APA Disappointed With Supreme Court's Decision in Takings Case

The decision in Knick v. Township of Scott prompted a response from the American Planning Association.

2 minute read

June 24, 2019, 7:00 AM PDT

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell


Supreme Court Statue

Mark Fischer / flickr

A ruling last week from the U.S. Supreme Court in the case Knick v. Township of Scott inspired national news coverage of the ongoing ideological battle on the highest court in the land, also prompting a statement from the American Planning Association that expressed disappointment with the decision.

"The Supreme Court’s liberal and conservative members clashed again Friday [June 21, 2019] on respecting the court’s precedents, this time about when a property owner aggrieved by a local government’s restriction on her land can go to federal court," reports Robert Barnes for The Washington Post.

The 5-4 decision overturned a ruling from 1985 that the "conservative legal establishment" had targeted for reform because it "left property owners without options in federal court if claims in state proceedings are unsatisfactory."

Barnes mostly focuses on the concern among liberal members of the Supreme Court that this case is another example of willingness of the current court to overthrow precedent. Another article by Arianne de Vogue for CNN also focuses on those dynamics of the Supreme Court after the surprise election of Donald Trump.

The American Planning Association picked up on the planning related consequences of the decision, with a statement published online and shared on social media. The state reads, in part:

The American Planning Association (APA) is disappointed with the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision today in Knick v. Township of Scott. The decision upends established precedent for addressing takings challenges and poses potential obstacles for important local land use decisions that benefit communities.

Here's more on the potential consequences of the decision:

The potential for frivolous takings claims to clog federal courts and push local governments into undermining important protections for health, environment, safety, and quality of life for all residents is a real possibility after today’s decision.

A soundbite from John Baker, chair of APA’s Amicus Curiae Committee, is also included in the statement:

“APA urged the Supreme Court to ... decide the case based on existing legal principles, while at the same time clarifying those principles so as to curb their abuses,” said John Baker, chair of APA’s Amicus Curiae Committee. “Instead, by a single vote, the Supreme Court took a meat-ax approach, explicitly overturning a 7-1 decision from 1985 and trivializing language in the Court’s own decisions dating back over 125 years.”

Friday, June 21, 2019 in American Planning Association

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

View of dense apartment buildings on Seattle waterfront with high-rise buildings in background.

Seattle Legalizes Co-Living

A new state law requires all Washington cities to allow co-living facilities in areas zoned for multifamily housing.

December 1, 2024 - Smart Cities Dive

Times Square in New York City empty during the Covid-19 pandemic.

NYC Officials Announce Broadway Pedestrianization Project

Two blocks of the marquee street will become mostly car-free public spaces.

December 1, 2024 - StreetsBlog NYC

'Vertical canyon' on glass-clad residential high-rise in Denver, CO.

Denver's New High-Rise Integrates Vertical Canyon in Architectural Design

Unlike other new builds in Denver, Colorado, a new high-rise reveals a unique “sculptural canyon” running vertically through the facade to foster a sense of community and connection to nature.  

November 29, 2024 - designboom

Aerial view of small town of Sparta, Wisconsin.

Opinion: Federal Government Must Continue Supporting Rural Housing Program

The incoming Congress will have a say in bolstering — or harming — the only federal housing program focused on affordable housing in rural areas.

December 8 - The Daily Yonder

Chicago sidewalk with brick homes in winter.

Chicago Budget Fails to Include Snow Plowing Program

Disability rights advocates say the “Plow the Sidewalks” program is a necessity for Chicagoans with limited mobility in winter months.

December 8 - Block Club Chicago

Close-up of yellow Pacers Bikeshare e-bike parked outdoors with blurred people in background.

Indy Bike Share Sees Sharp Growth Thanks to Free Pass Program

A new fleet of e-bikes and free access for Marion County residents are getting more people on bikes.

December 8 - Pacers Bikeshare

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.