Commuter Taxes: An Untapped Revenue Source?

For all those cities that double population during the work day, here's a revenue thought to consider. But why restrict it to in-bound commuters? What about residents who commute-out of the city? Is the commuter tax a legitimate revenue source?
March 26, 2014, 5am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

While "New York City’s commuter tax expired more than a decade ago, political arguments for its revival continue to persist, as recently as last year’s mayoral election," writes Mike Maciag, data editor for Governing. But this revenue option is not limited to big cities.

"Last week, officials in Johnstown, Pa., which participates in a state program for distressed cities, told a panel of judges that they either needed to implement a commuter tax or scale back services. In Indiana, state legislators are mulling their own commuter tax for counties."

However, cities with the highest percentages of nonresident commuters in their workforce may not be what you think they are. See quiz questions below.

And the commuter tax need not be restricted to the conventional commuter. There could also be a "reverse commuter tax". Distressed areas could consider a related revenue stream for their residents who commute the opposite direction.

Buried deep in Detroit Emergency Manger Kevyn Orr’s restructuring plan released last month was a single line that caught the attention of one group of taxpayers. For the first time, the city publicly stated it was weighing an ordinance requiring employers to withhold city income taxes for reverse commuters.

So job-rich areas might tax non-residents who commute in, and job-poor cities could tax residents who commute out. However, it's the conventional commute tax that is considered the most "as property tax bases dwindle," writes Maciag. "Taken together, these two groups of taxpayers represent a largely untapped source of potential revenue that cities may begin to target more aggressively, particularly if they’re struggling."

Readers might wish to view "Governing's compiled data published for the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey to compute localities’ estimated nonresident workers. Across all cities with at least 50,000 workers, nonresidents accounted for slightly more than half – 52 percent – of the total workforce."

However, note that areas need not be incorportated, as is the case for the one in Fairfax County, Virginia, population 19,627, with the highest percentage of nonresident workers: 91.6%.  Guesses anyone?

And here's a surprise - for me, anyway. Guess which cities in New York State had the highest and the lowest percentages of nonresidents in their workforce?

  1. White Plains
  2. Albany
  3. Rochester
  4. Syracuse
  5. Buffalo
  6. Yonkers
  7. New York

(Answer: It's numbered in descending order. New York City had 21.5%; White Plains, 81.2%)

Full Story:
Published on Wednesday, March 5, 2014 in Governing
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email