Keep up with essential planning news and commentary, delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.
Homeland Security Advisor Recognizes Effects of Climate Change, Ignores Causes
Thanks to a reporter who asked the obvious but rare question of how climate change relates to two devastating Category 4 hurricanes in less than two weeks, we now know that the Trump administration "is ignoring the underlying causes of climate change while also trying to address, in the aftermath of two intense hurricanes, its potential causes," observed Washington Post energy and environmental policy reporter, Dino Grandoni, who writes The Post's daily analysis, Energy 202.
From Monday's press briefing:
Q. Mr. Bossert, the previous administration saw a connection between climate change and homeland security in that the frequency and intensity of powerful storms, like Harvey and Irma, could pose a problem for future administrations. [...] We know the President pulled out of the Paris Climate Accord. Are these storms giving this administration some pause when it comes to the issue of climate change and homeland security?
A. Causality is something outside of my ability to analyze right now. I will tell you that we continue to take seriously the climate change -- not the cause of it, but the things that we observe. And so there's rising flood waters -- I think one inch every 10 years in Tampa -- things that would require prudent mitigation measures.
Lots to comment on that response by Mr. Bossert.
First, Grandoni called it a "gaffe", which has a special meaning "according to journalist Michael Kinsley, founding editor of Slate: 'A gaffe is when a politician tells .... some obvious truth he isn't supposed to say.'"
Second, Bossert got it wrong on the rising sea level of Tampa Bay, considered to be among the most vulnerable regions to damaging floods in terms of economic damage according to the World Bank. Politifact even analyzed a Sierra Club claim, "Tampa Bay among top 10 regions most threatened by climate change."
The sea in Tampa Bay has risen naturally throughout time, about an inch per decade. But in the early 1990s, scientists say, it accelerated to several inches above normal, so much that recent projections have the bay rising between six inches and more than two feet by the middle of the century and up to nearly seven feet when it ends. On top of that, natural settling is causing land to slowly sink.
Tampa and the region suffered lots of damage from Irma, but it wasn't the nightmare it could have been. Fears updated his July article on Sept. 10, while Irma was ravaging much of the Sunshine State as a Category 3 hurricane, and Tampa Bay was bracing for a hit.
During Monday's press conference, Bossert acknowledged the need to deal with the effects of climate change, indicating that rebuilding efforts need to take increased risks into account:
"... And what I said from the podium the other day and what President Trump remains committed to is making sure federal dollars aren't used to rebuild things that will be in harm's way later or that won't be hardened against the future predictable floods that we see."
Wait a minute! Didn't Planetizen already post that thanks to Trump's executive order last month to roll back an Obama-era regulation, rebuilding won't be better, but "to the same standards that were in place before the floods?"
"We shouldn't use federal money to rebuild in ways that don't anticipate future flood risk, so we need to build back smarter and stronger against flood plain concerns when we use federal dollars," stated Bossert.
He went on to explain that the "White House might put out another executive order or additional guidance that would essentially say the same thing as the order President Obama signed in 2015," adds Thongrit. In other words, thanks to two hurricanes, Trump may rescind his executive order that rolled back the Obama regulation in order to rewrite the Obama regulation.
Bossert did his best to try and justify Trump's actions, but it's clear that Trump was less interested in developing infrastructure and more interested in undoing Obama's efforts, especially the ones that have to do with climate change.
- United States
- Government / Politics
- Tampa Bay
- Climate Adaptation
- Climate Change
- coastal flooding
- Executive Order
- Hurricane Harvey
- Hurricane Irma
- Sea Level Rise
- Trump Administration
- Department of Homeland Security
- Bipartisan Report
- The White House
- World Bank
- Tom Bossert
- Dino Grandoni
- Michael Kinsley
- President Obama
- Natalie Thongrit
- President Donald Trump