The Pseudoscientific Foundations of Racist Planning Practices

Racist and colonialist narratives in old geography textbooks help explain the prevalence of segregationist and discriminatory policies and other nasty planning practices. It’s time to understand and reconcile.

6 minute read

March 28, 2023, 5:00 AM PDT

By Todd Litman


Greetings from Denver, Colorado, where I am attending the American Association of Geographers Annual Meeting. Tomorrow, I present a paper titled, “Racism and Colonialism in Geography Textbooks, 1840s to 1950s” (slideshow and full report) which describes how old school textbooks portrayed foreign peoples and cultures, and discusses how they influenced popular beliefs about race, culture, and colonialism.

Old geography textbooks contained racist and colonialist narratives that justified discriminatory and harmful planning practices. Information about this history can help us better understand and correct this ugly legacy.

This research is based on my personal collection of old geography books—I own a few dozen, some more than two centuries old. I find these documents beautiful and fascinating; they are little time machines that show how previous generations perceived the larger world. Geography textbooks introduced children to foreign lands and people. Considered scientific and authoritative, they left a durable legacy on students' worldviews. If previous generations thought about China, Africa, or South America, they probably based their understanding of those places and their peoples on the brief descriptions in their grade school geography books.

My study includes texts and images scanned from these books. You probably would not be surprised to learn that old geography books were overtly racist (they claimed that White races are superior) and colonialist (they claimed that European imperialism was benevolent and beneficial), but it is still shocking to see how systematically they used pseudoscience to categorize non-white races and cultures as violent, immoral, lazy, ignorant, and generally inferior, establishing a foundation for exclusionary and oppressive policies.

Modern Geography, 1850
The title page illustrates the “Stages of Society” which include “savage,” “barbarous,” “half-civilized,” “civilized” and “enlightened.” Since this book was published in Philadelphia, it is unsurprising that it ranks the United States among “enlightened” countries.

Early geography textbooks categorized race and culture using methods modeled after biological taxonomies, giving them a veneer of scientific objectivity. They identified various races (European [White], Asiatic [Yellow], African [Black], Malayan [Brown], and American Indian [Red]), which were categorized according to “stages of society” (savage, barbarous, half-civilized, civilized, and enlightened).

Introductory Geography, 1855

Unsurprisingly, European and North American textbooks ranked Europeans highest and described other races and cultures as intellectually and morally inferior. They also argued that natives benefitted from colonialization and “progressed” to the degree that they adopted Western values and practices. This allowed Whites to feel superior to other peoples and supported colonialist policies.

Here is a typical quote:

“The European or Caucasian is the most noble of the five races of men. It excels all others in learning and the arts, and includes the most powerful nations of ancient and modern times. The most valuable institutions of society, and the most important and useful inventions, have originated with the people of this race.”

Races of Men, 1854
These pages describe the races of men, which include European or Caucasian (White), Asian or Mongolian (Yellow), American Indian (Red), Malay (Brown), and African or Negro (Black). It ranked Europeans as the ‘most noble’ of the five races of men.

These racist messages in authoritative textbooks contributed to a self-reinforcing cycle of racist beliefs, discriminatory policies, segregation and isolation, inferior education and employment opportunities, lower self-esteem, and poor economic outcomes for minority groups, which justified more racist beliefs. 

These descriptions changed over time. Textbooks published from 1900 to 1940 had less overt racial hierarchies but still emphasized the superiority of western institutions and the benefits that colonization provided to natives. Textbooks published after 1940 often provided positive stories about foreign people, cultures, and immigrants, and some encouraged students to critically analyze racism and colonialism. Here is a quote from a 1934 textbook:

“Unthinking people usually believe that that those of other language, religion, and culture are inferior to themselves. We must remember, however, that differences do not imply inferiority. Our thoughts, habits, and beliefs depend upon the accident of birth…From this it does not follow that a person of any given nationality or religion is better or worse than his follow-man of different creed or nationality.”
 

Our Attitudes Toward Strangers, 1934

Many racist textbooks published in the 1940s were probably still in use in the 1960s and affected the beliefs of current generations. Current racial and ethnic discrimination is, to some degree, a legacy of geography textbook lessons that portrayed non-whites as culturally, intellectually, and morally inferior, and therefore dangerous and unproductive.

One specific example is the common practice of building freeways that destroyed minority urban neighborhoods, as described in “Interstate Injustice: Plowing Highways Through Minority Neighborhoods” and Deborah Archer's study “White Men’s Roads Through Black Men’s Homes’: Advancing Racial Equity Through Highway Reconstruction.

It is striking how little respect planners gave to minority neighborhoods. In fact, they often described low-income and minority community as blight to be displaced when possible. For example, a 1978 Transportation Research Board report, Beneficial Effects Associated with Freeway Construction, stated that “Old housing of low quality occupied by poor people often serves as a reason for the destruction of that housing for freeway rights of way.” It claimed that freeways improve safety, environmental quality, economic productivity and aesthetics:

“Blighted or substandard housing, junkyards, dumps, and other sources of ugliness may be eliminated through condemnation, eminent domain, out-right purchase, and other procedures. The effect is a reduction in visual discontinuity to the highway viewer and a possible improvement in the entire visual quality of the affected area and the community.”

Most planners I know are ashamed of such insensitivity. These attitudes and practices caused the destruction of very accessible, multimodal neighborhoods, displacing low-income, minority communities for the benefit of suburban motorists and contributing to a cycle of automobile dependency and sprawl. We now recognize these policies as racist, classist, and harmful, as discussed in the Federal Reserve Bank study, “Freeway Revolts!” We now have an obligation to correct these injustices.

Many professional organizations now have programs to support multiculturalism. For example, the American Anthropological Association’s website, Race: Are We So Different?, critically examines the treatment of race at various times and locations, and provides resources for improving our understanding of race and overcoming prejudices. The American Association of Geographers has a new Justice, Equality, Diversity and Inclusions program, the American Planning Association has an Equity, Diversity and Inclusion program, and many of the papers and posters I’ve seen at this annual meeting address equity and inclusion goals.

Race: Are We so Different?
The American Anthropological Association’s art exhibit and website, Race: Are We So Different?, critically examines the treatment of race at various times and locations, and provides resources for improving our understanding of these issues and overcoming prejudices.

Planners have an important responsibility to better understand the roots of racist, discriminatory policies, their current impacts on our communities, and ways to correct this ugly legacy. We can do better!   

For More Information 

Avril M C Maddrell (1998), “Discourses of Race and Gender and the Comparative Method in Geography School Texts 1830-1918,” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, Vo. 16, pp. 81 103.

Michael Keevak (2011), Introduction No Longer White: The Nineteenth-Century Invention of Yellowness, Princeton University Press.

Todd Litman (2022), “Evaluating Transportation Equity: Guidance for Incorporating Distributional Impacts in Transport Planning,” ITE Journal, Vo. 92/4.

Todd Litman (2023),Racism and Colonialism in Geography Textbooks, 1840s to 1950s (slideshow and full report), Victoria Transport Policy Institute. 

Royal Geographical Society's Race, Culture and Equality Working Group (RACE) promotes anti-racist initiatives.

The Decolonising Geography Educators Group works to decolonise geography curriculum.

Humor resources include the Parody Tests for Anti-Racist and Decolonial Geography School Teaching and Kayonga Kagame Shows Us The World. Episode: Darkest Austria.

Race: Are We So Different?, by the American Anthropological Association.


Todd Litman

Todd Litman is founder and executive director of the Victoria Transport Policy Institute, an independent research organization dedicated to developing innovative solutions to transport problems. His work helps to expand the range of impacts and options considered in transportation decision-making, improve evaluation methods, and make specialized technical concepts accessible to a larger audience. His research is used worldwide in transport planning and policy analysis.

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

Graphic with blue background, flags, and text reading 2024 Presidential Election

Where 2024 Presidential Candidates Stand on 12 Issues Important to Urban Planners

Whether you’re yet undecided or have already cast your early vote, here is a roundup of the key positions of Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump on important urban planning policies.

October 31, 2024 - Planetizen

Modular housing under construction with worker guiding crane.

Commentary: New Bill Holds Key to Solving US Housing Crisis. We Just Have to Pass It.

Two bills currently moving through Congress could make mass production of prefabricated, affordable housing possible on a large scale.

October 29, 2024 - Jordan Rogove

Gaslamp Quarter

America’s 10 ‘Greenest’ Cities

A new analysis ranks cities based on their environmental quality, energy consumption and production, transportation, density, and other factors.

October 28, 2024 - The Street

Group of children with backpacks and bike helmets going to school.

How Seattle Achieved Safe Routes to School Goal

SDOT has installed safety improvements at more than 260 public schools since 2015.

November 7 - Office of Mayor Bruce Harrell

Parked cars in floodwater with two-story apartments or homes in background in Florida after hurricane.

Auto Insurance Rates Spike Due to Extreme Weather

Car insurance costs around the country are going up as insurers receive more claims from areas struck by storms and other climate disasters.

November 7 - Grist

Small mountain lake with snow-capped mountains in background in Eastern Sierra Nevada mountains in California.

California Approves $10 Billion Bond for Water, Clean Energy, and Environmental Projects

Funds will be used to support water, wildfire prevention, environmental, and park projects, reflecting strong public support for climate resilience.

November 7 - Los Angeles Times