storms, L.A. County has successfully captured 96 billion gallons of stormwater which is enough to meet the needs of about 2.4 million people a year.

3 hours ago - Los Angeles Times

Aerial Texas Hill Country at sunset, with an aerial view of a highway interchange and Interstate 35 in Austin, Texas.

The True Cost of Texas Highways

An explainer of the monetary, environmental, and social costs of exuberant road building.

4 hours ago - KERA News

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.