How Often Do Cities Mandate Smart Growth?

A recent Mercatus Institute paper addresses the frequency of minimum density regulations, maximum parking requirements, and similar regulations.

3 minute read

October 21, 2014, 2:00 PM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


San Jose Arterial Street

pbk-pg / Shutterstock

I recently coauthored a paper for the Mercatus Institute (a think tank operating out of George Mason University) about the prevalence of regulations designed to promote smart growth and green building—in particular, maximum parking requirements, minimum density requirements, and rules related to LEED certification.

We focused primarily on ascertaining how many cities have actually enacted such regulations; our sample was 24 American cities with populations of between half a million and one million people.  We chose this sample because it is large enough to reflect a reasonably diverse group of cities, yet small enough to be manageable. The sample includes transit-oriented cities like San Francisco and Washington, car-oriented cities like El Paso and Fort Worth, declining older cities like Detroit and Baltimore, and growing cities like Portland and San Jose.

Although critics of smart growth often claim that the smart growth movement seeks to "force" density on Americans, we found that minimum density requirements are in fact quite rare. Only two of our 24 cities (San Jose and Portland) generally require minimum densities for residential zones. Both cities, however, have a wide variety of zones, and have plenty of low-density zones. For example, San Jose has a minimum density in its low-density residential zone—but this minimum density is only one dwelling unit per acre. Because conventional planning wisdom seems to be that at least seven units per acre is necessary for decent bus service, San Jose is hardly mandating smart growth. Similarly, Portland has one zone where the maximum density is one dwelling unit for every two acres; thus, the city's density requirements constrain flexibility more than they mandate smart growth.

Maximum parking requirements are slightly less rare. Only three of the 24 cities (San Francisco, Louisville, and Fort Worth) have maximum parking requirements for every (or almost every use): interestingly, two of them (Louisville and Fort Worth) are car-oriented cities whose maximums are calculated as a percentage of their minimums. For example, Louisville requires 1.5 parking spaces per dwelling unit in most of its residential zones, and its parking cap is three spaces per unit—a lot of parking. Limited parking caps are more common: seven cities have imposed parking maxima for some or all commercial uses, and five for specified parts of a city (usually near downtown or near transit stations).

In addition, we also discussed rules requiring "green" (that is, energy-conserving) building design. Only four cities (San Francisco, Austin, Boston, and San Jose) require developers to meet LEED or similar green building guidelines—and in all but San Francisco, these rules are limited to larger projects. However, many other cities provide a variety of incentives for green building.

What about the wisdom of these rules? Because these regulations are often either new or not particularly controversial, we did not find very much information about the real-world side effects of these rules. All of these regulations are likely to have some positive results: for example, a smaller amount of parking may lead to less driving and thus to less pollution, while more compact development might lead to higher transit ridership as more people located near bus and train stops. 

On the other hand, any regulation could, in theory, burden building enough to deter development: for example, if builder X decides that there is not enough market demand to justify building at minimum density Y, X might decide to build housing in more permissive suburbs. Similarly, if X cannot afford the short-term expense of green building features or thinks tenants will want more parking than a city allows, it may move to suburbia. But whether any of these negative effects has actually occurred may require additional research.


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

"Planetizen federal action tracker" logo superimposed over black and white image of US Capitol dome.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

November 11, 2026 - Zachary Whalen

A highway in Washington state.

Washington state to charge fee to drivers with fuel-efficient cars

Revenue from the fee will go towards supporting the state’s highways.

November 17, 2026 - The Urbanist

A rendering of the proposed computing campus and data center, an aerial shot of three rectangular, gray buildings and smaller square, white ones.

Illinois considers spending $1 billion in taxpayer money on data center

A quantum computing campus and data center are currently under construction in Chicago.

November 17, 2026 - Block Club Chicago

The capitol building at sunset.

Senate passes bill overhauling permitting

The bill still needs to pass the House.

6 hours ago - CBS

A data center near the water billows smoke into a clear blue sky.

Did data centers change how voters cast their ballots?

Texas, Ohio, and Georgia all flipped party control. But in rural counties, the effect of local data centers was mixed.

November 20 - The Daily Yonder

An Airo transit driving behind a lake and in front of a dark forest.

Amtrak invests in eight new Airo trainsets

The new trainsets will begin serving passengers in 2031.

November 20 - Mass Transit

FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?

After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.

Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold

The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.

Write for Planetizen