A Theory of Gentrification—And Where It Goes Wrong

Does gentrification always follow massive disinvestment?

4 minute read

November 1, 2019, 5:00 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn

Brooklyn, New York City

Alessio Catelli / Shutterstock

In Capital City, a new book that promotes socialist solutions to New York City's housing crisis, Samuel Stein focuses heavily on gentrification, despite the ample evidence that gentrification is in fact fairly rare (which I have discussed here). 

More interesting to me,* however, is his description of how gentrification happens. He writes that cities suffer from a long-term process of "capital flow…first comes investment in a built environment; second, neighborhood disinvestment in property abandonment, and third reinvestment in that same space for greater profits." This statement suggests that gentrification occurs primarily in disinvested neighborhoods. If this was the case, gentrification would occur most frequently in a city’s poorest neighborhoods: for example, the West Side of Chicago. 

But in fact, gentrification often occurs in neighborhoods that are not the most disinvested. For example, a recent study of Chicago neighborhoods by Harvard Prof. Robert Sampson shows that black neighborhoods (which, in Chicago, tend to be the poorest) are far less likely to gentrify than white working-class and Latino areas. Similarly, many of Brooklyn's recently gentrified areas, such as North Williamsburg and Greenpoint, were historically white areas. These areas tend to be less poor than the most disinvested areas; in 2000, zip code 11222 (Greenpoint) had a 17 percent poverty rate, roughly comparable to the citywide average. (Williamsburg's zip code has always been poorer because it includes lower-income Hasidic Jews.)

If gentrification is not a response to disinvestment, how does it come about? Here's my alternative theory: most middle-class people tend to prefer short commutes from neighborhoods that they perceive as safe neighborhoods (a category that usually excludes a city's poorest neighborhoods). So if housing were free and abundant, nearly everyone with jobs near central business districts would prefer to live in rich areas near downtown, like New York's Tribeca or Chicago's Gold Coast.

In reality, of course, these desirable areas tend to be more expensive than other areas, because demand for them is high. So if you are priced out of the Gold Coast, where would you live? If your only goal was cheap rent, you would live in a distant suburb or an extremely low-income urban neighborhood. But if you also value safety or a short commute, you might prefer to pay an intermediate amount of rent—which means to live in an area that is only somewhat cheaper than an elite urban neighborhood, but is closer to downtown and safer than the distant suburb or poor neighborhood. Thus, middle-class people priced out of elite neighborhoods might go just a neighborhood or two away from the neighborhood they are priced out of—for example, people priced out of downtown Philadelphia live in Northern Liberties just northeast of downtown, South Philadelphia just south of downtown, or the University City area just west of downtown. Similarly, people priced out of Manhattan's elite neighborhoods go to the outer borough neighborhoods closest to Manhattan rather than going to cheaper outer-borough neighborhoods farthest from Manhattan, and people priced out of Chicago's ritzy lakefront areas go to neighborhoods just west of the lakefront or to the south side of downtown Chicago, rather than to Chicago's truly poor areas. In turn, people priced out of near-downtown neighborhoods sometimes go just a little farther out instead of moving to suburbia. Thus, people priced out of the Brooklyn neighborhoods closest to Manhattan may move to Bushwick or Crown Heights a bit farther out, rather than moving to the outer edges of Brooklyn or to suburbia. 

This doesn't mean that gentrifiers never move to poor, disinvested areas; Bushwick is certainly an example of an area that was extremely poor for many decades but is becoming more middle-class. But if they do, it is because such areas are tempting for other reasons, not just because of past disinvestment.

*I note that this point is not at all necessary to Stein's main argument; I just wrote about it because I think it is intellectually interesting. His main argument, to oversimplify radically, is that 1) New York had a housing boom in the last two decades, 2) this boom led to gentrification rather than to lower housing prices, and 3) therefore market-rate housing is bad.  In this blog post, I criticize Stein's first assumption.  

Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

Ornate, tan stone capitol building with a gold dome roof and low-rise city buildings in the background.

States Are Banning Guaranteed Income Programs

Four states now have laws in place that prevent cities and counties from creating or continuing guaranteed income programs, and several more have tried or are trying.

May 23, 2024 - Bloomberg CityLab

Aerial view of Oceanwide Plaza skyscrapers covered with graffiti tags.

LA’s Abandoned Towers Loom as a “$1.2 Billion Ruin of Global Capital”

Oceanwide Plaza, shuttered mid-construction after its developer filed for bankruptcy, has stood vacant on prime Los Angeles real estate since 2019.

May 21, 2024 - The Architect's Newspaper

Close-up of electric stove range with front burners red-hot.

California Cities Suspend Natural Gas Bans Following Court Ruling

A Ninth Circuit court ruling forced Berkeley to reverse its ban on natural gas in new buildings, prompting other cities to suspend their own efforts to promote all-electric buildings.

May 28, 2024 - East Bay Times

BART heavy rail train on elevated track pulling into Concord, CA station with cloudy sky and trees in background.

Bay Area Transit Projects Awarded $18 Million

The funding supports eight ‘near-term’ projects slated for completion within the next one to three years.

2 hours ago - Contra Costa Herald

Silver UTA On Demand transit van in Utah.

Utah On-Demand Transit Hits 1 Million Rides

The service connects outlying communities with fixed-route transit lines.

3 hours ago - Utah Transit Authority

Texas Flood

Texas Flood Plan Shows One in Six Residents Live With Flood Risk

One-fourth of the state’s land falls within 100-year or 500-year floodplains.

4 hours ago - The Texas Tribune

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.