Keep up with essential planning news and commentary, delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.
People Still Want Buses, But Buses Aren't Delivering
High-profile transit projects are exciting, but because of their sexiness the dependable and unglamorous city bus may be getting short shrift.
Since the 2008 recession, "Light rail in particular has continued its decade-plus boom, with a service increase of more than 12% in just two years. By contrast, bus service – which already took a heavier hit in the first years of the recession – was cut an additional 5.8%."
Hertz argues that demand for buses has not dropped. In fact, he finds no real correlation between dips in ridership and subsequent service cuts.
The bus decline may have more to do with political demographics: "Even though more people take buses than trains in nearly every metropolitan area in the country, train riders, on average, tend to be wealthier and whiter [...] In other words, rail tends to have a more politically powerful constituency behind it than buses."
"There are serious equity issues with shifting resources from bus to rail – again, not because of anything inherent to those technologies, but simply because of who happens to use them in modern American cities."
For a response to the arguments of Hertz's article, see a Planetizen blog post by Michael Lewyn citing examples of light rail systems that add bus riders, rather than cannibalizing them.