New York City BIDs Have Indifferent Impacts on Economic Growth

"Rather than serving as a buffer against economic decline for independent retailers, it seems that Community BIDs are a hindrance to sales and employment growth..." writes Dr. Stacey Sutton in the Journal of Planning Education & Research.

3 minute read

September 24, 2014, 5:00 AM PDT

By JPER


New York City Greenwich

cwillbounds / Flickr

After the large scale abandonment of central cities in the 1950s-1970s, many urban municipalities lacked both vibrancy in their commercial districts and resources to reinvest in better urban infrastructure and security. Business Improvement Districts (BIDs) emerged as a strategy to help stem the decline of these districts by using special self-taxation powers to finance street upgrading, beautification, and increased security, among other industry-driven services. However, given the costs to businesses from the additional tax burden in BIDs, it is only natural to ask if they are justified by their benefits in terms of economic development.

In a recent article in the Journal of Planning Education and Research, "Are BIDs Good for Business? The Impact of BIDs on Neighborhood Retailers in New York City," Columbia University's Stacey Sutton asks just this question for the United States' largest city (Click the link for Open Access). The study differentiates large scale corporate BIDs, like the one which exists in Times Square, with Destination Bids, existing on important commercial corridors, and smaller Community BIDs, which cover neighborhood level retail corridors. Community BIDs are smaller and “...focus on district maintenance, upkeep, and retention of existing businesses rather than capital improvements or even security...,” (Sutton 2014) which are stalwart elements of larger BIDs. The Community BIDs grew rapidly in number during the 2000s, and these, along with the mid-size Destination BIDs are the focus of Sutton's study.

NYC Business Improvement Districts Formed Between 2002-2012 (Sutton 2014)

Sutton uses statistical matching techniques to compare the performance of NYC BIDs formed between 2002 and 2008 to other similar areas of the city that had not established BIDs. Matching is like a quasi-experiment. It allows a researcher to evaluate a policy intervention by comparing observed outcomes to what we might expect had the policy not been implanted. Here, Sutton used “retail firm, neighborhood, and building attributes” prior to BID formation as primary criteria for creating matched pairs. The idea is that the propensity score matching method will incorporate the most important observable factors related to retail firm performance, and create a balanced set of control districts to compare with those that entered BIDS pre-and-post creation.

NYC Business Improvement Districts with Their Matched Control Tracts (Sutton 2014)

The economic development outcomes that Sutton tested included employment growth and the rate of change of retail sales as measured in the National Establishment Time Series data set. Sutton found that BIDs are more likely to be established in areas “with higher retail density, assessed property values, dense population, and college-educated residents”. BIDs are less prevalent higher income areas, and in areas with large White or foreign born populations.

Somewhat surprisingly, Sutton found that when examining neighborhood retail, sales and employment both declined in small Community BIDs versus the matched non-BID areas, but larger Destination BIDs perform better than comparable areas of the city. This may have been because small BIDs tend to attract small independent retailers, who on average have lower sales volumes and employment than do larger retailers, and they are more susceptible to broader economic shifts. The effects of medium-size BIDs was different. In these larger retail corridors employment and sales increased. This may have to do with the fact that these areas tend to attract large and more stable businesses able to pay higher rents. Sutton concludes that BIDs may not always be the best policy for areas with significant levels of independent retail.

The study also finds that in areas of the city with greater growth in independent businesses, both sales and employment decline significantly. All of this suggests that policy makers should tread lightly when promoting BIDs as a solution for urban economic development, especially in areas of significant independent retail presence.

Full text of the Sutton article is available here in HTML format and here in PDF format until October 25, 2014. 

Blog Post by Thomas Douthat and Dr. Stacey Sutton

Follow JPER on Twitter @JPER7.


JPER

In this new series, Journal of Planning Education and Research (JPER) articles will be made available to Planetizen readers subscription free for 30 days. This is possible through collaboration between SAGE Publications and the Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning. JPER is currently edited by Clinton Andrews and Frank Popper of the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy at Rutgers University. The managing editor is Karen Lowrie ([email protected]).

Follow JPER on Twitter: @JPER7

Large blank mall building with only two cars in large parking lot.

Pennsylvania Mall Conversion Bill Passes House

If passed, the bill would promote the adaptive reuse of defunct commercial buildings.

April 18, 2024 - Central Penn Business Journal

Aerial view of Oakland, California with bay in background

California Exodus: Population Drops Below 39 Million

Never mind the 40 million that demographers predicted the Golden State would reach by 2018. The state's population dipped below 39 million to 38.965 million last July, according to Census data released in March, the lowest since 2015.

April 11, 2024 - Los Angeles Times

A view straight down LaSalle Street, lined by high-rise buildings with an El line running horizontally over the street.

Chicago to Turn High-Rise Offices into Housing

Four commercial buildings in the Chicago Loop have been approved for redevelopment into housing in a bid to revitalize the city’s downtown post-pandemic.

April 10, 2024 - Chicago Construction News

Aerial view of downtown Seattle, Washington at dusk.

Seattle Downtown Plan Expands Permitted Uses

The Downtown Activation Plan shifts from Euclidean to form-based zoning to encourage more commercial development.

1 hour ago - Governing

Large water pipe with brown water pouring out into dirt ditch.

Southern Water Infrastructure at Risk From Climate Impacts

A water main breaks somewhere in the United States every two minutes, according to an estimate from the American Society of Civil Engineers.

3 hours ago - The Conversation

People gather on a street with no cars during the L.E.A.F. Festival of Flowers in the Meatpacking District of New York City.

NYC Open Streets Program Faces Lawsuit

A group of residents is charging the city with violating accessibility requirements by blocking vehicular traffic on some blocks.

5 hours ago - StreetsBlog NYC

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.