Eric Jaffe of CityLab looks at what went wrong with what should have been a clear way to employ technology to reduce crashes and save lives, and what can be done to stem the tide of cities removing red light cameras.
"Generally speaking, red light cameras do an excellent job of reducing 'red-light related' crashes—the highly dangerous T-bone collisions that occur when a driver blows a red once other traffic has entered an intersection," writes Eric Jaffe. So why are they so detested that communities are removing and even banning them?
Jaffe references an incredibly wide array of national news articles, data analysis, and academic, technical, and federal reports from throughout the country. "Houston voters banned the life-saving technology in 2010, with the press mostly cheering (CBS Morning News, Nov. 2012) them along," writes Jaffe.
Last year Houston PD examined how that’s impacted safety at intersections. According to department data [Streetsblog chart (PDF)] their predictions have been borne out.
However, in many cases, meaning at specific intersections in cities throughout the country, e.g., Albuquerque, crashes went down when the cameras were removed. Specifically, "rear end" crashes decreased after the cameras were removed.
Recent academic studies in Charlotte and Los Angeles have found post-camera increases in rear-end collisions. The Chicago Tribune recently conducted its own study of the city’s camera program, and while it did find a 15 percent decline in right-angle crashes, it found a 22 percent rise in rear-end collisions, too.
A 2005 Safety Evaluation of Red-Light Cameras by the Federal Highway Administration supports that finding:
A literature review found that estimates of the safety effect of red-light-running programs vary considerably. The bulk of the results appear to support a conclusion that red light cameras reduce right-angle crashes and could increase rear end crashes.
"That might explain why red light camera programs are on the decline," writes Jaffe. "Down from a reported high of 540 communities with cameras in 2012, only 443 have them today, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
There might be some middle ground to salvage yet. Extending yellow lights, which has been shown to decrease rear-end collisions, might help.
The other complaint Jaffe investigates is alleged corruption, be it messing with length of the yellow lights or unaccountable surges in automated citations. The role of the private contractors has become a central focus for the complaints as Yonah Freemark explained in CityLab in Oct. 2011. Even CALPIRG felt compelled to investigate the role of "privatized traffic law enforcement" (posted here).
But even with the increase in rear end collisions, the cameras show themselves to be a public health benefit. "(T)he lesser severities and generally lower unit costs for rear end injury crashes together ensure that the increase in rear end crash frequency does not negate the decrease in the right-angle crashes targeted by red-light-camera systems," states the FHWA evaluation.
Read the full story: Why Red Light Cameras Have Big Safety Benefits But Little Support
Disabling Red Light Cameras Increases Traffic Fatalities
A new study shows what happens when cities remove red light cameras, which have become targeted by many motorists and eliminated by at least 158 cities. Fatal crashes increased 30 percent compared with area cities that kept the controversial cameras.
Signs of Financial Distress Among Office Properties
The foreclosure risk facing a pair of high-profile office buildings highlight the debt difficulties facing the office sector as it deals with the fallout of the pandemic. The trend could be on the verge of picking up steam.
2020 Population Growth Rates for the 50 Biggest U.S. Cities
The Census Bureau released new data on May 27 that includes the first four months of the pandemic. Seattle tops the growth rate at 2.2% from July 1, 2019, to July 1, 2020, while Baltimore and San Francisco land at the bottom with -1.4%.
Planetizen Federal Action Tracker
A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.
Amtrak, CN end decades-long dispute with eight-year agreement
The new operating agreement establishes an updated framework for the companies to work together, including processes to resolve disputes.
Northwest rail fans eager for Sept. 30 debut of Amtrak’s Airo fleet
Get ready for that new train smell and more seats. But they won’t go faster or run more frequently on the Cascades route in Washington and Oregon.
LAX SkyLink opening delayed again, contractor won’t commit to new deadline
The project was supposed to open its doors to the public in 2023.
Caltrain may slash over one-third of its stations
If Bay Area voters reject two transit tax measures, Caltrain, BART and AC Transit will see steep service cuts.
A 'dangerous' precedent: North Carolina successfully pressures communities into voting for toll roads
Two mayors resigned from the Charlotte Regional Transportation Planning Organization after it voted in favor of the toll roads.
FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?
After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.
Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold
The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.
City of Thousand Oaks
City of Wisconsin Rapids
Harvard University Graduate School of Design
The Architects Foundation
University of Cincinnati Online
The Pocatello Development Authority
The Urban Renewal Agency of the City of Pocatello