A Big Legal Win for the Climate Change Fight in the Golden State

The nation's only state-run cap-and-trade program survived a legal challenge by the California Chamber of Commerce and the libertarian Pacific Legal Foundation when a state court of appeal ruled 2-1 that the program doesn't amount to an illegal tax.

2 minute read

April 10, 2017, 8:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Yosemite

Dan Sedran / Shutterstock

A new era in fighting climate change began in the U.S. on Nov. 14, 2012 when the California Air Resources Board launched the first state-run auction of carbon permits. One day earlier, the California Chamber of Commerce sued CARB over the legality of the program. "The Chamber believes that CARB can only impose regulatory fees on businesses," noted Planetizen at the time.

The first ruling came a year later by Sacramento Superior Court Judge Timothy Frawley who "ruled that the program does not constitute a tax, in part because the ‘license to emit’ does not come for free," reported Allie Goldstein for Ecosystem Marketplace. The ruling on April 6 by two of the three judges of the 3rd District Court of Appeal in Sacramento was along the same lines, reports Chris Megerian, who writes about climate change and California for the Los Angeles Times.

“It is not accurate to liken the auction system to payment for the privilege to stay in business in California,” they wrote Elena J. Duarte and M. Kathleen Butz. “It is a payment for the privilege to pollute the air in California.”

However, cap-and-trade is still in trouble. Carbon sales have remained low since May, and the program, authorized by the landmark Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32) is authorized only to year 2020. While SB 32, signed into law last September by Gov. Jerry Brown, extends the carbon reduction effort an additional decade, it did not include the cap-and-trade program.

Megerian reported in January that AB 151 had been introduced to extend the program. "Gov. Jerry Brown wants a supermajority vote in both houses of the Legislature to safeguard cap-and-trade from legal uncertainty."

Propositions 13 (1978) and 26 (2010) require that taxes and fees, respectively, be passed by the legislature by a two-thirds supermajority.

As for next steps for the current litigation, Megerian writes that "[i]t’s unclear whether the California Chamber of Commerce or the conservative Pacific Legal Foundation, both of which expressed disappointment Thursday, will appeal to the state [Supreme Court]."

Thursday, April 6, 2017 in Los Angeles Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Cover CM Credits, Earn Certificates, Push Your Career Forward

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

July 16, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Blue and silver Amtrak train with vibrant green and yellow foliage in background.

Amtrak Cutting Jobs, Funding to High-Speed Rail

The agency plans to cut 10 percent of its workforce and has confirmed it will not fund new high-speed rail projects.

July 14, 2025 - Smart Cities Dive

Green vintage Chicago streetcar from the 1940s parked at the Illinois Railroad Museum in 1988.

Chicago’s Ghost Rails

Just beneath the surface of the modern city lie the remnants of its expansive early 20th-century streetcar system.

July 13, 2025 - WTTV

Aerial view of viaduct under construction for California High-Speed Rail.

DOT Officially Cancels California High-Speed Rail Funding

The Trump administration has repeatedly taken aim at the LA-to-Bay Area rail project, blaming Democratic leaders for cost overruns and delays.

5 hours ago - Streetsblog California

Orange "Apartments Leasing" sandwich board sign on sidewalk with arrow pointing right.

Legislators Push Back Against ‘Rent-Setting’ Software

In the last six months, lawmakers in more than two dozen cities and states have made strides to stop landlords from using anti-competitive rental software to determine how much to charge for rent. Shelterforce looks at the wins and losses so far.

7 hours ago - Shelterforce Magazine

Orange and black heavy equipment and workers building new asphalt roadway.

DOT Awards 77% of BUILD Grants to Road Projects

Trump’s DOT is directing 87 percent of total grant dollars to states that backed the President in the last election.

July 20 - Streetsblog USA