Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Report: Electric Vehicles Best Option in Most of U.S.

A new Union of Concerned Scientists report shows that due to considerable gains made in cleaning the electric grid and in producing electric vehicles more efficiently, EVs are the environmentally sensible choice.
November 18, 2015, 9am PST | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments
Matej Kastelic

The UCS report, "Cleaner Cars from Cradle to Grave (2015)," considers three variables in its evaluation of lifecycle carbon emissions that includes "vehicle production, operation, and disposal":

  • Regional electricity grids across the United States based on the global warming emissions produced from electricity generation,
  • Emissions generated by charging an EV,
  • Emissions produced by gasoline-powered vehicles.

"Two-thirds of all Americans now live in areas where driving an EV produces fewer climate emissions than almost all comparable gasoline and gasoline hybrid cars—a fact attributable to more efficient EVs and an increasingly clean electricity grid," states the introduction to the report.

The 2012 "State of Charge"report [PDF] is posted here.

To see the fuel efficiency necessary to match that of an EV, find your region on the map below:


Credit: UCS blog: How to Calculate Electric Vehicle Emissions by ZIP Code and Model

The lowest fuel efficiency on the map is in Kansas with 35 mpg. The average fuel efficiency for a new passenger car in the United States is 36 mpg; for a light truck, it's 25.3 mpg, according to the Department of Transportation.

The utilities move away from coal to natural gas and renewables played a critical role in making electric vehicles cleaner. Coal-powered electricity "emits between 1.4 and 3.6 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent per kilowatt hour (lb. CO2e/kWh)," writes USC policy analyst Josh Goldman, policy analyst. "Natural gas, by comparison, emits between 0.6 and 2 lb. CO2e/kWh."

The report accounts for the fact that "BEV [battery electric vehicle] production results in higher emissions than the making of gasoline cars—mostly due to the materials and fabrication of the BEV lithium-ion battery," writes Rachael Nealer in her UCS blog.

For an interesting read on the new report, please see David Roberts' piece in Vox.

A June CityLab article based on a working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research presents a contrary viewpoint (posted here). The report also considers criteria pollutants and rebates given to EVs.

Hat tip: Paul Scott, EVs and Energy

Full Story:
Published on Monday, November 16, 2015 in Union Of Concerned Scientists
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email