Reexamining the Origins of Zoning

According to Seymour Toll's 1969 book, New York City's 1916 zoning code was less a civic-minded project than an attempt to protect elite retail districts from the riff-raff. The ramifications for American zoning at large are significant.

2 minute read

July 7, 2016, 2:00 PM PDT

By Philip Rojc @PhilipRojc


New York City Zoning Map

The first American zoning code turns 100 this year. | New York City Planning Commission / New York City Zoning Map

For a short time during the late 1960s, Jake Blumgart writes, "zoning received the attention it deserved as a monumental force shaping the character of many American communities—in large part due to civil rights protests over its exclusionary effects in newer suburbs." Today, renewed debate about urban segregation has cast zoning into the spotlight once again. 

In his 1969 book Zoned American, Seymour Toll gives us "an in-depth history of the 1916 New York code, the progenitor of zoning codes nationwide, and the impetus for its creation. The received history of zoning often frames it as a creation of Progressive-era good government planners. But Zoned American shows that the code was actually created as a weapon to defend the narrow self-interest of a small group of prestigious merchants."  

In a move that presages problematic zoning later in the century, "wealthy retailers based along Fifth Avenue were the advance guard of zoning in New York. Dubbed the Fifth Avenue Association, they believed their investments would be compromised by the northward advance of the garment industry and the hordes of foreign born workers that accompanied it." 

The zoning that emerged from these conditions had specific and recognizable prejudices. It sought to constrain density and height, separating uses to preserve "the northern stretch of Fifth Avenue—and Manhattan more generally—for businesses that catered to the wealthy."

Stephen Smith, well-known as the voice behind @MarketUrbanism on Twitter, remarked, '"There wasn't some grand plan, zoning was taking whatever was there and freezing it [...] Toll convinced me it wasn't really planning, it was just reacting to whatever was already built.'"

Monday, June 27, 2016 in PlanPhilly

"Planetizen federal action tracker" logo superimposed over black and white image of US Capitol dome.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

November 11, 2026 - Zachary Whalen

A highway in Washington state.

Washington state to charge fee to drivers with fuel-efficient cars

Revenue from the fee will go towards supporting the state’s highways.

November 17, 2026 - The Urbanist

A rendering of the proposed computing campus and data center, an aerial shot of three rectangular, gray buildings and smaller square, white ones.

Illinois considers spending $1 billion in taxpayer money on data center

A quantum computing campus and data center are currently under construction in Chicago.

November 17, 2026 - Block Club Chicago

A rendering of the project which shows two bus lanes side by side with a passenger island in the middle of the road

Mamdani unveils his ‘most ambitious bus lane project’ so far

The city has added two new bus lanes, which it expects to speed up tens of thousands of bus riders’ commutes.

November 18 - Gothamist

new Yorker's cross the street next to bus

New Jersey and New York suggest $10.3 billion budget for transit

Some of the budget is dedicated to replacing Manhattan's Midtown Bus Terminal.

November 18 - Future Transport

Aerial view of Kingston power plant in Roane County, Tennessee

States split over EPA’s proposal to drop greenhouse gas rules for power plants

The proposed rule drew over 165K comments, including from officials, health and environmental groups, and private citizens.

November 18 - Stateline

FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?

After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.

Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold

The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.