Keep up with essential planning news and commentary, delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.
Less Than the Olympic Ideal
According to an article by Dave Zirin, "the 2016 Summer Olympics in Rio de Janeiro could have been another chapter in this long history of facades for foreign consumption." Instead, "with a dramatic set of crises breaking out across the country, the multibillion-dollar Olympic mirage…is at risk of complete collapse. "
According to Zirin, it's easy provide a list of what's going wrong in the country—from political corruption to budget shortfalls to the public health risks of the Zika virus. Instead of characterizing the problems as "general chaos" and symptoms of the shortcomings of the developing world, Zirin pins the responsibility for the country's troubles on the International Olympic Committee.
We have seen this corruption in city after city that has hosted the games, particularly since 9/11, as spiraling security costs and out-of-control budgets have become central to the games themselves. The names of recent Olympic host cities—Athens, Beijing, London, Sochi—are more likely to conjure images of heavily armed troops; abandoned, rotted-out Olympic stadiums; and multibillion-dollar price tags than anything that happened on the field of play.
But for this year’s Rio Olympics, the corruption is also a function of how Brazil’s elites have always done business, and the crisis has little to do with general problems in the “developing world.” Instead, it is closely connected to the fact that Brazil is an incredibly unequal society, with oligarchical elites who disdain the poor, mourn for a lost military dictatorship, and don’t particularly care for democracy (all attractive traits to the IOC when looking for an Olympic host city).
Zirin reports from Rio de Janeiro, where he met with Mayor Eduardo Paes, to hear his case for the case for the Olympics as a legacy-building success for the country. Zirin replies to that narrative by describing the displacement that has come as a consequence to the Olympic ambition. He visits residents of the Colônia Juliano Moreira public housing project, finding "the voices of the poorest, least empowered people in the city," who Zirin says have "the power to overturn the $11.9 billion apple cart by exposing as a lie the idea that the Olympics are a social good."