The Real Story Behind the Death of Streetcars in the United States

Yes, there was a conspiracy led by General Motors to replace streetcars with their buses in the 1930s. But streetcars were dying well before then, due to competition with the automobile and other reasons apart from nefarious corporate collusions.

3 minute read

May 12, 2015, 2:00 PM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

D.C. Streetcar

rockcreek / Flickr

Joseph Stromberg of Vox provides yet another reminder that the convenient scapegoat for the death of public transit in the United States can not be laid at the doorsteps of General Motors. [If you haven't read Stephen Smith's 2010 article iMarket Urbanism about the conspiracy and how it is misinterpreted by some in the planning profession today, it's summarized and linked here.]

"There's this widespread conspiracy theory that the streetcars were bought up by a company National City Lines, which was effectively controlled by GM, so that they could be torn up and converted into bus lines," says Peter Norton, a historian at the University of Virginia and author of Fighting Traffic: The Dawn of the Motor Age in the American City.

But that's not actually the full story, he says. "By the time National City Lines was buying up these streetcar companies, they were already in bankruptcy."

For the record, there was a conspiracy according to the 1949 U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in UNITED STATES v. NATIONAL CITY LINES, Inc., et al. But can General Motors, as well as Firestone Tire, Standard Oil of California, Phillips Petroleum, and Mack Trucks (the other companies found guilty in the lawsuit) be blamed for tearing up almost 17,000 miles of streetcar tracks?

"The real reasons for the streetcar's demise are much less nefarious than a GM-driven conspiracy — they include gridlock and city rules that kept fares artificially low — but they're fascinating in their own right, and if you're a transit fan, they're even more frustrating," writes Stromberg. I would add that if you're a transportation planner and/or advocate, it's even more reason to get the story straight as those problems apply to some degree today, as posted here and here.

The real problem was that once cars appeared on the road, they could drive on streetcar tracks — and the streetcars could no longer operate efficiently. "Once just 10 percent or so of people were driving, the tracks were so crowded that [the streetcars] weren't making their schedules," Norton says.

While it's true that National City continued ripping up lines and replacing them with buses — and that, long-term, GM benefited from the decline of mass transit — it's very hard to argue that National City killed the streetcar on its own. Streetcar systems went bankrupt and were dismantled in virtually every metro area in the United States, and National City was only involved in about 10 percent of cases.

"The Los Angeles Streetcar system developed into the largest trolley system in the world by the 1920’s," according to Los Angeles Streetcar, Inc. Stromberg cites Cecilia Rasmussen at the Los Angeles Times, who wrote in 2003, "With 160,000 cars cramming onto Los Angeles streets in the 1920s, mass-transit riders complained of massive traffic jams and hour long delays." Rasmussen also describes the 1988 animated comedy that become associated with the plot:

"Who Framed Roger Rabbit" [YouTube] became to traffic planning what "Chinatown" was to Los Angeles water politics -- but with more laughs.

Although it's tempting to believe that evil forces must have been to blame, most historians agree that GM and the other mega-companies only helped to speed the end of the railway, which already was deep into red ink. There were mixed court verdicts, with fines levied that were considered a drop in the bucket.

CityLab's Eric Jaffe in 2013 provided an equally good recount of what caused the death of the American streetcar, including the 1974 testimony of former antitrust attorney for the United States Senate, Bradford C. Snell, which "introduced the scandal theory to a wider public."

Hat tip to Angie Schmitt of Streetsblog USA.

Thursday, May 7, 2015 in Vox

Aerial view of homes on beach in Maui, Hawaii

Hawaii Passes First Legislation Regulating Short-Term Rentals Statewide

The new law will give counties the power to limit number or short-term rentals and convert existing short-term rental units back into long-term residential housing.

May 13, 2024 - USA Today

Google office building in Virginia.

Virginia Data Centers Draining State’s Water Supply

Being the world’s largest data center hub is having a severe impact on local water resources.

May 9, 2024 - Grist

Entrance to a drive-through car wash at night with green 'Enter' sign.

Ohio Towns Move to Ban New Car Washes

City officials in northeast Ohio are putting limits on how many car wash facilities can open in their towns.

May 16, 2024 - News 5 Cleveland

Grand Coulee Dam in Washington state.

Northwest Power Demand Could Surge as Data Centers, Transportation Electrification Ramps Up

New estimates project a steady increase in electricity demand due to population growth, data centers, and the shift to electric power in homes, buildings, and transportation.

May 17 - Governing

Blurred traffic speeding by on freeway with Los Angeles skyline in background.

California Testing Per-Mile Gas Tax Alternatives

A summer pilot program will test the fairness and efficacy of collection mechanisms for mileage-based fee options.

May 17 - Newsweek

Close-up of 'Pay rent' note in red marker on day 1 of monthly calendar.

After Months of Decreases, Rents Nationwide Are Going Up

Average rents rose by $12 around the country so far this year.

May 17 - Smart Cities Dive

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.