Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Three Es of Grade Crossing Safety: Focus on Enforcement

Education, Engineering, and Enforcement. MTA police are taking the last one very seriously at grade crossings they monitor on the Metro-North and LIRR lines since the February crash in Westchester County that killed five passengers and a motorist.
April 13, 2015, 6am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

"As a result of the Valhalla [Westchester County] crash, the [Metropolitan Transportation Authority] MTA Police have ramped up their enforcement efforts at railroad crossings in New York City’s suburbs," writes Joseph De AvilaWall Street Journal's metro reporter for greater New York.

Credit: FHWA Railroad-Highway Grade Crossing Handbook

"The highway unit patrols about 90 railroad crossings for Metro-North and nearly another 300 for the Long Island Rail Road [LIRR]," adds De Avila. Special attention is given to "hot spots" based on "the volume of cars, pedestrians and train traffic." 

Judging from the number of summons written, they are indeed serious. "MTA Police issued 326 summons from Jan. 1 to March 30, a marked increase from the 212 issued in all of 2014," he writes.

In fact, he begins his piece describing a motorist being cited who had successfully cleared the descending railroad gate, but who had entered "the area," which he doesn't' specify but presumably is the space before the gates with the large "RXR" stenciled on the asphalt.

Officer Stanton gave the driver a summons for “driving through, under or around a railroad crossing barrier.” A conviction for a first offense is punishable by fines between $250 to $400 and or up to 30 days in jail.

“You shouldn’t be entering that area while lights are flashing and the gates are up or going in the upward or downward motion,” Officer Stanton said in an interview after issuing the summons last month.

While the particular incident that sparked the above ticket was unusual - the gates had lifted after a Metro-North train passed followed by the gates descending before a train going in the opposite direction approached, the citation itself wasn't.

About a third of the 2015 summonses were for driving under or around the gates. The remainder were for other offenses like texting or driving without a seat belt.

A major offense that officers watch for is described as "vehicles obstructing the railroad crossing." 

Vehicles obstructing railroad crossings typically occur when a car approaches the crossing but can’t pass completely through because of traffic, Officer Stanton said.

One of my local papers, in describing a horrific crash in February at a Caltrain crossing in Menlo Park, Calif., described this as being "boxed in," implying in my opinion, that it was a freak accident of sorts.

De Avila goes on to describe individual incidents of drivers in Westchester County being cited by Officer Stanton.

The crackdown may have been precipitated in part by local Congresswoman Nita Lowey who has put pressure "on the federal government to bolster education and enforcement campaigns" at grade crossings, according to her Feb. 6 press release.

Hat tip to Heather Caygle of Politico Morning Transportation.

Full Story:
Published on Tuesday, April 7, 2015 in The Wall Street Journal
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email