Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

The Pandemic's New Epicenter

On May 22, the World Health Organization declared Latin America the new epicenter of the coronavirus pandemic. Brazil is second in the world in reported cases after the U.S., and Ecuador, Peru, Chile, and Mexico are also suffering disproportionately.
June 10, 2020, 11am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments
Andre Luiz Moreira

The coronavirus arrived late to South America, giving the continent time to prepare so as to avoid the outbreaks seen in Europe and North America. "Jarbas Barbosa da Silva Jr., the assistant director of the Latin American office of the World Health Organization [the Pan American Health Organization], flew throughout the region this year to meet with health ministries," reports Terrence McCoyThe Washington Post's Brazil correspondent.

In early March, Barbosa said every country was making plans. Cases were then very low — not a single instance of community transmission had been registered in Latin America — but everyone appeared to be taking the disease seriously.

In addition to time, the region had an advantage similar to the East Asian success storiesit had dealt with infectious disease recently: the 2015–2016 Zika virus epidemic. Countries took the threat serious and imposed restrictions.

Chile issued a 90-day national emergency declaration within days of its first cases, restricting freedom of movement and banning public gatherings. Argentina closed its borders. In Peru, President Martín Vizcarra imposed perhaps the strictest measures in the region, allowing people to leave their homes only to buy food and medicine.

But despite the diversity in approaches — from the draconian in Peru to the laissez-faire in Brazil — many countries are ending up in roughly the same place: watching cases surge, with little political or institutional capacity to flatten their ascent.

Favelas not conducive to social distancing

McCoy blames the failure on factors related to urban poverty plus related woes including "inequality, corruption, and plunging faith in institutions."

How it got to this point has been a case study in the difficulties of controlling a pandemic in the developing world. Policies such as social distancing and isolation — which must be maintained for weeks to have any effect — have proved simply untenable in countries where many people live crowded in urban slums [favelas] and must work every day to survive.

The projections for Brazil, which has the third-highest deaths after the U.S. and the U.K, are grim.

The Pan American Health Organization last week urged a recommitment to social distancing in Brazil to avert a calamity. Its projections showed that 88,000 people could die by August. Researchers at the University of Washington put their death toll still higher — around 125,000 by August.

The IHME model now projects nearly 166,000 deaths in Brazil by August 4. President Jair Bolsonaro has undermined the nation's response, scoffing at the need for social distancing, and, somewhat like President Trump, dismissing COVID-19 as a "little flu."

South America coronavirus dashboard

In deaths per capita, Ecuador, Brazil, Peru, and Chile, respectively, have the highest mortality, according to WorldometerOn June 7, more people died from COVID-19 in Chile than anywhere else in the world, with 649, followed by Brazil and the U.S.  On June 8, Brazil was highest, with 813, followed by the U.S., India and Mexico.

Multi-media:

  • NPR reported on the dire situation in Brazil and other Latin American countries in a 6-minute broadcast (with transcript) on June 3.
Full Story:
Published on Wednesday, June 3, 2020 in The Washington Post
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email