Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Head-On Commuter Train Collision Leaves 10 Dead in Germany

The two trains were traveling on a single track in Bavaria, each going around a bend at about 62 mph so they were not visible to the engineers. The trains were equipped with automatic braking systems reported to have been deactivated.
February 12, 2016, 7am PST | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

"Media reports said human error was to blame for the high-speed crash near the southern spa town of Bad Aibling, where one of the trains sliced into the other, ripping a hole in its side," writes Ralf Isermann for Agence France‑Presse (AFP). They crashed at 7 am on Feb. 9.

One media source "said a signalling station worker had manually disactivated [sic] the automatic signalling system to let the first train -- which was running late -- go past." Another source "said manually disabling the signalling would have disactivated the automatic braking systems."

The trains were operated by the Bavarian rail company Bayerische Oberlandbahn GmbH (BOB), "a private railway company based in Holzkirchen, Germany, and owned by Transdev Germany (formerly Veolia Verkehr)," per Wikipedia. Veolia, now Transdev, is a major private transportation contractor in the U.S as well as internationally, operating systems such as San Diego's Sprinter diesel light rail system and Stanford University's Marguerite Shuttle service.

After German rail was liberalised at the end of the 1990s, BOB became one of the train operators competing with state-run Deutsche Bahn.

Although it has lost its monopoly operating status, Deutsche Bahn still owns the rail network.

More will be known about the cause, whether human error or a technical malfunction is to blame, after the trains' black boxes have been analyzed. Two of the three have been recovered. Both engineers and two conductors were among the fatalities.

Police chief for the Upper Bavaria region, Robert Kopp, said the trains were carrying about 150 passengers, fewer than on a regular work day as many people were off for the region's winter holidays.

The crash "rais(es) new questions about the safety and reliability of a rail network in Europe that has been the envy of much of the world," writes Melissa Eddy for The New York Times. But "crashes across Europe in recent years have highlighted weaknesses in the rail network."

Many countries in the region have abandoned government-run monopolies in favor of privately-run rail systems, even as the European Union is spending billions of euros to modernize rail networks.

The result is an increasingly precarious system, with a patchwork of old and new technologies in use at the same time, and with drivers, who are often alone in cars, shouldering more responsibility for safety.

In Germany, the most serious accident since unification was in 1998, when 101 people died in the northern town of Eschede after a high-speed train derailed, crashing into a bridge. Fatal crashes since then have been rare and on a much smaller scale.

"The accident is believed to be Germany's first fatal train crash since April 2012, when three people were killed and 13 injured in a collision between two regional trains in the western city of Offenbach," writes AFP's Ralf.

In the United States, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is still investigating the cause of the May 10, 2015 Amtrak Northeast Regional train derailment in Philadelphia that killed eight passengers. 

Full Story:
Published on Tuesday, February 9, 2016 in AFP
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email