White Roofs Can Be Wrong Roofs

"By having information on the different roof choices, building owners can choose the roof that is best for their location and climate, and that best solution isn't always white.

The Cool Roof Rating Council admits to a "winter penalty" when cool roofs are installed in northern climates. An article in the April edition of Maintenance Solutions magazine that was penned by the CRRC states, "Heating costs may increase slightly for buildings located in cooler regions." CRRC's justification for increasing heating costs and greenhouse gasses was that days (sunlight hours) are longer in the summer than they are in the winter, thus more energy is consumed to cool a building than to heat it.

The article failed to mention spring and autumn. However, information gathered from the U.S. Department of Energy clearly demonstrates that heating is a much more significant factor in energy usage than cooling. For instance, Grand Rapids, Mich., has 7,153 heating degree days versus 508 cooling degree days per year, which means heating equipment runs approximately 14.3 hours for every one hour that cooling equipment runs."

"...To illustrate this point, I've chosen three major U.S. cities and provided analyses of energy and carbon footprint models, all generated using the DOE's cool-roof calculator, to help lend some clarification and hopefully dispel some growing cool-roof myths.

• Boston, Mass.: 5,841 HDD versus 646 CDD

• Grand Rapids, Mich.: 7,153 HDD versus 508 CDD

• Albuquerque, N.M.: 4,361 HDD versus 1,211 CDD

Due to the overwhelming amount of heating degree days and positive winter heat gain in these locations, in all instances, energy consumption and carbon emissions are fewer with a dark roof surface than with a reflective surface. This is true even as far south as Albuquerque. It is also important to note that increased insulation dramatically reduces energy consumption in every model."