Miami Beach: A Four-Foot High Barrier Island Awaited Irma

A city of almost 92,000 people sits on a one-mile wide island designed by nature to protect the mainland from ocean swells, storms, and hurricanes. The seven-mile long island, which floods even when sunny, was spared from catastrophic storm surge.

4 minute read

September 14, 2017, 5:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

Miami Beach

Pietro & Silvia / Flickr

As Hurricane Irma bore down last week, Miami-Dade County Mayor Carlos Gimenez called for a mandatory evacuation of all barrier islands, including Miami Beach, "as well as those living in low-lying areas along the South Miami-Dade coastline," reports Jerry Iannelli for the Miami New Times. The order went into effect on Thursday, September 7.

Barrier islands: no place for development

In the U.S., barrier islands exist from Maine to Florida on the Atlantic coast and Florida to Texas on the Gulf Coast. In Florida, Miami Beach is separated from the Miami-Dade County mainland by Biscayne Bay. On its eastern shore is the Atlantic Ocean.

Map of Miami Beach, FL

Credit: Google maps

Barrier islands serve a critically important ecological purpose by preventing ocean swells and other storm events from disrupting water systems on their mainland sides, protecting the coastline. "As the first line of defense during storms that threaten coastal communities, barrier islands are very important for reducing the devastating effects of wind and waves and for absorbing storm energy," according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) of the U.S. Department of Commerce.

A science webpage is even more to the point: "[B]arrier islands are fragile, constantly changing ecosystems that are important for coastal geology and ecology. Development has posed dangers to these ecosystems and has also increased the risk of property damage every year from hurricanes and Nor'easters."

Given barrier islands' critical protective role, should a city of 92,000 people exist on a mile-wide island "averaging only 4.4 feet (1.3 m) above mean sea level hurricane storm surges "could reach 10 feet?"

Sea level rise

Storm surge is not the only environmental problem facing Miami Beach. According to NASA, sea level rise by the end of the century could "range from 0.2 meters to 2.0 meters (0.66 to 6.6 feet)". In South Florida, it could be as much as "two feet over the next four decades," according to Yale Climate Connections.

A history of flooding and destruction

"In the hundred years since [Miami Beach] was incorporated as a city, it has repeatedly been pummeled by major storms, one of which, the Great Hurricane of 1926, wiped out buildings, tossed ships ashore, and remains, in adjusted dollars, the costliest hurricane in American history," wrote David Kamp for Vanity Fair in December 2015. But even on sunny days, high tides can push water up through storm drains and flood city streets.

Those who monitored Hurricane Irma's South Florida approach may have seen interviews of Miami Beach Mayor Phillip Levine, particularly as he implored residents to leave the island. Levine has spearheaded programs to both mitigate flooding and adapt to climate change, wrote Kamp.

Levine models himself after Michael Bloomberg, New York City's mayor from 2002 to 2013—as a first-time officeholder whose wealth and outsider status allow him to bypass an entrenched political culture of intransigence and inaction. After he took office, in November of 2013, Levine fast-tracked a program to install electric pumps along Alton Road and other prime flooding spots on the city’s west side so that, during a storm surge or high tide, the pumps can be switched on, suctioning water off the streets and out into Biscayne Bay.

See Miami Herald video on the pumps (which have their critics) to reduce flooding and roads which have been raised to adapt to sea level rise. Levine and his staff clarified that the pumps will be useless during Irma's storm surge. Their utility will be proven after the surge subsides.

A December 2015 post also distinguished Levine from the state's other leaders, "like Governor Rick Scott and Senator Marco Rubio, who have both proven staunch in opposing [policy] responses to climate change, and to the large-scale interventions that will be necessary for the region to remain habitable in the future."

Of course, Miami Beach doesn't face the perils of sea level rise alone. Shortly after Hurricane Harvey flooded HoustonOliver Milman, an environment reporter for the Guardian, wrote about how Miami Beach and six other U.S. cities deal with the risk of flooding.

The entire southern section of Florida is at risk from climate change but Miami Beach is eyed with particular concern by other cities. After all, if this wealthy area can't engineer its way out of trouble, where can?

More in Planetizen on South Florida's vulnerability to climate change and sea level rise:

Friday, September 8, 2017 in Planetizen

Green rapid transit bus pulled into station in dedicated lane.

Indiana Once Again Considering Ban on Dedicated Transit Lanes

The proposed legislation would impact the construction of planned IndyGo Blue Line, the third phase of the city’s bus rapid transit system.

February 25, 2024 - Fox 59

View from shore of Sepulveda Basin water catchment basin with marsh plants along shore.

LA’s ‘Spongy’ Infrastructure Captured Almost 9 Billion Gallons of Water

The city is turning away from stormwater management practices that shuttle water to the ocean, building infrastructure that collects and directs it underground instead.

February 25, 2024 - Wired

Aerial view of large homes surrounded by mature trees with Lake MIchigan shoreline at left.

Investors Snapping Up Record-High Number of Affordable Homes

High interest rates and record-high prices are driving investors to focus on homes in the lower price tier, exacerbating inventory shortages and pushing regular home buyers out of the market.

February 25, 2024 - Yahoo Finance

View from between tall white brick buildings in evening in downtown Los Angeles with modern office building across street.

Federal Office Conversion Program Slow to Start

To date, no loans have closed through a federal program meant to spur office-to-residential conversions.

3 hours ago - Bloomberg CityLab

Zebra crosswalk with raised curb extensions and bioswale on small street with parked cars and mature trees.

How Capturing Rainwater Can Make Cities Safer, More Resilient

Green infrastructure can help prevent flooding and replenish groundwater supplies, preventing subsidence that makes land sink.

5 hours ago - Wired

People in hoodies and jackets waiting for oncoming bus at sidewalk bus stop in Boston, Massachusetts.

Boston’s Blue Hill Avenue to Get BRT, Safety Improvements

The key bus corridor serves over 37,000 bus riders daily.

7 hours ago - WBUR

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.